Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-22 12:18:55 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-22 12:19:56 UTC · last check 2026-11-22 12:30:20 UTC

Part D - Multi-scale Ethics and Conflict Optimization

D.1 - Clarify an Ethical Claim’s Value Basis (Value Plurality)

Type: D-family ethical boundary pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. The value basis of an ethical claim or proposed action is unclear.

Use A.1.CSD when the judgement depends on who could bear a consequence and the affected systems are still unclear. A conditional value premise can be examined for a class of participants. To apply it to a proposed action, establish whom the action reaches and which conditions of the premise hold. Retain a missing participant or consequence as an open question when it could change the judgement.

Not this pattern when. If the question is already a conflict across declared levels or scopes, use D.3. If the question is how to mediate that conflict or use it in a decision, use D.4. If the question is bias, fairness, human or group impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance, use D.5.

What goes wrong if missed. FPF looks ethically neutral because it names evidence, method, architecture, or work but leaves the value frame and affected EntityOfConcern implicit.

What this buys. The reader can see whose concern is at issue, what is valued, and which ethical question to address next. For a judgement, the reader can recover how the value premises and relevant facts support the conclusion, what changes when a premise changes, and which use the reasoning warrants.

D.1:1 - Problem Frame

FPF cannot prescribe one final ethics doctrine and still remain usable across engineering, research, organizational, public, and AI-enabled work. But FPF also cannot treat ethical neutrality as permission to omit ethics. Many working claims already carry values: who may be harmed, who benefits, which consequences count, which responsibilities are accepted, what evidence is enough, and which sacrifice is treated as admissible.

When a value concern matters, state what is valued, for whom and under which conditions. Explain the value premise and identify any factual evidence on which the judgement relies.

D.1:1.0 - Problem

Ethically loaded FPF claims often arrive as ordinary technical, architectural, method, evidence, or publication claims. The failure is that the reader cannot recover who or what is affected, what is valued, or what the ethical claim is meant to support. A conclusion can also overstate the evidence or hide a limitation that changes its use.

D.1:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Value plurality vs. shared useFPF must work across ethical traditions, but the claim still needs an inspectable value frame.
Technical adequacy vs. ethical forceEvidence, assurance, method, architecture, or work quality may be strong while the value concern remains implicit.
Local usefulness vs. overreachA bounded ethical claim can guide work, but it must not become universal moral permission.
Plain language vs. hidden doctrineWords such as responsible, safe, fair, aligned, or humane are useful only after the valued object and affected parties are named.
Boundary entry vs. conflict handlingUse D.1 to surface the value frame, D.3 for conflict structure, D.4 for mediation, and D.5 for bias audit and assurance use.

D.1:2 - Solution

Start with the ethical claim or question, the affected EntityOfConcern, the value concern, and the present use of the answer. Name evidence and material uncertainty when the answer relies on them. If the task is to recognize the concern, a short statement of the value concern and next question completes that task; use D.3 when its sides and tension need description.

To judge a use ethically admissible, explain how the value premises and available evidence support that judgement and where it remains limited. When the judgement depends on expected benefits or harms, identify the period over which they count and what the evidence supports over that period. Recognizing a concern supplies neither that judgement nor permission to act.

Use an EthicalValueFrame@Context when the present reasoning or a later reader needs to compare value premises, distinguish the uses a judgement supports, or revisit a premise that can change it. This content can remain in the answer or an existing decision record. The following form groups the applicable content:

EthicalValueFrame@Context:
  ethicalClaimRef
  affectedEntityOfConcernRef
  intendedEthicalUse
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  valueConcernRefs
  valueFrameEditionRefs?
  ethicalTheoryOrTraditionRefs?
  affectedHolonRefs?
  affectedSystemRefs?
  affectedEpistemeRefs?
  directResponsibilityRelationRefs?
  systemRoleAssignmentRefs?: FinSet(U.RelationRef constrained to U.SystemRoleAssignment)
  methodOrWorkRefs?
  transformationRefs?
  evidenceRefs?
  uncertaintyOrCurrentnessCondition?
  admissibleUse
  inadmissibleOverread?
  strongerSourceReturnCondition?

Include a source-return condition when a stronger claim or changed use needs it. Use C.11.DUA when the contribution or burden of a proposed frame, report, or evidence request is unresolved. The form creates no obligation to invent a further check or explain an inactive one.

This frame makes the value premises inspectable; the ethical judgement needs reasoning. A utilitarian consequence claim, a deontic constraint, a virtue or character claim, a care-ethics concern, a rights claim, a professional-duty claim, and a project-specific value trade-off may all be admissible starting points, but they must not be presented as the same claim merely because the same word “ethical” appears.

D.1:2.1 - Make the value premise do explanatory work

A value label identifies a concern; a reason explains why that concern supports the proposed judgement. State the value premise, the relevant facts and the step joining them. For example, a prediction of greater aggregate benefit can support a recommendation only under a premise giving that benefit the relevant priority. A right can constrain the recommendation under a different premise even when the prediction is correct. Use B.5.RA when the argument must be recovered from a source, including a rhetorical question or an analogy.

Keep the grounds of acceptance distinct. Evidence can support a claim about consequences or the conditions in which a person agreed. A normative premise states what ought to count, what may be required or which treatment is permissible. Explaining a tradition’s history can help interpret its premise; neither that history nor a model of a system establishes the premise’s moral authority. When the premise is contested, preserve the conditional conclusion and identify what accepting another premise would change.

Attribute the premise at the level at which it has grounds. A member can report their own objection. To say that an organization adopted a rule, identify the decision that gave the rule force and the matters it covers. That decision may bind members who disagree. A claim that all members endorse it needs evidence about their views. An analyst can identify an unreported risk to a member and give the reasons for considering it, while leaving that member’s assessment open.

The following argument develops one such conditional basis for decisions about people’s participation. It supplies reasons that can be examined and applied; FPF does not select this basis as its final ethical doctrine.

D.1:2.2 - Personal authority, voluntary participation and reciprocal limits

Use this reasoning when a proposal treats a person’s body, work or participation as available because a planner can describe a useful larger system. The question is who may decide that person’s contribution, on what grounds and within what limits.

D.1:2.2.1 - State the normative starting point

One possible starting point gives each person presumptive moral authority over the use of their own body and participation. On this view, another person’s valuable plan creates a reason to request cooperation, but the value of that plan alone does not authorize the required personal contribution. This is a claim about how people should be treated, not a claim that they always control their circumstances.

Some accounts develop this position through self-ownership. The working claim here is the stated personal authority; a stronger ownership theory needs its further premises. Whether rights can be transferred, which rights cannot be waived, and which obligations qualify them are substantive ethical questions.

A person’s moral standing is also distinct from their present ability to decide or act. Children and people temporarily unable to decide do not become resources available to a planner; a protective or representative arrangement needs its basis and limits.

For this argument, accept a second premise: comparable persons have the same presumptive standing, and a difference in treatment needs a relevant reason. Equal standing does not mean equal knowledge, skill, resources or preferences. Those differences can change who can perform work or give useful advice without establishing a right to command another person.

D.1:2.2.2 - Use reciprocity to expose a missing justification

Suppose a designer claims that knowing how to improve a project permits imposing its work on another person, while denying that the other person may impose work on the designer under comparable conditions. With the equal-standing premise, the designer’s identity cannot justify this asymmetry. A relevant difference must do the work: for example, an applicable commitment or a justified authority limited to that decision. If no such difference is established, either the special permission must be withdrawn or the equal-standing premise must be rejected and the alternative defended.

This is the force of the reciprocal question: what would justify the same rule when the positions are exchanged? Preserve the facts that matter to the rule, including a mandate, vulnerability and effects on others.

Asking only whether the proposer personally likes the treatment is weaker: people have different preferences, and someone willing to endure a burden may still lack permission to impose it on others. Reciprocity examines the consistency and grounds of the proposed rule; it does not independently prove the starting premises or settle every conflict.

Combined with the personal-authority premise, the result is a reason to seek an authorized contribution rather than count the person as already available. When no applicable prior commitment or other justified authority covers the move, a plan requires the person’s valid agreement or a different way of obtaining the result. Reusing an adequate existing commitment within its limits does not require asking for permission again.

D.1:2.2.3 - Explain what consent can authorize

Consent matters under this value basis because it lets the person exercise the authority the premise assigns to them. It must concern the proposed act or a sufficiently clear class of acts. A signature, silence or presence in a group cannot establish its scope and validity without the circumstances that give that response its meaning.

Examine the information and understanding needed for this choice, the person’s decision capacity, the pressure involved and the practical ability to refuse. Where a person’s agreement is obtained through a threat of a penalty that the adopted ethical basis does not justify, that compliance does not supply voluntary consent. Dependence or limited alternatives can make voluntariness doubtful; their presence calls for a judgement under the applicable ethical and domain standards, rather than an automatic inference either of valid consent or of its absence.

An agreement to contribute gives the recipient only the authorization it supplies. Agreeing to a defined task need not authorize a new purpose, wider disclosure or another person’s participation. The applicable basis must also establish the conditions for changing or ending a commitment; permission to begin does not by itself answer every question about withdrawal. Some protections may remain non-waivable under that basis. Consent between two parties cannot by itself dispose of a third party’s rights or settle harm imposed on that party.

When consent is absent or insufficient, retain the unmet condition. A narrower task, different terms, supported voluntary participation or another provider can sometimes meet the project’s purpose. Where the question is which alternative to choose or how to resolve a conflict with another duty, use D.3 and D.4.

D.1:2.2.4 - Keep system structure and rights separate

A person can participate in an organization or be a physical component of a working arrangement while retaining moral claims against what that arrangement demands. Describing the organization’s useful function does not establish a duty to serve it. Conversely, a person’s refusal does not establish that every obligation they previously undertook has disappeared. Identify the proposed act and the relation that could authorize it.

Ownership of a tool, authority over work, membership in a group and physical part-whole relations answer different questions. Treating possessions as an extension of a person may express a moral argument for protecting them, but extending the personal-authority premise to property requires an account of legitimate possession and its limits. It does not make every owned object a physical part of its owner. Likewise, a sponsor’s control of funds or equipment does not confer control over every person the project affects.

Dissolving an organization and killing its members have different consequences. A model that calls both entities living systems cannot supply the missing ethical comparison. Investigate the consequences for people, including dependence on the organization and the costs of transition, instead of deriving either unconditional preservation or harmless dissolution from the metaphor.

D.1:2.2.5 - Identify the premise that changes the conclusion

A consent-based account can recognize duties to others and limited powers that do not depend on consent to each individual act. Their justification must be supplied rather than hidden in the word “system”. A valid employment commitment may authorize a bounded assignment. A protective duty or public authority may be offered as another basis; its source, scope, safeguards and application need the relevant ethical and domain reasoning. Calling compliance consent would conceal the difference.

Other value frames can give different reasons for the same decision. A consequence-based account asks whether the proposed intervention produces better supported outcomes than feasible alternatives, with its chosen treatment of distribution and rights. A public-justification account asks whether the governing rule and its unequal powers can be justified to those subject to it, including a basis for binding dissenters. A care-based account may give special weight to dependence and responsibilities arising from a relationship. These lines can support or oppose a use of authority; none follows merely from system scale or the number of supporters.

