Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-22 16:35:45 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-22 16:36:48 UTC · last check 2026-11-22 17:05:15 UTC

Library.Reference:6.5.3.8 - Hoshin/catchball: develop direction through feasible contributions

Use this connection when direction, local proposals and shared support do not yet form an undertaking the participants can carry out. A common aim can leave departments planning incompatible contributions. A locally sensible target can also misrepresent the result wanted by the recipient. Hoshin connects direction with investigation of the work, proposals in return, joint execution and reconsideration. The Liker–Shook account relates this construction to horizontal as well as vertical dependence and to the development of problem-solving capability.

Develop the proposal in both directions. Start from the question that is open. An existing direction can be adequate; a shared concern may instead need a worthwhile direction to be constructed. A participant investigates the present work and proposes a contribution, explaining why the way should help, what they can undertake and what they need from others. The return can reveal an unsuitable local measure, an unsupported causal assumption or unavailable provision. Those imply different changes: refine the local interpretation, investigate or replace the means, obtain support, or reconsider the aim through its owner. Graban’s account of catchball makes adjustment in both directions explicit. The proposal can inform a decision before it warrants a promise.

Bring the proposal to the people whose contributions it needs or whose work it displaces. Keep the dependencies between departments explicit: whose specialist time, permission or result must be available to whom and when. Compare the whole demand and timing, obtain the relevant decisions, and return changes to the affected participants. Some can contribute knowledge while another holds the authority to change a goal, commit resources or accept revised terms. Reich’s account of getting started makes leadership participation and differing stakeholder powers consequential conditions. Select an attainable organizational scope with the required participation; introducing a form cannot confer the missing mandate.

Choose the form of exchange for the result it must supply. A group can examine a prepared plan, expose dependencies and improve it. When the participant must also become able to construct such a plan, provide for their own substantive attempt: they investigate the work, formulate the proposal and use a capable coach’s response to improve their reasoning. Howell’s comparison explains this distinction between group revision and the problem owner’s development. The latter needs practice time and suitable help. A better group plan does not by itself establish each participant’s ability, and a management title does not supply coaching competence.

When relevant knowledge is widely dispersed, individual proposals followed by collective examination can make contributions available that a small planning group cannot supply. In the historical Tennant–Roberts Rover study, interviews, a Delphi survey and workshops contributed to a revised milestone proposal before executive approval. Survey estimates informed discussion; they did not determine binding dates. The authors report dropping the Delphi stage in later iterations once shared understanding was available. Select the more involved exchange when obtaining the missing contributions warrants its cost. Use an adequate ordinary conversation or existing agreement directly when it already supplies the needed result.

Use execution results to reconsider the undertaking. Once work begins, compare what happened with the proposal’s grounds and with the commitments still in force. A stalled contribution may need a different method, support, sequence or agreement; a changed recipient need may require revising the goal. Obtain the decision that makes the selected change effective. In Reich’s interview account, review examines actual work and missing support, while the organization can also revise how it develops direction, gathers proposals and reviews them. Choose the review interval so that needed operating responses can occur in time. The subject of revision determines the relationship; annual and monthly meetings do not by themselves establish two control levels.

Hoshin can supply direction and provision for Improvement Kata; experiments and acquired capability can inform later proposals. Rother’s clarification calls for revisiting the challenge at the end of each target-condition cycle, using what has been learned. It does not justify changing direction merely because a step is difficult. Keep clear which target condition and experiment the returned results concern, and obtain the authority needed to change any affected commitment. Either practice can be sufficient without the other when the other difficulty is absent.

For the common operations, GOALS.1, GOALS.3 and GOALS.4 supply goal meaning, joint feasibility and warranted revision. In Leadership, LDR.5 develops direction and participation when they remain unresolved; LDR.2 obtains responses to a complete feasible proposal where negotiation is needed. Their results can identify a contribution that remains unsupported or state a warranted refusal. Use HCD for the development of a person’s capability and C.40.JD for its connection to the method and provision, as in §6.5.6. This comparison explains Hoshin’s characteristic connection of those contributions; undertaking full implementation requires the relevant subject method and its conditions.