A.19.SOURCE-SET-SPACE-SUBSTRATE:7 - Conformance Checklist
Apply these declaration checks to the claims and qualifiers used:
| ID | Check question | Fail when | Repair or governing pattern |
|---|---|---|---|
CC-A19SS-1 | Is the line declaring one substrate-bearing relation rather than only CharacteristicSpace, publication metadata, or policy? | The line only names a space object, or only publishes, ships, or retains something, with no explicit source, ref, relation, or posture stack. | Move to A.19, G.5, G.10, C.19, or C.24 as appropriate. |
CC-A19SS-2 | Is the source basis recoverable for the case? | A contributing set, its family or its member contribution rule is ambiguous, or a primary source is invented for a composition that distinguishes none. | Recover each set identity and family and any composition under §4.7; use refs or accessible defining sources as needed. |
CC-A19SS-3 | Do SearchSpaceRef and OutcomeSpaceRef both resolve to declared A.19 CharacteristicSpace, and is SpaceRefRelationKind explicit? | One or both refs are vague, or the line leaves the same-space versus cross-space question to inference. | Restore the two refs and declare sameDeclaredSpaceAs or distinctDeclaredSpaceFrom. |
CC-A19SS-4 | Is the source-to-outcome relation explicit in its participants, direction, mode and defining basis? | The relation remains hidden in an umbrella phrase with no recoverable map, model, operation or rule. | State the participants, direction, mode and defining basis or cite where they can be recovered. |
CC-A19SS-5 | Are the relevant qualifications explicit and supported for the claimed use? | Material limits are missing, or different qualified cases are blurred into one generic loss story. | State the qualifications and the basis needed by that use. If needed support is missing, retain the established content and withhold only the dependent conclusion; a primary token is required only by a selected interface. |
CC-A19SS-6 | Are conditional and qualifier fields used only when they do work? | Composition, derivation, base-palette, declared map ref, metric, transition, or bridge qualifiers are fabricated everywhere or silently become core. | Remove unused qualifiers; keep only the fields the case depends on. |
CC-A19SS-7 | If DescriptorMapRef or DistanceDefRef is active, does the text say they realize or qualify the relation rather than replace the space ref? | The representation or metric layer is treated as if it were the declared search-side or outcome-side space. | Re-state the docking rule and keep the two space refs visible. |
CC-A19SS-8 | Does the line stay out of publication and policy work? | The prose starts deciding shortlist identity, selector outcome, shipping closure, or live-pool/enactment policy. | Split the line and move those downstream decisions to their governing patterns. |
CC-A19SS-9 | Can the account establish the substrate claim needed by the use without inventing facts? | A required source identity, space resolution, relation or material qualification remains unsupported. | Return the recovered components and the missing basis; withhold the complete claim and only uses that depend on that gap. |
CC-A19SS-10 | Could a cold reader take the next declaration step from this line without surrounding memo help? | The line still speaks only in umbrella words such as space, projection, or portfolio, and the reader cannot tell what to fill next. | Use the declaration sequence in §4.5 and recover the needed content from §4.2 before reuse. |
CC-A19SS-11 | When the next question is interpretive-view, publication, or policy, is the next governing pattern explicit? | The text keeps talking as if substrate, interpretation, publication, and policy were one layer, so the reader cannot tell where to continue. | Split the line and cite A.19.DECLARED-SUBSTRATE-INTERPRETIVE-VIEW, G.5, G.10, C.19, or C.24 as the next governing pattern. |
CC-A19SS-12 | Does the use claim only the breadth its declared posture and qualifiers license? | The prose implies universal geometric closure or one universal heavy-qualification story, but the declared posture or qualifiers stay narrower, uncertain, learned/adaptive, or case-bound. | Narrow the claim or add the missing posture/interpretive qualifiers that make the broader claim honest. |