Locate the disagreement: the standing assigned to persons, the priority of a duty, the validity of an authorization, a predicted consequence or the interpretation of a rule. That tells the practitioner what could change the judgement. A conditional argument for voluntary cooperation establishes neither that all public projects fail nor that every collective decision needs unanimous consent. Whether an artificial system has moral standing is also a separate question from whether it can pursue goals or perform a task.

The practical result is an explained boundary on a proposed action: which contribution may be requested or required under which premises, which agreement or authority supports it, and what remains unresolved. D.3 describes a resulting value conflict; D.4 develops and compares ways to continue.

D.1:3 - Boundaries

D.1 keeps value plurality and FPF boundary discipline. It does not replace:

QuestionSubject pattern
Which levels, scopes, holons, interests, responsibilities, methods, work, and consequences are in ethical tension?D.3
How should a mapped ethical conflict be mediated, refused, escalated, or used in a decision?D.4
Is a model, metric, policy, publication, or release-bearing claim biased, unfair, or ethically unsafe?D.5
Does the causal fairness claim have the required C.28 evidence value and verdict?C.28, with D.5 for ethical-audit use
Is the ethical claim supported, and can that support be relied on for this use?Use the applicable subject and evidence patterns and an adequate existing basis; apply A.10 when the source-to-use relation is implicit or must be made replayable for the receiving use.
Is an assurance claim being made?B.3
Is an architecture residual current?C.30.ILC

D.1:4 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slice)

A team says that a triage model is “ethical because it maximizes total benefit.” Asked which ethical question this leaves open, the practitioner can answer: the claim values aggregate benefit, while equal access and avoidable subgroup harm may lead to a different judgement. The next question is how those concerns apply to the affected patients. That answer completes the initial recognition task.

If the team instead proposes this claim as a reason to adopt the model, identify the affected patients and institutions, the meaning of “total benefit”, the consequence theory, the excluded concerns, the evidence relied on, and the use that evidence warrants. D.3 describes any live conflict over access or harm; D.4 governs its mediation or decision use.

D.1:4.2 - A project needs a person’s contribution

A community workshop has adopted a personal-authority premise for voluntary participation. Its coordinator wants members to carry location trackers during a festival so that help can be dispatched quickly. The equipment sponsor approves the plan. Members had agreed to specified volunteer shifts, with no agreement to continuous tracking.

The benefit of faster dispatch gives a reason to propose tracking, while the sponsor’s approval covers the supplied equipment. Neither supplies the members’ missing agreement. Under the adopted premise, the coordinator must obtain valid agreement to the proposed information use or construct another arrangement. The reciprocal question exposes the missing ground: the coordinator would also need a reason for letting another organizer collect the coordinator’s movements merely because it helped that organizer’s project.

Suppose members understand the purpose and retention period, can decline without losing access to ordinary workshop services, and can instead report availability at agreed intervals. A member’s agreement can authorize the limited tracking described. It does not authorize publishing a route that reveals a nonparticipant’s location; that changed effect needs consideration. The alternative reporting arrangement also shows why a useful dispatch purpose need not require the initially chosen means.

Now change the question to an ordinary task within a member’s already accepted shift. If the established agreement authorizes the coordinator to allocate that task, the personal-authority premise does not require a new consent ceremony. Recover the scope and any remaining constraints. If the proposed tracking is instead claimed to be mandatory under an applicable safety rule, establish that rule and its ethical basis; voluntary consent is no longer the explanation for the mandate. These different conclusions arise from changed grounds of authority, not from a change in the person’s status.

D.1:4.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Ethical label as permissionA word such as responsible or fair is treated as enough to act.Name the value concern, affected EntityOfConcern, evidence, and admissible use.
One doctrine by defaultThe local text silently assumes one ethical theory while claiming neutrality.Name the ethical theory, tradition, or project value frame when it changes the claim.
Technical proof substitutes for value frameEvidence, model quality, or architecture adequacy is read as ethical adequacy.Keep evidence-use and assurance patterns separate from the ethical value frame.
Ethics becomes universal ownerEvery difficult concern is assigned to D.1.Use D.1 only for value-frame boundary; return conflict, mediation, bias, causal, assurance, and architecture claims to their subject patterns.

D.1:5 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D1-1The ethical claim or question, affected EntityOfConcern, value concern, and intended use are named. Relied-on evidence and material uncertainty qualify the answer. Value-frame editions, ClaimScope, qualification window, affected Systems, and direct responsibility relations are added when they change the claim or its warranted use.Keeps “ethical” from becoming a label without content or a generic context premise.
CC-D1-2A judgement of ethical admissibility states its warranted use and any limitation that changes it. A separate frame or stronger-source return serves a reasoning or receiving need.Prevents value wording from authorizing action by itself.
CC-D1-3Ethical theory, tradition, or project-specific value frame is named when it changes the claim. A conditional judgement preserves its value premises, relevant facts and inference; a contested premise remains identifiable.Keeps plural value frames inspectable and reasoning recoverable.
CC-D1-4Multilevel conflict, mediation, bias or fairness audit, causal use, evidence, assurance, and architecture residuals use their subject patterns.Keeps D.1 as boundary pattern rather than universal ethics owner.

D.1:7 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
Neutrality theaterThe work claims to avoid ethics by naming only technical evidence or method quality.Recover the value concern or state that no ethical claim is being made.
Slogan ethicsResponsible, safe, humane, aligned, fair, or beneficial is used without affected parties and warranted use.Name the affected parties, value concern, and intended claim; qualify the basis relied on.
Doctrine smugglingA utilitarian, rights, duty, care, virtue, professional, or project-specific value frame is treated as obvious.State the normative premise and how it supports the judgement; use D.3 when the disagreement forms an ethical conflict.
Universal D.1D.1 is used to decide mediation, bias, causal fairness, or assurance.Use D.3, D.4, D.5, C.28, A.10, B.3, or the subject pattern.

D.1:6 - Consequences

Explicit value premises let readers compare ethical claims and identify where their grounds differ.

Explicitness follows the claim being used: recognition needs a clear concern and next question, while a judgement needs its supporting basis and use limits. A durable frame earns its effort through the comparison or later reliance it supports.

For decisions about people, the conditional argument in :2.2 makes a practical difference: the planner can distinguish a valued result from authority to require a person’s contribution, reuse an adequate commitment, and identify when consent, another justification or a different means is still needed. It also shows which disagreement concerns the normative basis rather than a missing technical fact.

D.1:8 - Rationale

D.1 connects a value concern with the premises and facts needed to assess its use. Revealing that connection lets a reader identify whether a disagreement concerns values, facts or authority and direct the unresolved question to the appropriate method.

This keeps FPF usable in engineering, research, organizational, public, and AI-enabled contexts where ethical traditions differ but value-bearing claims still need explicit affected entities, value concerns, and warranted use, with the evidence and return conditions that this use needs.

D.1:9 - SoTA-Echoing

For judging a person’s participation in :2.2, adapt the developed consent reasoning in the Belmont Report, “Respect for Persons” and “Informed Consent” (1979), UNESCO’s bioethics declaration, Articles 5–7 (2005), and the Declaration of Helsinki, paragraphs 25–30 (2024). Against treating expressed willingness or a sponsor’s approval as sufficient, :2.2 examines the agreement’s scope, information, understanding, voluntariness and applicable capacity or representation conditions. The participation case changes its conclusion when the claimed authority or an existing commitment changes.

These sources supply developed treatments in medicine and research; their requirements retain those domains, while D.1’s broader argument remains conditional on its stated normative premises. Reopen that argument when a changed obligation, affected party, consent condition or domain rule changes the grounds of the judgement.

D.1:10 - Relations

  • Builds on A.1 and A.7 for EntityOfConcern and description distinction.

  • Coordinates with A.1.CSD when a current ethical claim still lacks an adequate set of Systems that may bear consequences; D.1 consumes the returned account and does not add value fields to its neutral core.

  • Coordinates with B.5.RA when the ethical argument must be recovered from a source and with B.5.RR when a changed premise requires revising its conclusions.

  • Coordinates with A.10 when the source-to-use relation behind a relied-on claim is implicit or needs a replayable account.

  • Coordinates with C.11.DUA when a proposed ethical record or evidence demand needs appraisal of its contribution, feasibility, burden, or requirement merits.

  • Coordinates with B.3 when an assurance claim is current.

  • Use D.2 to recognize concerns across levels and scopes, D.3 to describe conflicts, D.4 to develop and compare continuations, and D.5 to select and interpret an ethical audit.

  • Coordinates with C.28 for causal fairness use and with C.30.ILC when an architecture residual is current.

D.1:End

D.2 - Recognize Ethical Concerns Across Levels and Scopes (Multilevel Ethics)

Type: D-family ethical entry pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. A proposed action may benefit one party and impose a cost or risk on another, or it may change who is responsible for the consequences. The parties can be parts of one system, members of overlapping groups or users affected through a shared service.

Not this pattern when. If only the value frame is missing, use D.1. If D.3 has already described the conflict, use that result. If the conflict has to be mediated or used in a decision, use D.4. If the concern is bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance, use D.5.

What goes wrong if missed. A team sees the improvement it sought and recommends the change while somebody else loses access, takes on work or bears a new risk.

What this buys. Identify who or what may bear a consequence, explain how the action could reach them, and choose the ethical question that needs an answer.

D.2:1 - Problem Frame

An organization can save work by moving it to its members. A project can meet its target while people outside the project lose access to a service. A standard can improve coordination for some users while excluding a device on which others rely. In each case, follow the change from the decision to those who may gain or lose.

Use a level of composition when the concern depends on what a constituent does within an identified whole. Two groups can share members, or rely on the same service, without either group being a constituent of the other. Identify the relation that carries the effect. Someone can bear a consequence without taking part in the decision.

D.2:1.0 - Problem

A change can benefit one affected entity while imposing harm, exclusion or risk elsewhere, or change who is responsible for its consequences. The failure is to infer ethical sufficiency from the local gain without examining consequences for others. When responsibility matters, state its basis; a kind or assignment does not by itself establish that responsibility. Use E.10.ROLE when role wording leaves the relevant object or relation unclear.

D.2:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Local benefit vs. cross-level harmA change can improve one declared scope while imposing cost, risk, or exclusion elsewhere.
Situation-defined levels vs. fixed laddersIdentify the relevant composition, membership or exposure in the situation and the conditions assumed in the claim.
Affected entities and their descriptionsIdentify the affected entity, whether a system or an episteme such as a standard, and explain whose use or interests make the change an ethical concern.
Early recognition vs. premature mediationUse D.2 to make the conflict visible, D.3 to describe its sides and tension, and D.4 for mediation.
Ethical concern vs. architecture residualCross-scope residuals can be architectural, ethical, or both; choose the method for the question that needs answering.

D.2:2 - Solution

Start with the proposed action or arrangement and the gain it promises. Use an existing account if it identifies the affected parties and explains the consequences that matter here. Otherwise trace the changes in work, use or dependency to the entities that may experience their effects. Say which connections already exist, which the proposal would create, and which effects are observed or predicted. If you cannot tell who might experience an effect or how it would reach them, use A.1.CSD to investigate and state what remains unknown.

