Use profiles
These profiles apply the distinctions among subject, account, expression, recipient and evidence to instruction, technical or advisory work, and human–AI interaction. Start from the intended use and select the methods that supply a contribution it needs.
EXD.Profiles:1 - Instructional explanation
Use this profile to help a human learner reconstruct and use a relation, or to assess an earlier explanation by that learner. Start with the task, its criterion and the help permitted. An accurate imitation may leave the underlying relation unexamined. An existing performance can supply the answer, and someone seeking an immediate answer or its grounds can use an adequate explanation directly.
For human instruction, use the HCD contribution the task needs. HCD.6 helps design a practice task, HCD.9 connects feedback to its criterion and a further attempt when needed, and HCD.10 helps decide whether and how to change assistance. HCD.19 can assess the instructional material itself. Use Explanation Design to choose or make the account, example, expression or prompt the task needs, and to interpret the learner’s own contribution. A judgement about a capability gap or durable learning needs evidence under the relevant conditions.
In the pooled-mean task, the learner can add and divide and first writes “(3 + 8)/2 = 5.5, because there are two averages.” The question gives equal weight to each individual. EXD.1 helps recover that target when necessary. EXD.2 can show why multiplying each group’s count by its mean recovers its sum. EXD.3 can place count, mean and sum together while preserving the same mathematical claims.
For a teaching attempt, use EXD.5 to ask what the denominator counts for the stated target and retain the initial explanation. For an earlier attempt, identify the question, response and help from the available evidence. If the learner needs help, point to the eight observations and ask how to reconstruct the total sum and count. The pooled mean is 54/8 = 6.75. Identify what the learner supplied, what help they received and what part of it they used where this matters. If a further attempt is needed, use three observations with mean 4 and nine with mean 8. Their pooled mean is (12 + 72)/12 = 7. The reasoning needs to connect the group sums and counts to the individual mean. The number alone leaves open how it was obtained.
If the question changes to equal influence per group, the two means in the further example give (4 + 8)/2 = 6. Use EXD.4 when the learner’s contribution changes the question. Address the group-weighted result on its own terms. The instructor can use the original individual-weighting task again if the learning objective still requires it.
A learner’s product can identify a needed connection, demonstrate a successful use or leave a particular inference open. State what the person did under the documented help conditions. Performance on a meaningfully changed task may show transfer to that task under its actual help conditions. A qualified later observation of the same contribution can show what the learner retained over the interval. Generalizing about learners or attributing a learning effect needs evidence appropriate to the wider claim.
Guidance can reduce the work of finding a connection while supplying a step the learner might otherwise have to construct. Choose the task and assistance from the purpose and preparation. Seeking an unassisted first response costs effort and may tell little if the learner still needs a component supplied. If initial independent performance is at issue, use an existing observation or seek a response before giving the decisive step. Where the learner needs the component supplied, it can be provided directly.
Fiorella’s work on explaining, visualizing and enacting, the relational-mapping study, Zhang and Fiorella’s error-focused feedback, and Tetzlaff and colleagues’ synthesis inform choices of examples and support in EXD.2 and EXD.5. Mayer’s multimedia principles and Cromley and Chen’s synthesis inform EXD.3 under their learner and presentation conditions. Use EXD.6 or HCD.19 when the task calls for assessing or repairing the explanation or instructional material. Use the content and conditions of access to assess what the lesson supplies. Use evidence of the learner’s work and help to establish what happened in a particular attempt. A supported finding may leave the material as it is or call for a change in the task or support.
EXD.Profiles:2 - Technical and advisory explanation
Use this profile when a practitioner or advice recipient needs to understand a technical arrangement or a recommendation, assess its conditions or establish which rationale was used earlier. Identify the question and the premises already available. An omitted relation, unfamiliar expression, changed premise or disagreement can call for different responses. If the recipient also needs permission to act, establish who can decide.
Use the qualifications supplied by the applicable technical or advising practice. Core A.3.2.DE and E.8.ML address a method description and the rationale for a connected set of methods. C.37.CF helps compare their representations. Use Decision Design PSDA.14 for the grounds and alternatives of a recommendation, PSDA.15 when earlier advice needs re-examination, and PSDA.19 when its engagement, authority or feasibility conditions matter.
An engineer asks why source allocation, coherence checking and reconstruction have separate entries and proposes combining them. Distinguish the architecture question from the performance of one check. F.0.2.MA asks which source contributions are carried and why. A.3.1.CC tests a maintained method claim against its basis. F.0.2.RC examines whether the promised source contribution can be reconstructed for its stated use. Its result may confirm coverage, identify an omission or leave the basis open. E.8.ML explains how the distinct questions, results and returns can justify separate entries. A diagram can group them for navigation without prescribing a sequence.
