MDPE.30 - Construct a Rhythmic Part from a Seed, Phase and Action Rule
Type: Method Status: Stable Normativity: Normative
MDPE.30:1 - Problem frame
Use this when a performer or arranger needs to construct a part from a cyclic rhythm or establish how an existing part places sounds and actions against an accompaniment. The part specifies the phase, sounds, actions and instruments, with grounds for using them under the intended conditions.
Use a fixed unit-pulse grid. This method develops two ways to alternate hands. Begin with an available seed or construct one suited to the music. Section 5.1 derives the three-onset, eight-pulse example. For other counts use Toussaint’s chapter 21 or another suitable construction. An existing part can already meet the musical requirement.
MDPE.30:2 - Problem
A cyclic onset pattern specifies spacing, but its placement against another part, allocation to hands, action period and performing demands can remain open. A different accompaniment can change which placement or allocation fits even when the seed remains the same.
Construct the relation among attacks, actions and receiving music. When one receiving condition changes, identify which part of the construction depends on it. If the rule excludes the required sound, identify the incompatibility. To supply that sound, change the rule or another part of the arrangement.
MDPE.30:3 - Forces
| Concern | Consequence for construction |
|---|---|
| Cyclic shape and fixed musical origin | Rotations can preserve spacing while changing entries, collisions and silences against the accompaniment. |
| Audible attacks and intervening actions | Alternating attacks and alternating motions on every pulse can produce the same onset pattern with different sounds and bodily demands. |
| Local phrase and continuing performance | Follow the rule across the boundary to establish when the action or audible pattern recurs. |
| Retained relation and changed span | Stretching, appending rests and splicing can retain different properties. Select the operation by the musical requirement. |
MDPE.30:4 - Solution
Connect the rhythmic material and the receiving music with the actions specified for the sounds. For a question about a performance, establish which actions the performer used. Use a given seed or an already sufficient allocation directly. Reconsider the relation that remains open or has changed.
MDPE.30:4.1 - Recover the seed and place it in the receiving music
Represent the cycle by its unit-pulse count and onset positions, including the gap from the last onset to the first onset in the next cycle. Identify the musical purpose, such as preserving a familiar figure, exploring spacing or changing an arrangement. A spacing property can settle a geometric question. Its musical value depends on the receiving use.
Fix the origin against a feature of the receiving music, such as an accompaniment entry or a shared phrase boundary. Identify the required sounds or silences there and at other relevant landmarks. To shift the part by s pulses in an n-pulse cycle, replace each onset position p with (p + s) modulo n and leave the accompaniment fixed. Compare the shifted onsets with the receiving landmarks. A shift can change that relation; renumbering both parts leaves it unchanged.
An existing placement can be kept when it satisfies the receiving landmarks and the intended musical use. If a particular phase fails, compare another phase where it could help. When none can supply the wanted relation, reconsider the seed, the receiving requirement or the arrangement.
MDPE.30:4.2 - Construct the action and sound allocation across the boundary
In attack-wise alternation, advance to the other hand on each audible attack and carry the rule over the cycle boundary. With an odd number of attacks per seed cycle the first hand switches sides at that boundary and returns after two cycles. With an even number it returns after one. The scored timbre can repeat sooner than the hand pattern when the instruments and strokes sound alike. How a particular listener heard the exchange is a separate question.
In pulse-wise alternation, advance to the other hand on every pulse. Sound only the onsets. The other motions still belong to the performance. With an even number of pulses, the hand allocation at the next cycle boundary repeats. With an odd number, the first hand changes. These two rules can place sounds at exactly the same instants while requiring different actions.
Map the actions to the instruments and the required sounds. Follow them long enough to establish the period relevant to the accompaniment. Consider an easier allocation if it can meet the same musical conditions. If the rule excludes a required hand or sound at an entry, identify which must be preserved. A sound can sometimes be remapped; to require the right hand itself, choose a rule or phase that puts it there, or reconsider the receiving condition. If the rule permits the sound and the performer cannot produce it under the needed conditions, consider practice or another playable allocation.