Connect each material consequence to the party or entity affected, the value premise that makes it matter and the conditions under which the change could produce it. If the claim concerns a whole, establish how the effects on its constituents bear on the property in question. A saving for one office may be extra work for another. If the claim concerns other settings, establish which conditions of that explanation hold there. State the next question. Use D.3 when the sides and their tension need describing. When an adequate account of the conflict already exists, it can go directly into the D.4 comparison.

Use MultilevelEthicsEntry@Context when the practitioner or a recipient needs to recover these connections for comparison or revision. Keep its content in the existing answer or working note when that suffices. If an existing note says only “level or scope”, recover which relation, affected population or applicability condition the note identified. Retain a reference to a U.WorkScope with the capability it qualifies, or to a U.PublicationScope with the publication view or form it qualifies. If the meaning of the old label is still unclear, keep the original wording and identify that uncertainty. Add the evidence, value-frame editions and supporting relations on which the stated concern relies.

MultilevelEthicsEntry@Context:
  ethicalConcernRef
  affectedEntityOfConcernRef
  valueFrameEditionRefs?
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  compositionRelationRefs?  // identified whole and constituent, when their relation matters
  affectedPopulationOrAreaRefs?  // who is included or where exposure occurs
  affectedHolonRefs?
  affectedEpistemeRefs?
  roleWordRecoveryRefs?: E.10.ROLE results when the relevant role meaning needed clarification
  localSystemRoleKindRefs?: FinSet(U.KindRef)
  systemRoleClassificationAssertionRefs?: FinSet(U.EpistemeRef)
  systemRoleAssignmentRows?: FinSet({
    assignmentSpeciesRef: U.RelationKindRef constrained under U.SystemRoleAssignment
    assignmentOccurrenceRef: U.RelationRef constrained to an obtaining occurrence of assignmentSpeciesRef, with participants, holder, applicability, and extent recoverable
  })
  participationOrAffectedPartyRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  participationOrAffectedPartyMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  responsibilityRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  responsibilityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  commitmentRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  commitmentMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  permissionRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  permissionMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  authorityRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  authorityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  interestOrConcernRefs
  capabilityOrFunctioningConcernRefs?
  methodRefs?
  workRefs?
  transformationRefs?
  expectedConsequenceRefs
  evidenceRefs?
  uncertaintyOrCurrentnessCondition?
  nextSubjectPatternLocator

The entry has one job: make the multilevel concern recognizable and choose its next use. It does not require a separate dossier or new inquiry before the concern can be discussed. A proposed inquiry goes through C.11.DUA when its receiving contribution or feasibility is unresolved; conflict description and decision use remain with D.3 and D.4.

Material systems and epistemes can be affected EntitiesOfConcern. For an episteme such as a standard, state which uses and interests make its change ethically relevant.

D.2:3 - Recognition Matrix

Working situationWhat to recoverNext pattern to apply
A Method helps one team meet its target while increasing risk for another team or for users.Affected holons, any independently current assignment, Method, actual Work when present, expected consequences, evidence, and each responsibility, commitment, permission, authority, or participation relation that the concern relies on.D.3 conflict description
A city service gains capacity while access for night-shift workers in one district may worsen.Identify the service, who can use it at the relevant hours, how the proposed change affects access, and whose responsibilities or value claims it engages.D.3 conflict description
A technical standard improves interoperability but excludes a minority device, language, publication form, or data source.Standard or episteme whole, affected systems, publication and use relations, consequence horizon.D.3, with C.2.1 and E.17 as needed
An overall result meets its target while the outcome for a particular group is unknown.Recover who entered the count, which outcome was measured, and whether the result supports the claim about that group.D.5, with C.28 when a causal claim matters
An architecture move reduces residual at one holon level while creating cross-scope residual elsewhere.Architecture structure, selected scopes, residual, affected value concerns.C.30.ILC; use D.3 if ethical conflict is live

D.2:4 - Boundaries

D.2 recognizes ethical concerns across levels and scopes. Use the corresponding subject method to judge a conflict, mediate it or conduct an audit.

An affected population identifies who may experience a change. A composition relation identifies a whole and its constituent. A claim’s scope identifies the conditions under which the assertion applies (A.2.6). A proposed use can fall within the stated scope while evidence for its predicted effect is still missing. The same fact can matter to more than one of these questions. A change to a service can affect an entire organization on one occasion. To use that explanation for future decisions, identify what would carry the effect again. B.5.MR compares what models fix or leave open. Use C.29 when a mathematical representation is needed to examine scale, a trade-off or an allocation.

D.2:5 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slice)

A product team wants to reduce service cost by making a medical device harder to service outside authorized centers. The team expects better manufacturer quality control and lower liability risk. To find who may bear the cost, follow the proposed restriction through the service arrangement: some regions have local repair services but no authorized center; losing the local route may prolong device downtime and reduce patients’ timely access.

This is a possible consequence of the restriction, with its likelihood and extent still to be established. The next question is which service restriction, if any, addresses the hazard without imposing avoidable access harm. That question and the connected sides complete the present D.2 recognition; D.3 can describe their tension from this account.

Now suppose a release decision depends on whether a proposed servicing method can leave calibration outside the declared tolerance. A qualified test team can perform the discriminating check before the release window closes, and the release authority needs its result under the applicable rule. Preserve that investigation and the rule’s force.

Use C.11.DUA to compare the restriction’s protective contribution with access harm, feasible alternatives, delay, and displaced work. D.4 carries the resulting decision, including the authority needed to change a requirement or accept a residual. If the required basis cannot be obtained, the proposed release remains unsupported; a narrower continuation must meet its conditions.

D.2:5.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Local improvement treated as sufficientA proposal benefits one party while imposing costs elsewhere.Trace where the work, risk or loss goes and why it matters to those affected.
Fixed ladder biasA hierarchy such as individual, team and society is imposed on an affected population.Identify actual composition, membership, use or exposure. Establish responsibility where the judgement relies on it.
System-only biasMultilevel ethics is limited to material systems and misses epistemes, standards, publications, or descriptions.Treat affected systems and epistemes as admitted holons when the case makes them current.
Architecture absorbs ethicsA cross-scope residual is treated only as architecture because it has a structural shape.Use C.30.ILC for architecture residual and D.3 and D.4 when value, harm, responsibility, or admissible sacrifice is live.

D.2:6 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D2-1Identify the whole and constituent when composition matters, the membership or exposure that locates the affected parties, and the conditions on which the consequence claim depends. Use the distinctions needed for the next decision.Makes clear whose gain or loss is at issue and where the explanation applies.
CC-D2-2Name the affected entities, Methods, actual Work and consequences needed for the concern. Clarify unclear role wording with E.10.ROLE; keep any local kind and C.2.1 classification assertion distinct. For an assignment, use its declared species and support the claim; an asserted occurrence needs its participants and applicability. Establish participation, responsibility, commitment, permission and authority separately when relied on, retaining a supported negative or conditional result, or the missing fact or rule.Keeps the entry usable without making assignment imply participation or responsibility.
CC-D2-3The result identifies the next live question and D.3, D.4, D.5, C.30.ILC, or another subject pattern that answers it. The entry record is used only when its recoverable content contributes to that use.Keeps D.2 as entry recognition, not conflict solver.
CC-D2-4Mathematical reasoning retains its subject, interpretation and applicable conditions. Use C.29 when representation choice, transfer or supported use remains unresolved, and the measurement pattern when a measurement claim is current.Keeps mathematical support distinct from ethical priority.

D.2:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
One-level ethicsThe case is treated as good because one declared level improves.Trace the change in work or use to whoever may bear the consequence in question. A supported observation of the whole can establish its outcome. To infer the outcome from separate effects, establish how they combine.
Ladder importA fixed level list is imported before the case is understood.Follow the membership, exposure, use or part–whole relation through which this consequence could arise.
Entry as solutionD.2 is used to decide the conflict.Name the concern and select D.3, D.4, D.5, C.30.ILC, or another subject pattern for its next use.
Hidden episteme harmA standard, model, policy, or architecture description is treated only as a document, not as an affected episteme with use consequences.Separate the episteme, its publication relation, use relation, and affected systems or people.

D.2:7 - Consequences

Making cross-scope concerns explicit lets the practitioner choose the next question, such as an ethical conflict, an architectural consequence or a need for audit.

D.2:9 - Rationale

A change can look technically local while shifting costs, risks or responsibilities across affected entities. Recovering those relations lets the practitioner formulate the ethical question before choosing mediation, an audit or an architectural response.

D.2:10 - SoTA-Echoing

Fung’s account of public participation distinguishes who takes part, how participants receive or exchange information or reach a decision, and how their participation influences or authorizes public action. These distinctions help trace a proposal from the people consulted to those affected by its use. Establish the applicable mandate and protections in the practice at hand. Varieties of Participation in Complex Governance

For recognizing a transferred consequence, adopt A.1.CSD’s tracing of a proposed change through actual relations and supported possible effects, when the affected account is incomplete. Compared with judging only the proposal’s local target or assigning priority by level, :2 and the service-restriction case retain the access loss alongside the claimed quality benefit. D.1 supplies the value premise; D.3 and D.4 describe and decide the resulting conflict.

This construction makes the traced concern available for the next question without a fixed level catalogue or a full impact study. Its conclusion covers the bearers and effect paths recovered. Reuse an adequate existing account; reconsider it when a new relation, consequence or value premise changes the affected concern.

D.2:11 - Relations

  • Builds on D.1 for ethical value frame boundary.
  • Use A.1, B.1 and C.13 to recover holons and composition, and A.2.6 to establish where a claim applies.
  • Coordinates with D.3 for the interlevel ethical conflict description and with D.4 for mediation or decision use.
  • Coordinates with D.5 for bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, and ethical assurance.
  • Coordinates with C.11.DUA when a proposed inquiry or disputed protective requirement needs contribution, feasibility, and burden appraisal.
  • Coordinates with A.15, A.3.4, C.16, C.29, and C.30.ILC when method, work, transformation, measurement, mathematical lens, or architecture residual claims are current.

D.2:End

D.3 - Describe an Ethical Conflict Across Levels or Scopes

Type: D-family ethical conflict-description pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. A decision puts ethical claims about affected parties, activities or uses in tension and their incompatibility, trade-off or unresolved priority needs explaining. The claims can concern different constituents, overlapping populations or different uses of the same arrangement. State each concern in ordinary language.

Not this pattern when. If only the ethical value frame is missing, use D.1. If only entry recognition is needed, use D.2. If D.3 has already described the conflict and the question is mediation or decision use, use D.4. If the question is bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance, use D.5.

What goes wrong if missed. The team debates values or decisions before it can say who or what is affected, under which value frame and scope, over what horizon, and why the claims are in tension.

What this buys. A reader can see each side, what it affects, and how the sides are in tension before deciding what to do.

D.3:1 - Problem Frame

Ethical conflicts can cross part–whole relations or overlapping scopes. A decision may improve an organization’s performance while harming affected people; an episteme may shape decisions that benefit some users and disadvantage others. Declare the relations and scopes present in the case; structural levels do not establish a moral hierarchy.