For the question whether one maintained claim agrees with the available source, A.3.1.CC can suffice. If a needed source disappears, identify the conclusion that depends on it and retain independently supported findings. EXD.3 helps express these relations. The existing E.8.ML account can suffice. Use EXD.6 to assess a proposed change when the comparison matters. Authorization to publish requires its own basis.
In a stipulated advising case, Mira asks why a bounded coordination assignment is recommended before enrolment in a management course. She recently succeeded at coordination tasks, a sponsor offers four months of protected time, and the available evidence does not establish that a credential is required. These are the grounds offered for comparing the two options.
Mira may understand the rationale and still prefer the course for its social setting or decline the recommendation. Her earlier question can be answered by explaining the grounds on which the advice was given. If she wants advice for the current choice, consider that preference under the applicable criteria. If the sponsor has withdrawn the protected time, reassess feasibility, including any equivalent time available. The recommendation may change, remain supported for other reasons, or become conditional.
Check the rationale against its sources and conditions. For the engineer’s architecture question, explain how the three methods supply distinct results and why their relations justify the entries. For a particular check, identify which method answers that narrower question. In Mira’s case, show which premise depends on protected time. To establish what a recipient understood, examine their response with its help conditions. Agreement, consent, resources and decision authority each have their own grounds.
Use a clear question directly. Further elicitation or justification costs the recipient time when their purpose and the rationale are already known. An unfamiliar request or disagreement can reflect a different intended use or preference. Before inferring a difficulty in the recipient’s understanding, examine what their response establishes. Fisher’s eleven consultations illustrate how both participants can shape the exchange. Axelsson and colleagues distinguish feedback on contact, perception, understanding and attitude. These sources inform dialogue in the examples. Assess any effect on understanding separately. Use the instructional profile when learning is a further purpose.
EXD.Profiles:3 - Human–AI explanation
Use this profile when a person and an AI system prepare, discuss or revise an explanation, or when an AI system is itself the subject of the explanation. The question might concern its design or how a deployed version produced a particular result. Identify which subject is being explained. An account of a deployed system’s output may need evidence about its version, inputs and operation.
Use the relevant subject grounds and identify the contributions in the exchange. A person can propose a question, correction, constraint or preference, and an AI system may supply a calculation or source. To explain a deployed system’s behavior, use evidence bearing on its actual operation. A fluent self-description or expressed confidence can be reported as an output. Its causal interpretation needs further grounds.
An AI assistant can use the definition of the mean to recover the total sum and count and give 6.75 for equal individual weighting. If the user changes to equal branch influence, report 5.5 for equal branch weighting. Keep 6.75 as the answer to the earlier individual-weighting question. Use EXD.1 or EXD.4 when the intended question needs clarification. The established calculation can answer a direct request.
If the user asks why a deployed predictor returned a particular value, identify the model, input and diagnostic or other subject evidence that bears on that output. When evidence is incomplete, give the warranted explanation, identify the evidence still needed for an unresolved causal claim and state the limit. The earlier arithmetic example establishes the averaging relation for its own inputs.
For human instruction, an AI assistant can prompt for the learner’s reasoning and preserve the response, any help given and a further attempt when the question needs one. The person’s explanation gives evidence of what they did under those conditions. A result the assistant produces itself can help inspect public instructions or construct a candidate answer. Claims about either performer’s capabilities or mechanisms need evidence about that performer.
For an exchange, identify the current question, its subject grounds and what the participants contributed. For an observed result, specify the system or person, version where relevant, access and assistance. Distinguish interaction behavior, performance on the immediate task against its criterion, confidence, later retention and decision quality when interpreting evidence.
Social XAI work examines joint question formation, incremental explanation and adaptation. Liao and colleagues and Schmude and colleagues examine ways to recover a user’s task beyond a prepared question bank. Fichtel and colleagues’ 2025 study found more co-constructive behavior under its prompting conditions. It did not find a significant mean advantage on its objective understanding measure.
Adaptation may help with a changed purpose and may also add turns, reading effort or unsupported claims. Use a correction or existing response to identify what now matters. Give the warranted answer, the repair needed or the open subject question with its conditions. EXD.6 helps assess a worthwhile local change. Use the instructional or technical and advisory profile where a stronger claim depends on its evidence.