Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-22 16:35:45 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-22 16:36:48 UTC · last check 2026-11-22 16:50:09 UTC

C.30.LCA:4.1 - Interpret control relations and the claims they support

Control-participant interpretation.

Source labelFPF recovery
Plant or controlled holonU.Holon whose state evolves; reusable state-evolution claims use A.3.3.
Regulator or controllerRecover the regulation or control relation and its participant meaning. If control Work is claimed, recover the performer System through A.13 and admit the Work independently through A.15.1 with its enacted Method. Add an assignment occurrence and F.6 only when the control account expressly consumes precise assignment-bound attribution. Add local classification only when relied on; assignment supplies none.
PlannerRecover the reference-provision, planning, or other direct relation. A planning System and planning Work are separate; for a plan, authority, or allowed-region result, use its own pattern.
Observer or estimatorRecover the observation or estimation relation and participant meaning. If observation or estimation Work occurred, recover the performer System through A.13 and admit the dated Work and enacted Method independently through A.15.1. Add assignment and F.6 only when precise assignment-bound attribution is expressly consumed; a reading or evidence result remains separate.
SupervisorRecover the supervision or B.2.5 supervisor-subholon relation. Use separate patterns for any constraining Work, policy change, authority, responsibility, gate, or control-mode change.

Control-specific stratification gate. Layer, level, tier, and stack enter C.30.LCA only after C.30.STRAT or the local sentence recovers a direct control relation, inter-layer control relation, rate band, or B.2.5 supervisor-subholon relation. An assignment alone is insufficient, and the label by itself establishes neither control structure nor separation.

B.2.5 boundary. Use B.2.5 for the compound supervisor-subholon feedback assertion. The description cites its observation and returned-influence base relations in feedbackRelationRefs and the assertion in feedbackClaimRefs; it does not coerce an episteme into U.Relation. Keep the coupling rule and facts recoverable from the assertion. Use the relevant patterns for stability, safety, causality, evidence, gate and assurance claims.

If a dated Work occurrence involving an episteme is claimed, recover the performing System through A.13 and admit the Work and enacted Method independently through A.15.1. Add an assignment occurrence and F.6 only when the account expressly consumes precise assignment-bound attribution; keep publication, source-to-use, and work-reliance relations separate.

Transformation-flow boundary. An E.18 transformation-flow path slice may supply flow-structure, path, crossing, or transformation-flow-structure input to the control view when that relation is being used. The transformation-flow description may use a mathematical graph expression under E.18.2; the description is a U.View only when E.17.0 conformance obtains. Neither the expression nor the description becomes the functional architecture, the control structure, or proof of control adequacy.

Use of a mathematical model. A proof can settle the response of the modeled loop for all disturbances and operating conditions covered by its assumptions. To apply that proof to the installed loop, identify the operating mode and check the feedback path, plant response and timing on which the conclusion depends. A successful trial can establish the response in that trial. C.29 handles the transfer, A.3.3 the dynamics, C.27.TA and C.27 the temporal claims, and C.28 a claim about the effect of changing the controller.

Nesting and scale. Identify the property at issue and which control relations could produce it. A regulator can use feedback while a supervisor supplies a fixed reference. For a claim of supervisory control, show how the reference, limit or operating mode set by the supervisor governs the regulator’s action. For supervisory feedback, also trace the observation returned to the supervisor and how it can affect that setting. Several regulators can produce a joint response through their interactions and shared limits. Trace these when they account for the behavior of the whole. Recover the bounds needed to judge latency, stability, observability, accountability or assurance, and keep a scale-audit reference when the receiving rule calls for it.

Worked slice A — a diagram used as proof. A safety note claims that a plant is safe because the supervisor monitors the lower controller. A display can show measurements even while commands run on a timer. For feedback between the supervisor and the lower controller in one episode, establish what the supervisor observed about the lower controller, how the rule or judgement in use depended on that observation, and which resulting influence reached the lower controller. A timestamp can fit both a fixed schedule and an observation-dependent rule. Records of the input and decision can distinguish them even when both would issue the same command. A claim about the physical effect of that command needs evidence of the plant response. To extend the feedback claim to another operating mode, check the signals available in time, the rule enabled in that mode and the return to the controller. To assess safety, identify the hazard and establish how the response addresses it under the conditions at issue.

Use the applicable safety pattern for the safety claim, B.3 only for a named assurance claim, A.10 for bounded source-to-use reliance, G.6 for citable provenance paths, C.27.TA for temporal aspects and rate bands, C.27 for authored temporal-claim adequacy, and A.3.3 or the applicable dynamics pattern for dynamics or stability.

Worked slice B - multi-rate controller. A source says a control stack has a slow planner, a faster regulator, and an observer with a different update period. Apply C.30.LCA only after the stack label has been recovered as reference-provision, regulation, observation, or other control relations with their participant meanings and rate bands; otherwise use C.30.STRAT first.

Systems, classifications, assignments, Methods, and Work are added only where independently current. A C.30.LCA description establishes no rate adequacy. If the rate relation matters for oscillation, latency, stability, or safety, next use C.27.TA for temporal aspect or rate-band structure, C.27 when an authored temporal-claim adequacy question is under repair, and the dynamics or assurance pattern named by value when that claim kind is being made.

Worked slice C - supervisor-subholon loop. A subsystem is supervised by an external controller System. The C.30.LCA note cites the observation and returned-influence relations together with B.2.5’s compound assertion and its coupling basis.

If that System performs mode-change Work, recover it through A.13 and admit the Work and enacted Method independently through A.15.1. Add an assignment occurrence and F.6 only when this slice also expressly represents precise assignment-bound attribution; missing or failed F.6 attribution alone leaves the mode-change Work intact while its independent A.13/A.15.1 grounds still hold.

Authority, responsibility, gate passage, safety, stability, and policy-constraint results remain separate claims under their own patterns; the supervisor relation establishes none of them.

Currentness and smallest reopen. When a decisive input changes, reopen only the control-structure locus and the use conclusions that depend on it.

  • A changed selected control structure or controlled holon reopens the affected ControlStructureViewNote or full description and view.
  • A changed direct control relation or participant meaning reopens that occurrence and its dependent structure selection.
  • A changed classification, assignment, Method, Work, or F.6 attribution reopens only that neighboring fact and any view use that relied on it.
  • A changed B.2.5 coupling rule, supervised set or report/return fact reopens the affected pair and interval assertion, its cited base relations where changed, and dependent structure uses.
  • Changed rate or control-layer relations reopen only their matching relation or boundary fields.
  • Changed view conformance reopens only the E.17.0 admission.
  • A changed source edition reopens its source-to-use and source-return locus.
  • A changed authority, responsibility, safety, proof, evidence, assurance, or gate claim reopens only that neighboring claim unless a control-structure input also changed.

A communication break need not end an assignment; reconnection requires new supporting facts.

Update the affected locus, demote full view use to a note or orientation, narrow use, or reopen the control-structure question; unrelated structures and claims stay closed.