The practical problem is connecting each claim to what it affects. An inventory of affected entities and values does not explain which claim concerns which entity or why those concerns are in tension for the present question. Describe each side as one connected statement and explain their tension.

The reusable result is a description episteme, not the conflict in the situation and not the form used to show it. The phrase conflict structure remains useful ordinary shorthand for the connected claim content inside that description.

D.3:1.0 - Problem

An ethical conflict is often argued before it is described. The affected objects, scopes, value frames, claimed benefits and harms, evidence limits, and consequence horizons remain implicit, so mediation begins from slogans rather than from inspectable claims.

D.3:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Conflict description vs. decision useMake the sides and their tension inspectable for mediation or decision use under D.4.
Level and scope plurality vs. fixed ladderRecover the relevant relations and scopes from the case; structural levels do not establish ethical priority.
Conflict vs. descriptionA narrative, table, graph, or formal expression can describe the conflict but is not the situation, claims, harms, or relations it describes.
First result vs. reusable precisionThe first result needs connected sides and a tension statement; later reuse may need an identified episteme and typed supporting relations.
Agency evidence vs. responsibilityEvidence may support an agency characteristic or threshold. Responsibility needs its direct predicate and participants; no score, label, collection name, or assignment supplies it.
Architecture residual vs. ethical conflictA cross-scope structure can be architectural, ethical, or both. C.30.ILC triages the architecture residual; D.3 describes the ethical conflict.

D.3:2 - Solution

D.3:2.1 - First result

Identify the sides needed to explain the conflict. At least two claims are involved; include more when the tension depends on their combination. For each side, write:

  1. the ethical claim that states the concern in ordinary language;
  2. the affected entity;
  3. how the proposed action reaches that entity. Identify the whole and constituent if composition matters, the people or work covered if their extent matters, and the conditions on which this side’s claim relies;
  4. the value premise under which the consequence matters, with a frame-edition reference when the reasoning uses one;
  5. the expected benefit, harm, or constraint and its consequence horizon; and
  6. the evidence use or uncertainty only when the side relies on it.

Explain which claims can hold together and what makes them incompatible or leaves the answer open. When several arrangements meet the constraints, explain what each would preserve or sacrifice under the competing value premises, or why their priority remains unsettled. Three claims can be jointly incompatible although each pair can be met. For one agreed combination, a feasible arrangement can establish compatibility. If the parties retain choices about future work, identify who decides, what each can know in time and which combinations the arrangement must accommodate. A plan for one combination establishes that combination. A constraint covering every permitted arrangement can establish impossibility. Give the conclusion this supports for the original decision and the alternatives that still matter.

A short working note can be sufficient. Develop a more elaborate description only when its intended use requires the additional content.

D.3:2.2 - Reusable conflict description

Identify the account of the conflict when another reader needs to cite, compare, revise or publish that account. A short note can serve. The account is one C.2.1 U.Episteme, here called an InterlevelEthicalConflictDescription. If a publication reports one observation, identify the source for that observation.

Apply the C.2.1 identity test:

  • EntityOfConcern: one exact entity already recovered for the case, such as the plan, proposed system change, or decision situation whose ethical tension is being described. Do not use a loose bundle of several possible subjects.
  • ClaimGraph: the claims about the affected entities, the conflicting sides and their tension, and the question for the next use. Where the description limits the cases to which those claims apply, identify its ClaimScope.
  • effective ReferenceScheme: the designation, interpretation, measurement, comparison, and evaluation rules needed to read those claims.

Changed claim content, EntityOfConcern, or effective ReferenceScheme identifies another episteme. Say that a later description revises or supersedes an earlier one only when a C.2.1 EpistemeEditionRelation is asserted. A changed narrative, table layout, publication form, carrier, or publication occurrence does not by itself change the episteme.

Use this content shape when a reusable record helps:

InterlevelEthicalConflictDescription — C.2.1 identity:
  entityOfConcernRef
  claimGraph:
    descriptionClaimScopeRef?
    conflictSides: at least two rows
      - sideId
        ethicalClaim: plain statement that identifies the claim; add a ClaimAddress only when reusing an existing claim
        affectedEntityRef
        declaredLevelRelationRef?
        sideClaimScopeRef?
        affectedWorkExtentRef?
        valuePremise
        valueFrameEditionRef?
        expectedConsequence: what changes and why it counts, for example, as a benefit, harm, or constraint under that value premise
        consequenceHorizon
        evidenceUseRef?
        uncertaintyStatement?
    tension:
      sideIds
      plainStatement
      directRelationDefinitionRef?
      obtainingRelationOccurrenceRef?
      missingGovernorRef?
    nextUse: plain statement; cite a question episteme only when another use needs that identity
  effectiveReferenceSchemeRef

When a restriction on the whole description matters, descriptionClaimScopeRef identifies the conditions under which its claims apply. Identify any subsystem affected on one side. The subject of the whole description can still be a fleet-wide decision. Change that subject only if the claim is now about the subsystem itself. Each side can also have its own ClaimScope or refer to a particular Work and its extent. Give the whole description its own scope when that further restriction matters.

For another setting, carry over the reasoning that connects the action to a consequence under a value premise. Check whether the same dependency, value premise and relevant constraints apply there. One affected party may belong to several groups. Count distinct people once for a headcount. For a claim about burdens, establish whether that person experiences one burden reported twice or distinct burdens. State what can be concluded about the whole under the relevant counting or composition rule.

The plainStatement must name the incompatibility, trade-off, parity, or other tension claimed among the sides. In an ordinary case, it remains claim content in the description. If a receiving use relies on a separately obtaining direct relation, cite the relation definition and occurrence with its participants, applicability, and identity. If no adequate governor exists, record the A.6.RCD missing-governor result. Merely filling a reference field never makes a direct relation obtain.

D.3:2.3 - Add detail only when it changes the conflict or its next use

Open this branch when…Add…Keep separate…
A Method is part of a side’s claim.the exact U.Method under A.3.1 and, when cited, its MethodDescription under A.3.2Method identity from any dated performance
Performance occurred.use A.13 to identify the performer System; use A.15.1 to admit the exact dated U.Work independently from its history, Method, extent, and containing System; if the conflict account must also identify the assignment under which the Work was performed, check that relation separately through F.6keep a plan, intention, assignment, capability, permission, authority, and responsibility separate from performed Work
Assignment matters.the exact assignment species and the claim with its case basis under A.2.1; cite an obtaining occurrence when the account relies on oneassignment from performance, responsibility, permission, or authority
Role wording or classification needs clarification.use E.10.ROLE to recover the meaning; when System classification is claimed, identify the local kind and the separate C.2.1 classification assertion under C.3.2 with its candidate-admissibility basisordinary wording, classification, assignment, and the acting System from one another
Evidence changes a side or its uncertainty.identify the supporting content and the grounds for this use; apply A.10 when the source-to-use relation is implicit or must be replayableavailable or stored evidence from what it warrants for this side
A change affects who may benefit or be harmed.identify the proposed change and its supported possible consequences; when an actual transformation is claimed, identify its occurrence and affected participants under A.3.4a possible or described change from an obtaining transformation
Membership or part-whole structure matters.the applicable collection-membership or part-whole predicate and its supported claim or unresolved condition; an affirmative occurrence claim needs its obtaining basisa plural name from an acting or responsible System
Agency is disputed.identify the agency claim and its supporting basis; use A.13 for an FPF agency claim, adding a Characteristic, Scale or threshold only when the claim or criterion requires itan agency claim from responsibility
Responsibility, permission, authority, commitment, or participation is claimed.the applicable direct predicate, participants and supported affirmative, negative or modal claim, or the unresolved condition; an affirmative occurrence claim needs its obtaining basis, and a separate occurrence reference is added when its identity is usedthe relation family from an occurrence; the occurrence from evidence for it
A calculation or formal comparison changes the tension.retain the calculation’s subject correspondence, applicable assumptions and operation; use C.29 when the representation’s choice, transfer or supported use remains unresolveda formula or score from the ethical conflict or decision
Publication or audience use changes the ethical claim.recover the claims made available, audience and bounded use under E.24.PUB, including the expression, carrier, form or occurrence identity that changes this judgement; use E.17 when a readable face of an accepted account must be producedthe published episteme from its expression, form, carrier, publishing Work, and availability relation
A harm or benefit depends on causality, assurance, or architecture.only the affected C.28, B.3, D.5, or C.30.ILC returnthe conflict description from causal proof, assurance, or architecture selection

Open no branch merely because the field exists. The detail must change a side, the tension, or the next receiving use.

D.3:3 - Collection and Episteme Cases

A collection is ethically current only when whole-level characteristics, membership relations, environment-mediated effects, or aggregate consequences matter. Use A.14 for part-whole and membership relations and C.13 for constructive grounding. A plural or institutional name does not make the collection an acting or responsible System.

An episteme is ethically current when its claim content, source use, publication, described EntityOfConcern, or model use changes the affected systems or decisions. Use C.2.1 for episteme identity and exact edition claims, and E.24.PUB for the publication relation; use E.17 when producing a readable face of an accepted account. The D.3 conflict description is a separate episteme about the selected case; it does not become identical to the policy, model, standard, or architecture description involved in one of its sides.

D.3:4 - Boundaries

Do this in D.3Do not do this in D.3
Derive the declared levels and scopes from the case.Impose a fixed moral ladder.
Connect every side’s claim, affected entity, scope, value frame, consequence, and horizon.Present flat bags of entities, values, evidence, and relations as if their connections were obvious.
Keep the conflict description, the situation it describes, and its narrative, table, graph, form, carrier, and publication separate.Treat a file or diagram as the conflict, or treat description content as proof that a direct relation obtains.
Add Method, Work, assignment, classification, evidence use, agency, responsibility, publication, assurance, causal, or architecture detail only when current.Require assurance-like apparatus before the first map exists.
Stop at an inspectable tension and next-use question.Choose the compromise, refusal, override, or accepted residual; those are D.4 uses.
Use C.30.ILC when an architecture residual is also current.Route every cross-scope architecture problem to ethics.

D.3:5 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slices)

First engineering description. A consultant is asked to improve a surveillance project’s effectiveness.

Case: whether to accept the named consulting plan
Scope: the proposed consulting work and the intended deployment it would enable
Side A: the client receives more effective engineering advice; affected entity: client project;
        value frame: client delivery edition 3;
        consequence and horizon: near-term performance benefit during design.
Side B: the proposed capability increases foreseeable harm to monitored people;
        affected entity: the named affected population; value frame: project ethics edition 2;
        consequence and horizon: rights and safety harm over service life.
Tension: performing the plan would advance Side A by enabling the harm named in Side B.
Next use: D.4 refusal or conditions; C.28 first if the harm claim needs causal support.

This description lets the parties begin mediation under D.4. If another reader must cite or revise the note, identify the InterlevelEthicalConflictDescription and the decision it concerns, whether to undertake the proposed work in this setting. Cite the proposal for the terms it supplies. The proposal itself becomes the EntityOfConcern when the question is what work it offers or what its terms would require if accepted. For a claim about an existing obligation, establish which terms took effect.