MDPE.30:4.3 - Change the span by the relation that must survive
Identify the relation to preserve, such as exact onset times, relative spacing, hand blocks, transition gaps or the sound at an entry. For each operation under consideration, derive what it would do to that relation and the receiving part. Options include scaling intervals, appending silence or splicing a segment.
For the smooth-toggle family in §5.4, preserve a block of right-hand onsets followed by a block of left-hand onsets, with three pulses between the final onset of one block and the first of the next. Begin with eight pulses and onsets at 0, 2 and 5 under pulse-wise alternation. Split the current cycle into equal halves. Copy the two pulses immediately before and the two immediately after the split, then insert that four-pulse segment between the original halves. Each such extension adds one audible stroke to each block, preserves the parity of the shifted motions and retains the two transition gaps.
Compare the changed span with the receiving accompaniment and entry. A correct twelve-pulse part can fail a requirement to return to the same phrase every eight pulses. If the change fits the score, a separate question may concern the performer’s capacity to realize it.
MDPE.30:4.4 - Establish what the part supports in the receiving music
Compare the arrangement with the tempo, reference cues, instruments and partners required for its use. For a performing claim, use adequate existing observations under those conditions. If a consequential question remains, consider a trial that can answer it at a worthwhile cost, or report the limit of the available evidence. An unintended contact sound may call for a change of technique or practice. When the rule assigns an entry to the wrong hand, report that consequence. To supply the required entry, change the allocation of actions or sounds as the musical requirement permits.
Give the onset pattern, fixed origin, action and instrument mapping, intended sounds and accompaniment needed to recover the part. A complete score can finish the construction. For a recommendation or decision, identify the part selected or proposed and the grounds for using it. To report actual use, identify the performer, assistance, conditions and observations supporting it. Timing geometry, a generating or performing method, an explanation of the construction, someone’s demonstrated understanding of it and acquired performing capability are distinct results. The style and acquisition account relates them for teaching.
MDPE.9 can compare generated alternatives. MDPE.3 can use the part in a performing configuration, and MDPE.10 can address a needed capability. RHY.7, RHY.8 and RHY.11 supply broader rhythmic comparisons, transformations and coordination. Use the constructed part or a supported finding directly when it answers the question.
MDPE.30:5 - Archetypal Grounding
Toussaint supplies the rhythmic and action constructions. The receiving constraints, choices and rehearsal outcomes below are stipulated to show how a change of musical purpose affects the part.
MDPE.30:5.1 - Generate the small seed and choose its phase
An ensemble wants three audible attacks in a repeating eight-pulse span. Its pulse 0 is fixed by the accompaniment. Another instrument has a cue at pulse 6, where this new part should remain audibly silent. The percussionist has a low-sounding instrument for the right hand and a contrasting high-sounding instrument for the left. The first musical question is whether a two-cycle timbral exchange works with the accompaniment.
Use x for an audible onset and . for a silent pulse. For this specific seed, begin with three onset columns and five silent pulses. Give each onset one silent pulse, leaving two; append the remaining two to the first two columns. Read each column downwards and concatenate:
initial groups: [x] [x] [x] remaining: . . . . .
after first sharing: [x .] [x .] [x .] remaining: . .
after second sharing: [x . .] [x . .] [x .]
concatenated: x . . x . . x .
positions: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
The onsets are 0, 3 and 6. Their cyclic gaps are 3, 3 and 2, including the return from 6 to the next cycle’s 0. The three gaps differ by at most one pulse. For other onset and pulse counts, use the repeated-distribution algorithm in chapter 21 or an already established seed. The two sharing steps here derive this particular pattern.
The seed strikes at 6, where the other instrument needs a clear cue. Advance every onset by two pulses modulo 8. Positions 0, 3 and 6 become 2, 5 and 0. In cycle order they are 0, 2 and 5, with gaps 2, 3 and 3. The attack count and cyclic spacing are preserved, while both placements have an attack at the fixed origin and only the shifted placement leaves pulse 6 silent. The unchanged accompaniment makes the two placements musically distinct.
