SYSE.22:4.1.4 - Let one side revise the other without losing the original need
Run the candidate forward far enough to reveal the consequential mismatch. A model, an existing comparable case, a supplier answer or a performed trial can supply that result at its own evidential strength. Relate it back to the problem before generating another variant.
| Result that changes the inquiry | Engineering revision | What remains to be established |
|---|---|---|
| A candidate achieves the stated output but an occupant or service System is worse off | Correct the problem’s consequence or protected condition; revisit dependent alternatives | Whether a replacement candidate satisfies the corrected use |
| A new means makes a previously unattainable use plausible | Add a use–concept pair and compare its worth with the selected portfolio | Actual demand, feasibility and admission; technical possibility alone supplies none of them |
| Different family members require incompatible assumptions | Separate their applicable conditions, introduce a justified branch, or change the family basis | Shared resources and cross-member consequences under the proposed arrangement |
| The target variant is plausible but its construction, evidence or support cannot be obtained | Keep its promise conditional and frame the limiting builder relation for SYSE.23 or the obtaining question for SYSE.24 | A compatible supported means of obtaining the result |
| A candidate disproves one interpretation of the problem but leaves another useful | Revise or retire the defeated claim and preserve the supported branch | What the evidence supports about the remaining branch and any question still open |
A better means may change which problem is worth current attention. Conversely, a revised problem may change which retained design is useful. Preserve the reason for that movement. If different variants are proposed for different operating conditions, establish who can identify the condition and select or configure the variant before it is needed. If a choice for all conditions must be made earlier, compare arrangements available at that earlier decision. A previously rejected design can become useful when its grounds change.