NSTD-LEARNING - Teach selection and use of methods across unfamiliar cases
- Situation: Learners can repeat separate explanations but cannot choose a repair in an unfamiliar project.
- Question: Which content, order and tasks will help them distinguish and perform the needed repair?
- First useful result or blocker: A learning route with the support each task needs. Claims about what a learner understood or could do depend on their work under the stated conditions.
- Mantra: Name the learner’s task, supply its prerequisites, vary the cases and examine the response. Repair the content or timing when the difficulty calls for it.
- Start with: NSTD.1 for the learning purpose and NSTD.8 for the route across cases.
- Stop or return: Use the response to identify what the learner did with the support provided. If missing content or late support explains a difficulty, repair that part. Use evidence from the intended transfer task for a claim about transfer.
Expansion for NSTD-LEARNING
In an engineering course, learners can repeat separate explanations of source selection, ordering, viewpoint and evaluation. They struggle to choose a repair for an unfamiliar project story. The course author uses NSTD.1 to define the target as selecting and performing an appropriate repair in a new case, and NSTD.8 to design a route for learning it. The source publication’s topic order remains available for reference.
The course can start with a supported source-selection case and then introduce an ordering failure. Learners later revisit the first case with a viewpoint question and choose repairs in unlabelled cases. NSTD.2 explains how that teaching order serves the task. With NSTD.8, arrange access to the distinctions, operations or references each task requires. An initial attempt before instruction can reveal competing readings. Follow it with the explanation and practice needed to resolve the observed difficulty.
Use NSTD.3 to frame questions about the connections learners need to reconstruct and NSTD.5 to choose examples that hold their attention. In the mathematics case a deformation image can help teach which changes the formal definition allows. Show where the analogy ends and give the definition and mathematical justification where the task requires them. To repair a missing mathematical distinction with another image, choose one that makes that distinction recoverable.
With NSTD.6 and C.2.8, examine which needed relations a reader can recover from the account in its chosen form and conditions. To report what a learner did, use the actual response and the support they used. For a numerical comparison, define the unit and the set of relations counted. One successful response with a reference supports that use. Effort, later retention and unaided transfer each require evidence for that question.
Let the difficulty guide the repair. Add missing subject content or make support available before the task that needs it. An adequate explanation can be retained. Use E.22 to clarify the improvement question or what must be protected. Use E.23 to compare a worthwhile repair and re-evaluate what changed. The resulting course can use lessons, slides and exercises suited to its learners.