SOTA-PORTFOLIO — Compare approaches that could answer your question
- Situation: Your team needs to know what competing approaches can establish and where each applies.
- Question: What can the sources already answer, and what work remains?
- First useful result or blocker: A comparison linking each claim to its source, edition, evidence and limits. State where the claims can be compared, what remains disputed and which part of your question is open.
- Mantra: Fix the inquiry and freshness needed. Compare claims, methods and grounds. Keep consequential disagreements. Use the comparison if it suffices. For a remaining need, consider reuse, a contribution, another product or maintained guidance. If a DPF or LPF is warranted, develop and test its patterns and revisit them as evidence or use changes.
- Start with:
G.2for source comparison. UseC.18,C.19orG.5for options. For framework authoring, develop the practitioner’s explanations underE.4.DPF. UseE.4.PFADfor a product choice andE.9for its decision record when needed. - Stop or return: Stop at the comparison when it answers the commission. For a usable practice or framework, carry the grounds into its construction and check what the practitioner can do. Recover a source construction lost in translation through
FPF.Reference:16.5.