B.5.MR:4.3 - Locate levels of model abstraction in an application chain
A level of model abstraction is a relative position under the comparison in section 4.2. When the inquiry concerns which applications are eligible, a chain may leave open or determine the interpretation of a formal construction, the discipline, the local conditions and the individual. Five useful names locate these possible restrictions.
| Position | What can be fixed while preserving earlier assertions |
|---|---|
| L4, foundational | A formal or computational construction and the choices its own conditions permit. |
| L3, transdisciplinary | A principle interpreted across eligible disciplines. Bind it to the construction wherever that interpretation is warranted. |
| L2, disciplinary | A subject discipline and the professional method, constraints or interpretation used there. |
| L1, local | Conditions shared by a particular setting or recurrent local population. |
| L0, individual | The identity of the particular entity or occurrence being modeled. Its unobserved characteristics can remain open. |
Read L0 toward L4 as abstraction, and L4 toward L0 as refinement, where the comparisons establish those relations. At each step identify the assertions retained and the warranted interpretation. For a strict step, show which answer the more abstract model admits and the more concrete model excludes, together with a surviving completion. The position’s name alone establishes neither preservation nor strictness.
Two successive application positions can admit exactly the same answers, as when a local setting adopts a professional rule unchanged for the inquiry at hand. They then occupy the same abstraction position for that inquiry. Specializing an application keeps the general rule as a premise. Merely discarding inconvenient cases from a purported universal result weakens its support. Use the steps the inquiry needs. Several consequential determinations may fall within one named application position; if the individual was fixed at the outset, binding its identity again removes no possibility.
When the entity is a method, a professional rule can be applied locally and a performed work occurrence can be compared with it. Establishing that the work occurred and followed the rule needs its own evidence. When the entity is a system, a more restrictive model can concern the very same system at the same scale. Moving to a constituent invokes the relevant constructive relation under B.1; its effect on the inquiry needs to be established separately.
Core, DPFs and LPFs supply models that can participate in such comparisons. A publication or discipline does not itself have one abstraction level. Binding a parameter can refine a model without changing its language; changing professional vocabulary can preserve all its admitted answers. A richer representation language can also express a model applicable to more situations. Compare the interpreted assertions for the inquiry.