A.19.DECLARED-SUBSTRATE-INTERPRETIVE-VIEW:7 - Conformance Checklist
Apply these checks to the interpretation and claims actually made.
| ID | Check question | Fail when | Repair or governing pattern |
|---|---|---|---|
CC-A19IV-1 | Is one already-declared base substrate or source-set entry point or set-result entry point named explicitly? | The interpretive view floats free of the line it is supposed to help read. | Cite the base substrate or the recoverable source-set entry point or set-result entry point. |
CC-A19IV-2 | When formal viewing is claimed, are the A.6.3 source and receiving epistemes recoverable, and is E.17.0 viewpoint conformance established separately for a U.View claim? | A pattern citation is treated as sufficient to establish either relation. | Recover the exact epistemes and viewing transformation; test the named viewpoint only when U.View qualification is needed. |
CC-A19IV-3 | Does the line preserve the same EntityOfConcern and keep the base substrate as semantic center? | The interpretive prose retargets the EntityOfConcern or repairs the substrate in place. | Reopen under A.19.SOURCE-SET-SPACE-SUBSTRATE, A.6.4, or the appropriate neighboring pattern. |
CC-A19IV-4 | Are the current source set, any active set result, and any active derived view or base palette recoverable? | The interpretive reading hides the base palette, base source/result, or active derived set result behind one fuller visible overlay. | Restore the missing recoverability fields. |
CC-A19IV-5 | Is the active profile chosen honestly: thin interpretation or atlas interpretation? | Atlas language is used by reflex, or the line needs atlas interpretation but never says so. | State the profile and the inspection question it answers; explain the composite need when choosing atlas form. |
CC-A19IV-6 | If atlas form is active, is the composite atlas-form interpretation declaration complete? | A source set/result, declared view, space, map reference, qualification, or connection needed to answer the composite inspection question remains hidden. | Supply the missing content needed by the inspection question; use thin interpretation only if it gives an adequate answer. |
CC-A19IV-7 | Is each qualification attached to the relation it qualifies? | A view qualification silently changes the source-to-outcome relation, or a material substrate qualification disappears. | Preserve substrate qualifications; state any view-only loss separately. Revise the substrate if its underlying relation changes. |
CC-A19IV-8 | If TraditionAtlasView is used, is it kept as one G.2 specialization rather than the common family head? | The local specialization is treated as if every interpretive case were already palette-first atlas work. | Restore the split between DeclaredSubstrateAtlasView and TraditionAtlasView. |
CC-A19IV-9 | Does the line stay out of publication and policy work? | The prose starts deciding who survives, what is published, or what is shipped. | Separate the interpretation from the remaining decision and apply the corresponding pattern in §4.10. |
CC-A19IV-10 | Could a cold reader choose thin interpretation versus atlas interpretation and fill one interpretive view declaration without hidden invention? | The reader still needs surrounding memo knowledge to know which head to use, what fields matter, or why atlas is or is not needed. | Use the content requirements in §4.2 and sequence in §4.5; show the composite inspection need if atlas form is necessary. |
CC-A19IV-11 | Is the inspection question explicit enough to tell the reader what this view helps inspect now? | The view mostly restates the base theory, but the practical inspection load stays unnamed. | State the inspection question directly and keep the base line recoverable beside it. |
CC-A19IV-12 | When specialization, naming repair, publication, or policy becomes the next question, is the governing neighbor explicit? | The prose answers a specialization, naming, publication or policy question as if it were part of the interpretation. | Split the line and cite the governing neighbor instead of stretching interpretive-view prose across that boundary. |