F.18:4.5 - Model refinement, abstraction and relative levels
Use these NameCards when project or teaching texts need a shared name for a model comparison. B.5.MR defines two relation kinds and one kind of inquiry-relative level, each a local U.Kind. A pair of models can stand in one of the relations. Constructing or selecting a model is Work.
For the shared ReferenceScheme fix an inquiry and an interpretation. Each admissible completion satisfies its model’s assertions and yields an answer to that inquiry. Include the probability claims when they matter. Refinement requires at least one completion of C, with every completion of C satisfying A under the interpretation. A is then an abstraction of C. For strictness A must allow an answer C excludes. Within a chain established this way, models admitting the same answers share a level. Equal answers across branches can coexist with incompatible constraints.
| NameCard and governed value | Exact local sense and selected Tech designation | Candidate comparison and selection | Lineage and reopening |
|---|---|---|---|
NC-MODEL-REFINEMENT; B.5.MR:4.2 refinement relation kind | model refinement: C refines A exactly when the feasible-preservation test above holds. Strictness adds exclusion. | Refinement retains the specification-theory comparison. Stronger model can suggest quality; specialization can mean type restriction; detailing can change expression alone. Concretization has a separately defined mathematical use in abstract interpretation and is not an unqualified English alias here. | Retains the established English designation and states its converse. Reopen when the predicate, inquiry interpretation or supported construction changes, or repeated use confuses preservation with accuracy. |
NC-MODEL-ABSTRACTION; B.5.MR:4.2 converse relation kind | model abstraction: A is an abstraction of C exactly when C refines A under the same comparison. | Abstraction names the converse without promising a unique inverse construction. Generalization can mean a wider empirical claim; weakening can suggest lower quality; lifting has source-dependent direction and may construct a fine-scale state. | Makes the converse of the existing comparison explicit. Reopen when the predicate changes or readers repeatedly recover omission of visible detail without comparing assertions. |
NC-MODEL-ABSTRACTION-LEVEL, B.5.MR:4.3 inquiry-relative level of model abstraction | Level of model abstraction when reading towards more abstract models. Level of model refinement when reading the same order towards more concrete models. In an established chain, a strict step changes the answers the models admit for the inquiry. | These names identify what is ordered and the direction of reading. A level of detail concerns a representation, a holonic level concerns constituent–whole organization, and a metamodel can govern construction of a model. Each has its own comparison. | F.17:12.6 records both expressions for one governed value. Reopen the choice if the comparison changes or readers apply it as a global rank of disciplines, publications or languages. |
In ordinary speech a team can say “the local model is more concrete about where the check may take place” and name the choice it has fixed. Refining a model and abstracting a model name the work of constructing or selecting one. The comparative adjectives describe the models once a strict difference has been established.
F.17:12.6 gives the three citable rows and the exact sense cells for this comparison. Source-specific uses of concretization, idealization and lifting retain their own definitions.