MDPE.30:5.2 - Turn the onsets into actual hand and sound parts
First alternate hands on audible attacks only. Start with the right hand and continue across the cycle boundary. After three strokes the next cycle begins with the left hand.
| Eight-pulse span | Pulse 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First cycle | R | . | L | . | . | R | . | . |
| Second cycle | L | . | R | . | . | L | . | . |
R and L are audible strokes on different instruments in this example. The unlabelled onsets repeat after eight pulses. The hand and timbre assignments repeat after sixteen, with right-hand attacks at 0, 5 and 10 and left-hand attacks at 2, 8 and 13. If both hands produced indistinguishable sounds, the onsets could still repeat after eight while the hand assignments took sixteen.
The ensemble compares the alternating sounds with playing all three attacks on one sound. For these musicians that option requires less coordination and preserves onset timing, while the alternating sounds give an exchange across two cycles. In the stipulated rehearsal the percussionist plays the alternating-attack version at 72 pulses per minute with the audible reference, and the partner reports hearing the cue at 6 clearly. The ensemble selects it for the next rehearsal under those conditions.
MDPE.30:5.3 - Change the receiving condition without confusing the two action rules
The revised accompaniment now needs the low right-hand sound at pulse 0 of every eight-pulse cycle. Continuous alternation on three audible attacks gives the left hand that pulse on alternate cycles. To put the right hand on that entry every cycle, change the action rule or arrangement. If only the low sound matters, a different instrument assignment may suffice. Practising the same arrangement cannot change its predicted first hand.
Compare a second action rule from chapter 32. Alternate the hands on every pulse, including silent motions, and sound only positions 0, 2 and 5. Capitals below mean audible strokes; lowercase letters mean the indicated hand moves without an audible attack, stopping short or using an appropriately silent motion.
pulse: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
motion: R l R l r L r l
sound: x . x . . x . .
Eight pulse-wise motions return the hands to their original allocation. The first two audible attacks are right-hand strokes and the last is left-hand, the smooth-toggle seed of chapter 32. The onsets and silence at 6 remain. This version calls for eight alternating motions per cycle, three of them sounded. Silent positions still require their specified motions. Whether that organization helps a performer depends on their technique and the conditions.
In this constructed rehearsal the percussionist initially sounds an unintended stroke at 4. The ensemble slows the passage to separate audible from silent motions, then restores the original tempo and accompaniment. The performer now supplies the required sounds and entry. The ensemble chooses this version for that arrangement and retains the two-cycle version for its earlier use. If the needed silent motion remains out of reach in the preparation time, consider another playable allocation or a change in instrument, entry condition or rehearsal provision.
MDPE.30:5.4 - Extend the phrase while preserving a chosen action relation
Suppose a later arrangement requires twelve pulses, a right-hand block followed by a left-hand block, and three pulses at both block transitions. Stretching all old times by 1.5 would put the old onset at 5 on 7.5, between grid points. Appending four silent pulses would extend the cyclic gap from the last attack to the next first attack. Neither operation preserves the required relations.
Use chapter 32’s splice instead. Cut the eight-pulse motion after position 3. Copy its four-pulse transition segment at original positions 2–5, then insert that copy between the two halves:
first half inserted transition second half
R l R l R l r L r L r l
new positions: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
new motion: R l R l R l r L r L r l
The right-hand attacks are at 0, 2 and 4, the left-hand attacks at 7 and 9. Their cyclic gaps are 2, 2, 3, 2 and 3. The new span has five attacks in twelve pulses. The two hand blocks and their three-pulse transitions remain, and inserting four pulses preserves the alternation of the shifted motions. Other musical or perceived properties require their own comparison.
For the revised twelve-pulse accompaniment, compare the constructed part with its required landmarks. If that score is the commission, the entries, action allocation and transition gaps can settle it. If the accompaniment still demands the eight-pulse return, keep the suitable earlier part or reconsider the joint arrangement. For a question about the performed transition, effort or entry, use relevant performance evidence. If it is insufficient, a feasible trial may supply the needed observation; otherwise give the supported result and its limit.
