Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Original source · lines 57–75
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-16 21:18:08 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-16 21:19:40 UTC · last check 2026-11-17 19:15:10 UTC

EXD-CHANGE — Distinguish a changed question from a mistaken inference

Situation: A recipient rejects an answer or offers another result. It is unclear whether they have changed the question, missed a relation or disputed a premise.

Question: What should the next explanation answer, and which part of the existing account can it reuse?

Possible result: the answer to the revised question, a justified correction under the original question, or an account of the disputed premise, including any grounds still needed.

Start with EXD.4 - Co-Construct and Repair an Explanation in Dialogue when an actual reply is available. Use EXD.1 - Establish and Revise What a Recipient Needs Explained if the reply changes what the account must explain.

Stop or return when the requested explanatory work is complete. Evidence of the recipient using the relation can settle a question about their understanding. A recipient who understands a recommendation may decline it. If the remaining issue is what to choose, identify who may make that choice.

  1. Recover the relation the question needs. In the worked exchange, two values have mean 3 and six values have mean 8. Their total is 2 × 3 + 6 × 8 = 54. Dividing by the eight individual observations gives 6.75. If each branch instead receives equal weight, the mean of 3 and 8 is 5.5.
  2. Show that correspondence. Use EXD.2 - Build and Bound an Explanatory Example to connect each count and mean to its group sum. Use EXD.3 - Coordinate the Expression of an Explanation when a table showing these quantities and the weighting condition would help. A single clear form suffices. Adding the missing relationship between count, mean and sum changes the content.
  3. Use the reply. If the recipient says “Each branch should have equal influence regardless of size,” EXD.1 helps establish the revised target. The answer is 5.5. The result 6.75 still answers the individual-weighting question. If the target remains equal weight per individual but the recipient divides the sum of two branch means by two, EXD.4 helps locate the error. Explain how each group mean and count give its sum, then divide the total of those sums by the number of individuals. If the issue is which policy should govern the report, use the applicable policy or seek a choice from its holder when necessary.
  4. Use the learner’s own explanation when that is the purpose. With EXD.5 - Guide a Recipient’s Own Explanation, retain the learner’s initial answer and the help they received. If the distinction needs practice, give feedback on groups versus individuals and offer a changed case. Three values with mean 4 and nine with mean 8 give (12 + 72)/12 = 7. Equal branch weights give 6. An immediate correction shows performance under those conditions. Independent performance after a delay needs evidence from that condition.

In advising, “Why does this assignment fit my present strengths?” and “Why would it develop a missing capability?” call for different grounds. A change to the second question requires the rationale for expected development. If the recipient understands that rationale and prefers another setting, respect their preference and identify its bearing on the choice they actually face.