If consulting Work later occurs, use A.13 to identify its performer and A.15.1 to admit the dated occurrence independently. Add F.6 only if the note must also identify the assignment under which that Work was performed. Add agency or relation detail only when that claim changes the account, using its pattern and preserving its affirmative, negative, conditional or unresolved result.

If the consulting agreement explicitly excludes deployment decisions, it grants no authority for those decisions. If the agreement’s scope is unavailable, leave that authority claim unresolved and identify the missing agreement. D.4 can use either result: a justified denial concerns this agreement, while an unavailable premise leaves a question to settle.

Joint incompatibility. Three neighborhoods each have a claim to a separate hour-long visit from the same mobile clinic at their own site, under a stated equal-access rule. One crew has 150 minutes, including travel and setup. Each two-site itinerary needs at most 30 minutes for travel and setup, so the crew can serve any pair. The three visits alone require 180 minutes. No itinerary can provide them all within the window. Choosing which visit to defer needs an ethical and decision basis. If a common session is proposed, establish whether it would count under the rule and whether residents from the affected sites could use it.

Conditional collection record. A fleet-wide maintenance change lowers cost but may raise failure risk for a small subfleet operating in harsh conditions. The description has a fleet-cost side and a harsh-service safety side, each with its affected entity, scope, value premise and any frame edition used, consequence, and horizon. Add the exact fleet-membership relation because it locates the subfleet. Identify the reliability evidence and its grounds for this safety claim; use A.10 if the source-to-use relation is implicit or needs a replayable account. Return the causal question to C.28 if the risk claim depends on the proposed change.

None of those additions makes the fleet an acting or responsible whole; use A.1 for systemhood and the responsibility predicate for responsibility.

Episteme record. A published architecture description normalizes an interface assumption that excludes an alternative implementation. The EntityOfConcern of the D.3 description is the exact supplier-selection situation, not the architecture-description file. One side claims lower integration cost; the other claims unjust exclusion of affected suppliers under a named value-frame edition and horizon. Cite the architecture-description episteme and its publication or use only because that use carries the assumption into the decision. Use C.30.AD for description adequacy and E.24.PUB for the publication relation; D.3 records the ethical tension that remains.

D.3:5.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Debate replaces a connected accountThe team argues about values before connecting each claim to an affected entity, scope, frame, consequence, and horizon.Write the side rows and tension statement before mediation.
Description becomes conflictA diagram, matrix, or narrative is treated as the ethical conflict.Identify the description as a C.2.1 episteme and keep its EntityOfConcern and presentation form separate.
Collection name becomes responsibilityOrganization, society, public, market, or AI is treated as responsible by label.Recover the subject and the responsibility predicate used, then establish its case basis or the unresolved question. Add membership, participation, assignment and agency claims only when that inference needs them.
Formal completeness displaces useA large record is filled even though two sides and one tension already answer the question.Stop at the first adequate description and add only detail consumed by the next use.
Architecture absorbs ethicsCross-scope residual wording hides value, harm, responsibility, or admissible sacrifice.Use the applicable architecture pattern for the residual and use D.3 with D.4 for the ethical conflict and its use.

D.3:6 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D3-1A reusable result is one C.2.1 episteme with one exact EntityOfConcern, ClaimGraph, and effective ReferenceScheme. Edition, form, carrier, and publication remain separate.Makes the reference used by D.4 reidentifiable.
CC-D3-2At least two sides each connect one ethical claim, affected entity, declared level relation or applicable scope, value premise, consequence, and horizon. Identify a value-frame edition when used; add evidence use and uncertainty when current.Shows what each claim affects rather than presenting a flat inventory.
CC-D3-3Any ClaimScope on the whole description remains separate from side-specific ClaimScopes and Work extents.Prevents the description’s coverage from replacing the scope of a side.
CC-D3-4The tension names the sides and explains the incompatibility, trade-off, parity or unresolved tension relevant to the next use. A direct relation claim retains its predicate, participants, polarity or modality, and case basis or unresolved condition. An affirmative occurrence claim needs its obtaining basis; cite occurrence identity only when the receiving use needs it.Prevents a reference field from manufacturing a fact in the situation.
CC-D3-5Classification assertion, Method, Work, relation definition, relation occurrence, evidence episteme, evidence use, publication, form, and carrier remain separately typed when used.Prevents the conflict description from absorbing neighboring objects.
CC-D3-6The first result is readable without the optional enriched branches, and every added branch changes the conflict or its next use.Keeps D.3 affordable in ordinary project work.
CC-D3-7The next-use statement names D.4, D.5, C.28, C.30.ILC, evidence, assurance, or another receiving pattern by value.Keeps mapping separate from mediation, decision, proof, and assurance.

D.3:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
Political label as structureThe conflict is named by a slogan such as society versus innovation.Write the sides, affected entities, scopes, value frames, consequences, and horizon.
Flat inventoryThe map lists values, entities, evidence, and relations without showing which belong together.Use side rows and one tension statement.
Actor by plural nounA collection is made responsible because its name is plural or institutional.Recover the subject and the responsibility predicate with the basis for the claim; retain a negative result or unresolved condition when warranted.
Description-only conflictThe case becomes only a wording problem about a report, model, or standard.Keep episteme identity and publication with their patterns while D.3 describes the affected systems, decisions, and ethical tension.
Mediation inside mapThe description chooses the compromise.Stop at the tension and next-use question; use D.4 for mediation or decision use.
Ontology as prose taxEvery simple concern is expanded into specialist relation language.State the ordinary side first; add a formal identity only when another use relies on the distinction.

D.3:7 - Consequences

A connected conflict description lets mediation or decision work start from the claims and their tension. For later reliance, keep its subject, claims, interpretation and supporting relations identifiable.

D.3:9 - Rationale

When a later judgement must cite or revise the description, C.2.1 identifies the claim-bearing episteme: the claims say what the sides are, its EntityOfConcern identifies the case, and its effective ReferenceScheme says how to read them.

Side rows make the conflict inspectable because they preserve which claim affects which entity and scope. Add supporting detail where it changes that account or its intended use.

D.3:10 - SoTA-Echoing

The comparison below selects contributions from the named sources and editions for making value conflict inspectable before deciding it.

How can design work expose affected parties, values, and long-horizon effects before choosing a solution?

Source and status. Batya Friedman and David G. Hendry, Value Sensitive Design: Shaping Technology with Moral Imagination (MIT Press, 2019), established method account (https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/7585.001.0001).

Selected contribution and limit. Stakeholder analysis, value scenarios, and multilifespan timelines support explicit affected parties, values, and horizons. VSD does not supply FPF episteme identity, direct-relation identity, or a complete method for resolving value conflicts.

Decision, receiving locus, and reopen. Adapt affected-entity, value-frame, and horizon prompts into D.3:2 and the worked cases; reject VSD as a conflict ontology or decision authority. Reopen if a later method connects conflict sides to affected entities more clearly at comparable effort.

How should ethical concerns remain traceable through system design?

Source and status. ISO/IEC/IEEE 24748-7000:2022, Edition 1, published 2022-11, Standard model process for addressing ethical concerns during system design (https://www.iso.org/standard/84893.html; IEEE 7000-2021 remains the earlier lineage edition).

Selected contribution and limit. The standard traces elicited values through operational concepts, value propositions, requirements, and ethical risk-based design. Its full life-cycle process and organizational apparatus are much heavier than one D.3 map, and official status does not make it the default method.

Decision, receiving locus, and reopen. Adapt traceability from each value-frame claim to the affected design move and receiving decision in D.3:2.2-2.3; reject compulsory transfer of the full process. Reopen on a new edition or evidence that a lighter method gives better traceability.

Must every value conflict become a single-scale trade-off or optimization?

Source and status. Atay Kozlovski, “Parity and the Resolution of Value Conflicts in Design,” Science and Engineering Ethics 28, 22 (2022), DOI 10.1007/s11948-022-00375-4.

Selected contribution and limit. The paper compares three VSD conflict approaches and argues that incommensurable values may stand in parity rather than in a better, worse, or equal ordering. It is a proposed repair, not a universal conflict-resolution procedure.

Decision, receiving locus, and reopen. Adapt the explicit tension branch and the rule against forcing one scale in D.3:2.1-2.2; send mediation to D.4. Reopen when stronger applied evidence changes how parity helps design decisions.

How can cross-scope benefits, harms, and uncertainty be mapped in a living technical programme?

Source and status. NIST, Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework 1.0 (NIST AI 100-1, 2023-01-26) and its live Core, checked 2026-08-20 (https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.AI.100-1; https://airc.nist.gov/airmf-resources/airmf/5-sec-core/). NIST states that a revised version is in progress.

Selected contribution and limit. MAP 1 and MAP 5 connect intended uses with positive and negative impacts across individuals, groups, communities, organizations, society, and the planet, while keeping uncertainty and changing conditions visible. The framework is AI-specific and its actor, governance, and responsibility language does not establish FPF systemhood or direct responsibility relations.

Decision, receiving locus, and reopen. Adapt the multi-scope affected-entity, consequence, uncertainty, and horizon prompts into D.3:2 and the collection case; reject the AI taxonomy, full governance apparatus, and any responsibility inference. Reopen when the announced revision is published or another domain method outperforms it for this use.

D.3:11 - Relations

  • Builds on D.1 and D.2 for value-frame boundary and multilevel entry.
  • Uses C.2.1 to identify the reusable conflict-description episteme and any classification assertion episteme.
  • Uses E.10.ROLE once when role-shaped wording must be recovered before kind, assertion, assignment, agency, or responsibility claims are made.
  • Uses A.6.RCD when a needed direct relation has no adequate governor.
  • Builds on A.1, A.14, B.1, and C.13 when systemhood, part-whole, membership, collections, or constructive grounding are current.
  • Coordinates with D.4 for mediation and decision use and with D.5 for bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, and ethical assurance.
  • Coordinates with E.17 and E.24.PUB for publication, form, carrier, audience, and availability claims.
  • Coordinates with C.30.ILC, A.10, B.3, C.28, and C.29 when architecture residual, evidence, assurance, causal, or mathematical-lens claims are current.

D.3:End

D.4 - Ethical Mediation and Decision Use

Type: D-family ethical mediation and decision-use pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. You need to develop and assess ways of responding to a described ethical conflict.

Not this pattern when. If the conflict has not been described, use D.3. If the issue is only value plurality, use D.1. If the issue is only entry recognition, use D.2. If the work is bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance, use D.5.

What goes wrong if missed. Naming the conflict or filling in a decision record replaces the work of developing options and judging what each would require or change.

What this buys. The practitioner can compare available ways to act, recognize a useful change to the proposed means, and explain a recommendation or why the choice remains unresolved.

D.4:1 - Problem Frame

Once an interlevel ethical conflict is visible, the next risk is premature closure. A team may declare a compromise before evidence is sufficient, turn an assurance input into ethical permission, use one level’s value as a trump card, or hide a refusal behind technical language.

From the conflict account, ask which continuations can be justified and what remains to be established. Use the subject method for any missing basis.

D.4:1.0 - Problem

Describing the conflict does not develop or compare ways of responding to it. Evidence and formal comparisons contribute to that judgement only within their stated scope.

