Semantic Integration Engineering Principles Framework Sources and Edition Notes
SIE.Sources:1 - Source use and currentness
The source contributions guide particular actions and qualifications. Each body states what a source contributes and what remains outside its authority.
| Source family | Contribution used here | Qualification and reopen |
|---|---|---|
| Current FPF | source-local meaning, episteme identity, direct Bridge truth, bounded representation use, claim/provenance reliance, representation transition, currentness and affected-use distinctions | FPF retains the generic concepts and assurance law. A changed relied-on result reopens only its SIE consumer. |
| Current Core Method-development patterns | situational criteria and the separate repertoire, variant, introduction, and revision Methods in C.39.RP, A.3.1.MV, A.3.1.MI and C.36.MC | SIE supplies domain content; it does not duplicate Method identity or lifecycle decisions. |
| Current Systems Engineering | engineering-description, configuration/effectivity, change, release, integration, and assurance results | SIE can supply a qualified semantic premise; SYSE retains engineering decisions. |
| ISO 704:2022 and ISO/IEC 11179-3:2023 | distinguish objects, concepts, definitions, designations, registry items, versions, and mapping metadata | do not establish cross-source identity, truth, or receiving-use fitness |
| LOT, maintained LOT resources, and LOT4KG | competency/use questions, domain-participant validation, qualified reuse or development, and dependencies between an ontology and a selected graph realization | reuse can finish the model question; LOT4KG’s maintained activities do not establish a final peer-reviewed edition or a measured advantage |
| OWL 2 and the public ISO/IEC 21838-1:2021 description | explicit language semantics and profile choices when formalization is useful; a deliberately selected top-level basis when coherence needs it | formal validity does not supply domain adequacy; no universal ontology or full-standard conformance is required or claimed |
| OBO Foundry principles, including term stability, contact responsibility, and notification | actual module users, stable identification, scoped shared content, reachable responsibility, and notice of changes affecting reliance | adapt to the particular commons; contact does not itself assign content or release rights, and an OBO-specific notice interval is not universal |
| SKOS, SSSOM 1.0, and OAEI 2025 | correspondence kinds, reusable mapping metadata, and task-dependent alignment evidence | a label, similarity score, or matcher output remains a candidate premise |
| ISO 8000-115:2024, PROV-O, SEMI traceability, and GS1 EPCIS 2.0.1 | identifier-owner/use-restriction inputs, provenance relations, and domain identity/traceability probes | they create no cross-source equivalence, master identity, authoritative value, or receiving action |
| R2RML, OMG QVT 1.3, and Ontop | bounded executable mapping and virtual/materialized realization forms | no mandatory RDF, MOF, graph store, or source authority |
| SHACL, DQV, Data on the Web Best Practices, ISO/IEC 25012:2008, and ISO 8000-61:2016 | distinct validation, quality, provenance/version, and quality-management questions | no one layer or score proves receiving-use adequacy |
| ISO 10303-242:2025 and ISO 23952:2020 | versioned product-definition/configuration and manufacturing-quality source cases | AP242 edition 4 is at stage 90.92, “to be revised”; a changed relied-on successor reopens the affected source, mapping, interface, and case only |
The foundation source cut was qualified on 4 September 2026. The model, evolution, and commons contributions were qualified on 8 September using LOT, the maintained LOT4KG description, OWL 2, and the selected OBO principles. LOT4KG’s site cites an under-review manuscript and contains mixed date metadata; its inspected activities supply method guidance rather than proof of a final peer-reviewed edition or measured advantage. The earlier 2024 joint-methodology proposal is historical background; its future-work account does not describe the maintained method’s current evolution activities. The public ISO/IEC 21838-1:2021 description and stage 90.20 systematic review since 15 July 2026 delimit its use here; no full-standard conformance is claimed. Reopen only choices affected by changed relied-on content or use conditions.
SIE.Sources:2 - Edition return
Semantic Integration Engineering Principles Framework — First Edition, 20 September 2026 designates the source, twelve authoritative pattern bodies, and deterministic carrier of the complete twelve-pattern first edition. The publication supplies practitioner guidance and constructed examples. An implemented service, maintained commons, or receiving decision needs the corresponding actual work and evidence.
The Architectural Reference explains the connected language and the consequences of these sources for its use.