Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-16 21:18:08 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-16 21:19:40 UTC · last check 2026-11-17 19:45:20 UTC

A.19.SelectorMechanism:0 - At a glance — didactic, informative

  • What it is: a universal set-returning selection kernel: it takes candidates, admissible comparison outcomes, and explicit criteria, and returns a selected set, not a forced single winner.
  • Why it exists: to prevent three recurring failure modes: hidden thresholds, silent scalarization, and winner‑take‑all defaults under partial orders and uncertain evidence.
  • Use this when: admitted candidates must be selected under explicit criteria after comparison. Identify the candidate universe and choice rule, recover the required comparisons and their conditions, then return the justified subset. Stop with comparison when the receiving question needs no selection; a selection result alone supplies no authorization to act.
  • What this buys: the practitioner gets one selected-set value whose criteria, finite basis of upstream binary CPM applications, required comparison coverage, token provenance, scope, any governing A.19 predicate, plane, window, and policy bindings are explicit. degrade and abstain remain eligibility values, not selected-set members or alternative result kinds.
  • First output: read the by-value candidate set bound to SelectionSlot. Read the candidate universe, finite upstream CPM application basis, required pair coverage, derived comparison-token union, selection conditions, claim scope and context slices, reference plane, evaluation window, eligibility value, and evidence use from the Select application and neighboring relations; they are not fields inside the selected set.
  • How it evolves: method semantics and SoTA algorithm families connect via G.2 packs and wiring modules; the kernel signature stays stable and teachable.
  • Suite stage: select (ordering lives only in A.19.CHR:4.5 and suite_protocols; suite membership is a set in A.19.CHR:4.2).
  • Inputs (conceptual): admitted candidates; a finite by-value basis of upstream binary CPM applications, each with its pair, realized GuardDecision, and own ComparisonResultSlot binding when produced; the union of justified relation or poset tokens from those bindings; explicit CriteriaSlot, CNSpecSlot, CGSpecSlot; one U.ClaimScope with selected A.2.6 U.ContextSlice members; the same A.19 predicate basis when one governs the comparisons or selection criteria; effective reference plane; explicit evaluation window; and optional TaskSignature and MinimalEvidence policy refs.
  • Output (conceptual): the by-value SelectionSlot candidate set. A singleton is allowed when the explicit criteria determine one candidate; a total order supplies comparison information but needs a choice rule. The output is not a decision log, guard value, result episteme, generic result relation, publication, or replay record.
  • Planned use: on a P2W path, an A.15.2 baseline selects editions and policies. A.15.3 and SlotFillingsPlanItem apply only to independently declared receiving positions under A.19.CHR:4.7.2. The Select application carries its effective arguments and SelectionSlot binding under §4.1. Dated selection Work and an A.10 provenance account retain their independent grounds.
  • Transformation-flow use: when selection is represented by an E.18 node, that node cites this declaration. Planned refs use A.15.3 typed filling only for independently declared receiving positions; Select bindings remain governed by §4.1.
  • Failure mode: tri‑state guard (pass|degrade|abstain); missing or unknown evidence never coerces to pass.
  • Mental model: SelectEligibility gates the step; Select applies explicit criteria to set‑valued comparison outcomes; the result is a selected set whose “single winner” behavior must be explicit.