D.4:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Described conflict vs. premature closureA conflict description makes action discussable, but does not by itself decide compromise, refusal, or permission.
Evidence demand vs. decision pressureThe decision may be time-sensitive while a claim it relies on still lacks the required support.
Mediation vs. universal authorityD.4 can guide one bounded use of a described conflict, but cannot become a general decision theory.
Residual acceptance vs. hidden harmProceeding under residual harm requires a justified decision with the consequential residual, affected parties, authority and responsibility basis recoverable. Include a plan, commitment or reconsideration condition when the decision relies on it; an unresolved required basis leaves that action unsupported. When the account asserts performed work, identify that occurrence and its performer; add assignment attribution when that claim is made.
Mathematical allocation vs. ethical decisionA formula or optimization can inform a decision, but it is not the ethical decision by itself.

D.4:2 - Solution

Recover the conflict, develop feasible alternatives, compare their consequences and constraints under the stated value premises, and give a warranted recommendation or decision. Keep the concerns that remain unresolved visible in that result. A short answer can complete this work.

D.4:2.1 - Develop and compare a continuation

  1. Recover the decision and the affected concerns. Use the D.3 account to identify who or what may gain or lose, over which horizon, and why those consequences matter. Check whether the proposed chooser can make the decision in question. Paying for a project, being represented in a survey, being affected by its result and having authority to decide are different relations. Return a consequential missing party to A.1.CSD; return an unresolved value premise to D.1.
  2. Separate the end from the proposed means. A valued result can be pursued through means that create another objection. Ask which feature, condition or operation produces that objection and what could supply the valued result without it. B.5.QD.CF develops that question when an assumed necessary means creates the conflict; C.39 supplies construction of another way. Consider continuing the present work, narrowing the change, changing its conditions or refusing it when those are feasible alternatives. A proposed alternative remains a proposal until its required contributions are available.
  3. Compare the same alternatives under the value premises. Preserve each side’s affected participants, consequences, constraints and uncertainty. An encompassing system’s gain does not by itself establish priority over a constituent’s loss. Where different value frames give different orderings, keep those orderings distinct. An alternative that is no worse under every retained ordering and better under at least one can remove a need to trade those values for this choice. This conclusion is limited to the alternatives, premises and affected concerns compared. If a trade-off remains, state the priority, compromise or other reason proposed for making it. Authority to choose does not make that reason correct or establish others’ agreement.
  4. Resolve only the uncertainty that changes this use. Separate disagreement about consequences from disagreement about which consequences or duties should govern. A causal inquiry can improve the former; it does not by itself settle the latter. Use available support and qualified uncertainty. Where an intended use requires a stronger claim, C.28 or the corresponding subject method supplies its basis; C.11.DUA compares an attainable inquiry with a narrower recommendation, a different option or a stop. Include delay, burden shifted to other parties and displaced work. Preserve a binding requirement’s current force while examining its merits or a feasible revision.
  5. Return the supported recommendation or decision. If the comparison basis and available options are settled, C.11 supplies the local choice. If the value conflict remains unresolved, give the conditional alternatives, the missing agreement or authority, or a refusal or impasse. Do not manufacture a common scalar to force a winner. State a residual consequence and a reconsideration condition when they matter to this use. A recommendation does not establish consent, permission or performed work.

Use the same reasoning when the option is advice, publication, a technical change or a change to a method. Identify how its possible use can affect other participants; describing one’s contribution as analysis leaves that question open. The relevant causal and responsibility relations need their basis.

Decide the reach of the proposed action. For a decision on behalf of a group, establish which procedure gives the decision force, whose work or rights it covers, and who can carry it out. Record a member’s dissent when it matters to the decision or its consequences. If the recipient wants a standing rule, examine the cases the rule would permit. A change in exposure, access, authority or available means can reverse the comparison. Where the same premises support the recommendation throughout the proposed use, the existing reasoning can cover those cases.

D.4:2.2 - Retain the decision basis when the work needs it

Use an EthicalMediationDecisionUse account when another participant needs to inspect, compare, authorize or later revise the result. The necessary content can remain in the existing answer or decision record. The following form groups that content; use only the optional detail needed for this decision:

EthicalMediationDecisionUse:
  conflictDescriptionRef: exact C.2.1 U.Episteme identified through D.3
  affectedEntityOfConcernRef
  affectedSystemRefs?
  valuePremises
  valueFrameEditionRefs?
  decisionQuestionRef?
  intendedDecisionUse?
  intendedWorkUse?
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  optionRefs
  proposedMediationRefs?
  refusalOrStopCondition?
  evidenceDemandRefs?
  causalReturnRefs?
  assuranceReturnRefs?
  architectureResidualReturnRefs?
  acceptedResidualRefs?
  decisionRecordRefs?
  decisionOrRepairSystemRefs?: independently admitted U.System refs
  localSystemRoleKindRefs?: exact local U.Kind refs
  systemRoleClassificationAssertionRefs?: FinSet(U.EpistemeRef)
  intendedWorkPlanOrCommitmentRefs?: prospective plan or commitment content
  intendedAssignmentRequirementRefs?: prospective requirement content; creates no assignment occurrence
  performedWorkRows?:
    - performerSystemRef: exact U.System
      workOccurrenceRef: exact dated U.Work
      assignmentSpeciesRef?: exact directly declared species under U.SystemRoleAssignment, when assignment-bound attribution is claimed
      assignmentOccurrenceRef?: obtaining occurrence of that species with participant values, applicability, and extent covering the Work
      f6AttributionRef?: exact performedUnderAssignment occurrence, for that attribution
      holderEquality?: performerSystemRef = assignmentOccurrenceRef.HolderSystemSlot, for that attribution
      methodRef:
      workExtentRef:
      containingSystemRef:
  responsibilityRelationRefs?: direct predicate, participants, applicability, and occurrence identity
  responsibilityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  authorityRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  authorityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  permissionRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  permissionMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  commitmentRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  commitmentMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  admissibleUse
  inadmissibleOverread?
  strongerSourceReturnCondition?

Name the affected EntityOfConcern and any affected Systems, the value premises and any frame editions used, the decision question and options, and the intended decision or Work use. Add ClaimScope and a qualification window when they delimit that use. State the proposed mediation or refusal and any accepted residuals. If evidence, causal adequacy, assurance, architecture residuals, responsibility, permission, or actual Work remains unresolved, return only that question to the pattern that defines it.

D.4:3 - Mediation Moves

SituationAdmissible D.4 moveNeighboring subject pattern
A compromise is proposed but the D.3 description omits a side, affected entity, scope, value frame, consequence, or horizon.Return to D.3 and complete the affected side or tension.D.3
A causal claim can change the recommendation or decision.Use its C.28 support and retain the uncertainty that changes this use. If stronger support is needed, use C.11.DUA to compare a feasible inquiry with a narrower use, another option or stopping.C.28, C.11.DUA
Evidence is too weak or outdated for the proposed use.Name the affected claim and use. Use C.11.DUA to compare a feasible evidence request with a narrower use, explicit residual acceptance or refusal; obtain stronger or fresher evidence when the selected use needs it.C.11.DUA; the evidence’s subject pattern for support, A.10 when its source-to-use relation is implicit or must be replayable, and C.27 when temporal adequacy changes that use
Assurance claim is being used as ethical permission.Keep assurance as an assurance or evidence relation, not moral authorization.B.3, D.5
Architecture move reduces one residual but creates ethical conflict elsewhere.Return the architecture residual and keep the ethical conflict distinct.C.30.ILC, D.3
A decision must proceed with residual harm.Keep the accepted residual, affected parties, decision basis and material evidence limits recoverable. Include the authority, responsibility, plan, commitment, permission, assignment requirement or return condition that this decision relies on, preserving each claim’s status and any unresolved condition. If Work has occurred, recover each performer’s A.13 core and independently admit the Work under A.15.1; add F.6 only when the decision account also needs assignment-bound attribution.C.11, B.3, D.5, A.2.1, A.13, A.15.1, and F.6 as applicable

When the basis required for a particular claim cannot be obtained, that claim remains unsupported. A narrower recommendation or decision must satisfy its evidence, ethical and authority conditions. Preserve an accepted residual where it changes the use.

D.4:4 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slices)

Fair-share case. A service outage plan can protect hospitals, households, or industrial customers, but not all at once. The D.3 conflict description connects each affected scope and value concern to its consequence and horizon. To develop a recommendation, trace how each feasible allocation would protect people and who would bear the remaining loss. Compare those consequences under the applicable commitments. Consider a changed allocation when it could provide protection that the stated options leave out. Give the recommendation and its grounds to the person entitled to decide. For a request about a decision already made, the authorized decision and its terms can supply the answer. No assignment or Work is asserted merely because the plan names intended action. If the account reports execution, add the Work occurrence and its performer; add assignment-bound attribution when that further claim is made. A mathematical allocation Method may have a separate C.29 representation or lens-use assertion, but the allocation formula is not the ethical decision, assignment, or responsibility relation.

Override case. An assurance review says a release has the required technical assurance relation, but the D.3 description shows unresolved harm for a subgroup. Determine which protection the technical review establishes, whose interests remain affected and who can authorize the proposed terms. Ask whether a feasible change would avoid the harm and what evidence would distinguish that change from proceeding as proposed. Use C.28 if the comparison depends on a causal claim. These grounds can support refusal, a condition, further inquiry or an authorized release with a stated residual. An unresolved required condition leaves that release unsupported.

D.4:4.1 - Change the means, then reconsider when another constraint changes

A team wants colleagues to find an available specialist, while staff want private calendar details to remain private. The initially proposed means publishes every calendar detail to the whole organization. Turning the service off protects those details but loses the intended availability information.

The D.3 tension concerns staff information and the team’s coordination, not two interchangeable scores. Recover the needed contribution: finding somebody available for a question requires neither an appointment title nor its other participants. Suppose an existing feature lets each member publish an availability window without exposing the underlying events; the team has permission and support to offer this voluntary feature. This supplies a third available option.

For this constructed decision, the participants’ stated orderings are:

Value concern and supplied judgementFirstSecondThird
Useful access to a willing specialistVoluntary availability windowsFull calendar publicationService off
Staff control of private event detailsVoluntary availability windowsService offFull calendar publication

Both orderings prefer the voluntary option to either original alternative. The team can recommend it on this basis without adding the ordinal ranks or deciding how much privacy one unit of access is worth. The judgement concerns these supplied preferences and feature conditions. The technical feature, the permitted voluntary arrangement and each participant’s choice are separate contributions to its use.

Now suppose the team instead needs guaranteed coverage of a required shift. Voluntary windows do not guarantee that contribution. The previous recommendation remains an answer to finding a willing specialist, but does not answer the changed staffing question. Return to the staffing arrangement and its affected commitments. A new assignment, another resource or a changed service promise may be needed.

If a second team asks only how to find a willing specialist, it can use the same recommendation when the feature is available, the applicable permission covers that use and the affected participants’ privacy and access judgements still support that option. A decision to offer the feature across the organization can authorize making it available to both teams. Each disclosure still depends on the choice or other authority governing that disclosure.

