SYSE.19:4.1.2 - Substitute the changed premise before ordering new work
Read the old and new claims with their applicability conditions. Temporarily substitute the later claim into the recovered reasoning, retaining other premises only where still justified. Ask what the engineer can now conclude and do differently. This is a test of the argument, not a claim that the new source caused the physical system to change.
Several changes call for different responses:
- A corrected value can change a calculated margin. Recalculate the affected result before deciding whether another experiment is needed.
- A reduced validity range can remove support for one operating condition while preserving another. Outside the supported range, the old inference is unavailable; failure of the system is not thereby observed.
- A withdrawn experiment or disputed model assumption can weaken the evidence without providing an opposite numerical answer. Look for independent support and check whether it shares the disputed basis.
- A changed requirement can make an unchanged measured result insufficient. Establish that requirement’s applicable version and effective conditions; a test cannot authorize a different requirement.
- A new description of a calibration or test Method can change how further evidence must be obtained without proving that every earlier observation is false. Inspect which earlier uses relied on the changed part.
The later source may be less applicable, disputed, or effective only for future products. Explain that difference before replacing a current basis. Conversely, an erratum can undermine a premise used in past decisions. Preserve the historical source and decision as history while reconsidering any historical claim that depended on the error. Preservation is not a verdict that the earlier conclusion was correct.