MDPE.30:6 - Bias-Annotation
The equal-pulse grid makes spacing and alternation calculable. Timing nuances and musical criteria may require other representations or observations. These two hand rules specify particular physical methods. An electronic instrument can reproduce their sounds through different actions, and another performer may need a different realization.
MDPE.30:7 - Conformance Checklist
- The seed’s onset positions, cycle length and last-to-first gap are recoverable.
- The phase is related to a fixed receiving origin and the entries or silences that matter.
- The action rule states whether attacks or all pulses advance it and continues across the boundary.
- The comparison shows which required sounds the action and instrument mapping supplies over the stated span and where it falls short, if anywhere. A claim that the sounds were produced identifies the evidence from that performance.
- For a changed span, show whether the construction preserves the required relation and fits the receiving accompaniment.
Inspecting the score can settle its structural requirements. A capability claim needs evidence of the performer under the conditions of the receiving music, with assistance that will be available and permitted there. Reuse adequate observations, or pursue a further trial if it can resolve the question on acceptable terms. Reliability over time and learning require evidence appropriate to those claims.
MDPE.30:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Invited mistake | Repair |
|---|---|
| Treat cyclic rotations as interchangeable against a fixed accompaniment | Compare each placement’s entries and silences against the same receiving origin. |
| Restart hand alternation at the bar line without changing the stated rule | Continue the rule through the boundary and determine the complete hand-labelled period. |
| Rehearse an allocation that gives the wrong entry sound by construction | Change the rule or arrangement. Use practice for an attainable performing goal. |
| Extend a part by a convenient arithmetic operation that loses its musical relation | Choose the preserved relation first, derive the changed part and check the join with the accompaniment. |
MDPE.30:9 - Consequences
The arranger obtains a part whose spacing, timbre and actions can be explained and changed separately where the music permits. A new phase or rule may suffice without a new seed. The required effort includes following the combined period and investigating the performing demands that matter to the intended use.
MDPE.30:10 - Architectural Rationale
A seed acquires a musical use through its phase against the accompaniment and the actions and sounds chosen for it. This explains how the same onset polygon can support different parts and why a change at one entry can require a different action rule.
MDPE.30:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source and use | Adopted or adapted contribution | Boundary and alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Toussaint, The Geometry of Musical Rhythm, second edition, 2020, chapter 21, especially Figure 21.2 | Use the explicit three-onset, eight-pulse construction and the distinction between a spacing family and its performed phase. | Other seeds may be supplied by the chapter’s general algorithm or another qualified construction. The shown calculation is not that whole algorithm. |
| Toussaint, chapter 31, “Alternating-Hands Method”, pp. 218–220 | Alternate the hands on audible attacks across the cycle boundary and assign the strokes to sounds. | A known part or simpler allocation may already meet the musical requirement. Compare their performing costs when cost bears on the choice. |
| Toussaint, chapter 32, pp. 225–230, especially Figures 32.1–32.2 | Adapt pulse-wise alternation and the smooth-toggle splice into an arrangement with explicit receiving conditions. | The family construction preserves specified relations; it establishes neither universal musical quality nor a performer’s capability. |
| RHY.7, RHY.8 and RHY.11 | Use their structural comparison, transformation and shared-performance methods when the work needs those broader results. | Their general operations do not by themselves select this specialized seed and action construction. |
The receiving constraints, candidate arrangements and revisions here illustrate applications of Toussaint’s constructions. Use the source’s historical and cultural cases for their documented settings. Reconsider the present arrangement when another method, instrument or observation changes a result or cost relevant to the music.
MDPE.30:12 - Relations
- MDPE.9 can compare the constructed parts or other available material when a comparison is needed.
- MDPE.3 can use the part in an arrangement with its accompaniment and other performing means. Evidence of its actual realization can answer a further performance question.
- MDPE.10 addresses a missing performing capability when the intended rule permits the required result and capability development is requested.
- Use MDPE.11 to distinguish the choices the score fixes from those the performer can make during performance.
- RHY.7, RHY.8 and RHY.11 provide the broader comparisons, transformations and coordination named above.
- Application 5.3 connects the recoverable structure of a method, its description and acquisition when this construction is taught.