D.4:4.2 - Keep a useful decision when a stronger claim is unavailable

A comparison has two feasible options under an agreed value frame: retain the current arrangement or make a reversible change. The available basis bounds the change’s net benefit between 2 and 4 units for every scenario retained in the comparison; all relevant constraints and affected concerns are already included in this stipulated example. The present question is which option is preferable under that basis, not what its precise effect will be.

The change is preferred throughout the supplied range. A study costing 5 of the same units solely to select between these options cannot improve their choice: its possible refinements within that range leave the selected option unchanged and impose that cost. C.11.DUA therefore supports the bounded recommendation without the study. The conclusion retains its conditional range and makes no precise-effect claim.

If a newly identified consequence can reverse that preference, or the intended use now needs a supported precise effect, the question changes. Examine that missing contribution and the feasible investigation that could supply it. The earlier decision does not authorize a stronger claim or ignore a newly affected party.

D.4:5 - Boundaries

D.4 does not define the conflict description, bias audit, ethical assurance, architecture residual, causal identification, evidence provenance, or decision theory in general. It defines one ethical use of a conflict already described by D.3.

Use a mathematical representation when its operations improve the comparison. Explain its premises and interpret its result under the ethical value frames.

D.4:5.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Conflict description becomes decisionA D.3 description is treated as if it already selected an action.Name the D.4 move and its admissible use.
Assurance becomes permissionTechnical assurance is read as ethical authorization.Keep assurance as an assurance or evidence relation and record the ethical use separately.
Formula becomes ethicsAllocation, optimization, or scoring is treated as the ethical decision.Explain how the calculation’s result and conditions inform the ethical comparison; use C.29 when the representation’s choice, transfer or supported use remains unresolved.
Residual harm disappearsAction proceeds while consequential residuals, affected parties or the authority and responsibility needed for the decision remain unclear.Name the consequential residual and the decision basis, including the authority and responsibility it relies on. Add plans, commitments, permissions, assignment requirements and a return condition where this decision needs them; retain material evidence limits and unresolved claims. Identify Work and its performer when performance is claimed; add assignment-bound attribution when that further claim is made.

D.4:6 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D4-1The conflict and its sides are recoverable through D.3; add a stable conflict-description reference when the receiving use needs to cite or revise it.Keeps the decision connected to the tension without requiring a separate record for a short answer.
CC-D4-2The recommendation or decision connects the affected concerns, value premises, feasible alternatives and comparison to its intended use. Retain differing orderings and residuals when they change the conclusion; add scope, qualification window and reference detail when that use needs them.Makes the chosen continuation follow from its basis instead of merely listing decision fields.
CC-D4-3Evidence, causality, assurance, architecture, and decision claims use their subject patterns.Prevents D.4 from becoming universal decision authority.
CC-D4-4When proceeding under residual harm, keep the consequential residual, affected parties and justified decision basis recoverable. Add local kinds, classification assertions, plans, assignment requirements and relation identities only where their distinctions change this use. Every responsibility, authority, permission or commitment claim retains its predicate, polarity or modality and factual basis or unresolved condition; an affirmative occurrence claim requires its obtaining basis. Every Work row first recovers each performer’s A.13 core and independently admits the Work under A.15.1; it adds F.6 only when assignment-bound attribution is also current.Keeps bounded decision use reviewable without deriving responsibility or performance from an assignment or decision.

D.4:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
Decision-ready by mapThe account identifies a conflict but gives its recipient no grounds to act.Trace the consequences of the available choices for those who bear them. Apply the governing commitments and identify who may decide. Give the resulting advice or the authorized decision that answers the request.
Trump-card levelOne level’s value automatically overrides all others.Recover the affected sides through D.3 and compare their consequences and value premises through :2.1; a larger scale alone supplies no priority.
Unsupported stronger useA decision or recommendation relies on a claim whose needed support is missing.Qualify that claim and obtain the required basis for its use, or select a supported narrower continuation through C.11.DUA. An accepted residual does not make the missing claim true.
Permission by assuranceA passed assurance relation is treated as moral authorization.Keep B.3 assurance and D.4 ethical use distinct.

D.4:7 - Consequences

A recommendation can be reviewed against its value premises, alternatives and remaining concerns. Refusal, a justified evidence request and acceptance of an explicit residual remain possible outcomes.

D.4:9 - Rationale

Recognizing a conflict leaves a practical question: what can be done under the stated value premises and available conditions? Developing alternatives can change the means that created the conflict, while comparison can justify a bounded recommendation or show why the choice remains unresolved.

D.4:10 - SoTA-Echoing

For turning a value conflict into a different design, adapt Value Sensitive Design’s joint examination of technical and social arrangements. Against choosing only between the initial proposal and abandoning its aim, :2.1 and :4.1 follow the needed contribution to another means. The VSD Lab’s current account distinguishes designer and stakeholder values, direct and indirect stakeholders, and several levels of analysis. Miller, Friedman, Jancke and Gill’s Value Tensions in Design (2007), §§6.1–6.2, supplies a design comparison: useful usage information need not disclose who searched. Its local survey thresholds are not ethical constants or a voting rule for every project.

The retained contribution is changing the means while keeping the affected values visible. Developing another design costs work; select it when it could improve the available choice. Reopen when the new arrangement fails a retained value or excludes an affected party.

For reasoning with several value frames, adopt the comparison problem made explicit by MacAskill, Bykvist and Ord in Moral Uncertainty (2020), Chapter 3, Introduction and §I: ordinal orderings do not supply comparable numerical differences. Against adding arbitrary ranks, :2.1 preserves separate orderings and uses agreement where it suffices, as in :4.1. Adapt this limited contribution without making the book’s Borda rule or expected-choiceworthiness proposal a universal FPF rule. C.11 already supports a partial ordering; D.4 keeps unresolved ethical aggregation visible rather than duplicating a decision calculus. Reopen when the present choice needs a trade-off or comparison across frames that the available basis cannot justify.

For deciding how much investigation this mediation needs, adopt C.11.DUA’s comparison of attainable information work with its receiving contribution and full burden. Against either an automatic demand for causal certification or ignoring a missing basis, :2.1, :3 and :4.2 distinguish a supported bounded continuation from a stronger unsupported claim. C.28, A.10 and B.3 retain their causal, evidence and assurance meanings; they do not supply moral permission. This comparison can end with required inquiry, a narrower result or refusal. Reopen when a changed consequence, intended claim, requirement or available inquiry can change that continuation. Use C.29 when an unresolved representation choice, transfer or supported-use question can change the comparison; a calculated ranking remains conditional on its ethical premises.

D.4:11 - Relations

  • Uses D.3 to recover the conflict and its sides; identify the description episteme when the receiving use needs that reference.
  • Coordinates with D.1 and D.2 when value frame or multilevel entry is incomplete.
  • Coordinates with D.5 when bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance is current.
  • Coordinates with A.10, B.3, C.11, C.11.DUA, C.28, C.29, and C.30.ILC when evidence, assurance, choice, inquiry value, causal, mathematical-lens, or architecture-residual questions are current.
  • Uses B.5.QD.CF and C.39 when a conflict over the proposed means calls for another construction; A.1.CSD supplies inquiry into a consequential missing party.

D.4:End

D.5 - Bias Audit and Ethical Assurance

Type: D-family bias-audit and ethical-assurance boundary pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. You need to examine bias or fairness in a current or intended use, assess its effects on people, or establish what an ethical-assurance claim supports.

Not this pattern when.

  • If the ethical value frame is missing, use D.1.
  • For multilevel ethics entry, use D.2.
  • To describe the sides and tension of an interlevel ethical conflict, use D.3.
  • For mediation or decision use of that conflict, use D.4.
  • If the question is only evidence, causality, assurance, measurement, or architecture residual without bias, fairness, human or group impact, or ethical assurance, use the corresponding subject pattern.

What goes wrong if missed. Ordinary technical verification is accepted as sufficient while bias or harm to affected people remains unexamined.

What this buys. A bounded audit conclusion states what was examined, which affected groups and uses it covers, and the limits of its support.

D.5:1 - Problem Frame

Bias and fairness failures often survive ordinary verification. A metric may be accurate while hiding subgroup harm. A model may be predictive while reproducing past exclusion. A policy may look neutral while moving cost to people or groups who were not represented in the evidence. A publication may look technically clear while licensing a harmful use.

Ask which bias, fairness or impact claim is being made, what that use requires of it, and whether the available evidence supports it. Use C.28 for a causal-fairness claim and B.3 for an assurance claim.

D.5:1.0 - Problem

The failure is to treat technical verification as sufficient for a fairness or ethical-assurance conclusion without identifying the audited object, affected people and intended use. Examine the evidence and any mitigation or residual on which that conclusion relies.

D.5:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Ordinary verification vs. subgroup harmOrdinary verification can leave bias or harm to particular groups unexamined.
Bounded answer vs. stronger relianceA concern may need only a qualified answer; a release or assurance claim can need a fuller account of the basis, mitigations, and residuals it relies on.
Fairness wording vs. causal claimMetric disparity, associative fairness, interventional fairness, and counterfactual fairness are different claims.
Assurance relation vs. ethical permissionAssurance can record examined evidence and residuals, but cannot turn unresolved bias or harm into moral authorization.
Connected audit vs. distinct supporting claimsUse the methods needed for measurement, causal support, assurance or ethical conflict; connect their results through the audit question and intended use.

D.5:2 - Solution

Identify the object, the bias or fairness concern, and the use the answer must support. Give the result warranted by the available basis, with the affected groups and limitations that change that use. A metric comparison can finish at its qualified measurement result; recognizing a value conflict returns to D.3 or D.4.

For a claim about a group, state what the conclusion attributes to whom. An eligibility rule can establish who is entitled to a service under its stated conditions. Whether people received the service depends on what happened. For a measured rate, identify the unit counted, the numerator and denominator, the period and which eligible units entered the evidence. An overall rate can meet its target while a subgroup misses it. Rates for two overlapping groups can each meet the target while their intersection falls short. Subtracting a subgroup’s numerator and denominator from the corresponding population counts gives the counts outside that subgroup. Use them for another named group only if it covers exactly the remaining records. If the evidence already establishes the required outcome for every member of the covered population, the same member-by-member finding holds within each subgroup. A verified violation can refute such an all-member claim without establishing how frequent the violation is. For a different population or period, establish which conditions of the rule or of the empirical comparison still apply.

An intended audit, fairness, or assurance conclusion must satisfy its evidence conditions. A missing basis leaves that conclusion unsupported. Select further investigation and the record it needs for that claim or decision, using §3.1.

Use BiasAuditAssuranceFrame@Context to organize an audit whose recipient needs to inspect the connection among claims, evidence, constraints, and residuals. The applicable content may already be present in the result being used:

BiasAuditAssuranceFrame@Context:
  auditedEntityOfConcernRef
  intendedUseRef
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  affectedPopulationRefs?
  affectedSystemRefs?
  affectedHolonRefs?
  metricOrModelRefs?
  policyOrPublicationRefs?
  biasConcernRefs
  ethicalClaimRefs?
  fairnessClaimRef?
  impactClaimRef?
  causalFairnessUseRef?
  causalUseSupportResultRef?: CausalUseSupportResultRef
  evidenceRefs?
  assuranceClaimRefs?
  assuranceUseRef?
  mitigationOrConstraintRefs?
  acceptedResidualRefs?
  admissibleUse
  inadmissibleOverread?
  strongerSourceReturnCondition?

