NSTD.Reference:1.2 - What supports narrative knowledge
A passage can establish what a narrator said. Its setting, contrasts, omissions and consequences can support an interpretation of that telling. To establish whether a reported event occurred, examine the relevant historical or observational evidence. For a causal claim or theorem, use the corresponding inquiry or argument. Explain what a proposed reading accounts for, which material counts against it and which assumptions it requires. A supported range of readings can answer the question when the material leaves a choice open.
In fiction the author chooses premises and can invent events, then examine their consequences for the imagined world. A factual future scenario can also make assumptions explicit. If the scenario is to guide a decision about a feasible course of action, establish the relevant premises and means in the setting of that decision. An imagined possibility can also serve a narrower purpose, such as identifying a question.
Textual analysis can show how delayed disclosure supports a changed interpretation. Cognitive research can test processing or recall under specified conditions. A planning system can demonstrate the effect of a represented constraint on particular generated events. An author’s experiment can reveal a possibility or a limit of a familiar technique. For a claim about how a population of readers responds, use evidence about those readers and the conditions of their encounter.
Schmid’s treatment of state changes and selection by perspective supplies a historical basis for analysing narrative units. Meretoja’s narrative hermeneutics examines how people interpret a life or situation through culturally available accounts. Use chronology for a question about event order. For a question about what the events meant to a participant, examine the grounds for that interpretation. Where the traditions make incompatible claims, retain the difference that matters to the question. NSTD.Sources:1 gives the source uses and their limits.