The frame organizes the audit account. Include relied-on evidence and any stronger-source return needed by the conclusion.

D.5:3 - Bias and Fairness Recognition

ClaimWhat D.5 requiresNeighboring owner
“This metric shows the system is fair.”Distinguish metric disparity, proxy choice, subgroup impact, and intended use.C.16 for metric construction
“This intervention makes outcomes fair.”Declare the causal fairness use, C.28 support components and causal-use support result.C.28
“The model is unbiased.”From the decision that uses the model, trace who encounters its consequences in access, treatment or the outcome at issue, and who can be screened out before a record exists. Select the comparisons that bear on the claimed protection and establish whose outcomes their records actually cover. Records of applications can suffice for a claim about those applications.C.16, D.5, and A.10 when a source-to-use account is needed
“The release is ethically assured.”Separate audit findings, mitigations, accepted residuals, and the assurance or evidence relation.B.3, D.5
“The policy is acceptable because it helps the whole.”Check whether a multilevel conflict is live.D.2, D.3, D.4

D.5:3.1 - Optional Audit Records And Depth

A BiasRegister@Context can keep concerns recoverable during ongoing work:

BiasRegister@Context:
  auditedEntityOfConcernRef
  intendedUseRef
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  affectedPopulationRefs?
  affectedSystemRefs?
  biasConcernCode
  evidenceRefs
  mitigationOrConstraintRef?
  acceptedResidualRef?
  nextReviewTrigger?

Choose depth from the claim and consequence that the recipient needs to judge. A bounded finding, corrected metric statement, or identified conflict can complete the present use, including when it concerns an affected group or appears in a publication. Retain the limitation that prevents that result from being read as a wider fairness or assurance claim.

Use a fuller BiasAuditReport@Context when the receiving decision needs to inspect the combined evidence, mitigations, and residuals behind an audit or assurance conclusion. A consequential or reusable causal-fairness audit retains this report and the C.28 support it consumes. A release that relies on a protective claim needs the evidence and audit account required to support that claim. Reuse a matching existing account; after a material change, reopen the claims whose basis or use changed. The report is a Description episteme or publication-use object, with scope and depth set by that reliance.

A concrete indication of harm, a missing basis for an intended claim, or an applicable assurance requirement can make further investigation necessary before that use. Name what its result could change, who can obtain it, and whether its contribution warrants its full cost and delay; use C.11.DUA when this appraisal is unresolved. If the needed basis remains unavailable, state which intended claim remains unsupported and give any feasible narrower use, mitigation, or stop with its conditions.

Exposure, repetition, automation, publication, and changed populations are cues to examine the use and consequence. They do not by themselves prescribe a full audit. When a protective or documentation requirement is disputed, use C.11.DUA to examine its hazard, threshold basis, protective contribution, feasibility, and distributed burden, while keeping its current force and amendment authority explicit.

D.5:3.2 - Bias Concern Taxonomy

CodeConcernTypical question
REPRepresentation, coverage, sampling, proxy choice, missing group, or shifted population.Who or what is missing, over-weighted, proxied, or moved out of scope?
ALGAlgorithmic, modeling, objective, ranking, optimization, or threshold behavior.Which model or optimization choice changes outcomes for whom?
VISWhat the presentation makes visible or authoritative.What becomes easy to see, hard to see, or too authoritative by display?
METMeasurement and comparison.What does the metric count, hide, compare, or turn into a pass or fail claim?
LNGLanguage, naming, category, definition, group label, or claim wording.Which words change what can be asserted, counted, blamed, or done?

The codes are only concern locators. They do not replace the governed object, affected people or groups, intended use, evidence, mitigation, or accepted residual.

D.5:4 - Causal Fairness Boundary

A fairness claim may be associative, interventional, or counterfactual. C.28 supplies the causal-use question, rung, estimand, separate support components, common-threat result, and CausalUseSupportResultRef. D.5 keeps the bias/fairness audit and its conclusion.

When counterfactual fairness is consequential, reusable, published, or used for assurance, the cited C.28 components expose the additional counterfactual-identifiability assumptions required for that question. If the audit relies on an estimated fairness result, they also expose the estimate and its estimation-consistency result. Missing identification or consistency lowers the C.28 result to bounded or unsupported; more of the same data does not repair either gap.

Cite the C.28 result from the existing BiasAuditReport@Context. When only metric disparity is claimed, record the metric or evaluation result and stop. An interventional proxy may support a bounded interventional fairness statement, but it does not establish counterfactual fairness without the required estimand and support components.

The C.28 result is one evidence basis for the audit conclusion. Interpret it within the declared audit scope. A release decision or ethical-assurance claim requires a judgement and supporting basis.

D.5:5 - Ethical Assurance Boundary

State the protection on which the recipient will rely and the use for which it is claimed. The record of an examination can establish that an audit took place. To rely on the protection, connect its criterion to the relevant findings, the people and decisions they cover, the effects of mitigation and the remaining exposure. Establish who may authorize proceeding with that exposure when such a decision is required.

Use B.3 for the assurance relation. Establish the needed evidence and its currentness through the applicable subject and source rules; use A.10 when the source-to-use relation is implicit or must be made replayable. Use D.3 to describe an interlevel ethical conflict and D.4 to mediate or use it in a decision. Use C.30.ILC when the issue is an architecture residual rather than a bias or fairness audit.

D.5:6 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slice)

Suppose a hiring-screening model agreed with a reviewed reference decision on 90 of 100 applications. Each applicant in the comparison submitted one application, and ten of the applicants belong to the group under review. All ten discrepancies could fall inside that group or all ten could fall outside it. A reliable subtotal of agreements for those ten applications, or a count from the corresponding decisions, can establish the observed group rate. If applicants can submit repeatedly, a rate per person also needs a rule for counting their decisions. An estimate for a wider population needs grounds for extending the comparison and an account of its uncertainty. A judgement about fair treatment also needs a criterion for what counts as fair in that use. People unable to submit an application are outside this calculation. A claim about access must account for them.

If the team claims counterfactual fairness, C.28 must expose the causal estimand, additional counterfactual-identifiability assumptions, and an estimate with its consistency result when that estimate is relied on. Missing conditions lower the C.28 support result before D.5 decides its audit use. If the audit exposes a conflict between company efficiency and applicant harm across declared scopes, D.3 describes that conflict and D.4 guides its decision use.

D.5:6.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Audit as document ritualA register or report exists but does not change intended use, residuals, or constraints.Tie each concern to audited EntityOfConcern, intended use, evidence, mitigation, and accepted residual.
Metric fairness overclaimA metric comparison is published as causal or counterfactual fairness.Recover the fairness claim kind. For counterfactual fairness, require C.28 identification assumptions and estimation consistency when an estimate is used before D.5 consumes the support result.
Assurance as authorizationEthical assurance is treated as permission to proceed.Record assurance as assurance or evidence relation and keep D.4 and D.5 use separate.
Bias category replaces objectREP, ALG, VIS, MET, or LNG code is treated as the governed object.Use codes only as concern locators; keep audited EntityOfConcern and intended use explicit.

D.5:7 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D5-1The result names the audited EntityOfConcern, intended use, affected populations or Systems, and the bias, fairness, impact, or ethical concern being answered. Relied-on evidence and material limitations qualify its warranted use. Assurance use, repair return, ClaimScope, and qualification window are explicit when they delimit the audit; record and investigation depth follow the reliance in §3.1.Keeps audit scope inspectable.
CC-D5-2Metric, causal fairness, evidence, assurance, publication, and architecture-residual claims use their subject patterns.Prevents D.5 from swallowing neighboring patterns.
CC-D5-3Ethical assurance is recorded as assurance or evidence relation, not moral permission.Keeps assurance from becoming ethical authorization.
CC-D5-4If the audit exposes interlevel conflict, use D.3 for the conflict description and D.4 for mediation or decision use.Keeps D.5 connected to the D cluster without replacing it.

D.5:3.3 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
Ethics ghettoBias or fairness is left in a separate ethics note while the model, metric, release, publication, or work plan keeps operating unchanged.Put the concern on the audited EntityOfConcern and its intended use, then name the mitigation, constraint, or accepted residual.
Checklist charadeA checklist is completed without answering the concern about affected people, evidence, use, or residuals.Return the bounded finding or judgement; use a register or report when its content is needed for tracking or reliance.
Bias whack-a-moleOne disparity is patched while proxy, representation, metric, visibility, or language concerns move elsewhere.Follow the change through the decisions and people it affects. Reopen the concerns whose grounds or consequences it changes and state the use and residual that this supports.

D.5:8 - Consequences

A reader can distinguish a supported metric finding from a causal-fairness or ethical-assurance conclusion and identify what additional basis a proposed use would require.

D.5:9 - Rationale

Technical accuracy alone does not establish fairness for affected groups. Connect the audit question with its object and intended use, then use the evidence appropriate to that claim. Measurement, causal support and ethical assurance answer different questions; interpret their results accordingly.

Audit depth follows what a claim or decision needs from the result. A compact account can carry a useful finding; a stronger audit or assurance conclusion needs its supporting evidence and the record required for that reliance. Material changes reopen the affected basis, and a disputed requirement remains open to substantive appraisal without losing its present force.

D.5:10 - SoTA-Echoing

For deciding what a fairness result supports, adapt C.16’s measurement interpretation and C.28:4.6’s claim-specific identification and estimation conditions. Against the aggregate-accuracy inference in :6, :2–4 retain the qualified metric result and obtain the additional causal basis only for a conclusion that needs it. Section :3.1 reuses an adequate audit account and selects further work from the reliance, while a missing required basis leaves the stronger conclusion unsupported. B.3 supplies any assurance relation and D.4 its ethical decision use. Reopen the affected basis when the population, intended use, claimed effect, evidence conditions or binding requirement changes.

Kearns, Neel, Roth and Wu show how a classifier can meet a parity condition for each of several predefined groups while violating it for a subgroup defined by a combination of attributes. Section 2 uses that distinction to select the group a claim concerns. Which criterion matters and which population it covers still come from the receiving use. Preventing Fairness Gerrymandering (2018)

D.5:11 - Relations

  • Builds on D.1 and coordinates with D.2, D.3, and D.4 for value frame, multilevel entry, conflict description, and mediation or decision use.
  • Coordinates with A.10 when the source-to-use relation behind relied-on evidence is implicit or needs a replayable account.
  • Coordinates with C.11.DUA for the contribution and feasibility of further inquiry and the merits and current force of disputed audit or protective requirements.
  • Coordinates with B.3 for assurance relation and reliance.
  • Coordinates with C.16 for metric and measurement construction.
  • Coordinates with C.28 for causal fairness, including counterfactual-identification assumptions, estimation consistency when an estimate is used, and the bounded causal-use support result.
  • Coordinates with E.17 when publication or publication-use relation changes admissible use.

D.5:End