SYSE.23:4.1.5 - Judge future benefit against commitment and continuing burden
Compare each alternative for the same change scenarios, horizon and current arrangement. Keep current implementation and transition Work, recurring operation and maintenance of the new means, later target-change Work, and displaced protective Work visible. Use a single quantity only for genuinely commensurable terms; safety, comfort, evidence strength and option reach do not become hours or money by being in the same table.
For a bounded effort comparison, suppose equivalent admissible changes currently require 60 engineering hours
each. A proposed means requires 240 hours to establish and 16 hours per later change. Under those stipulated
conditions, with all differing effort included in those terms, its total is lower only when
240 + 16n < 60n, hence at six or more changes. At five, the totals are 320 and 300 hours. This calculation
does not establish that six changes will be needed, that the effort estimates are supported, that other
characteristics are equal, or that the transition fits the calendar. If recurring provider maintenance,
qualification or adaptation differs, add those contributions before using the comparison.
When the benefit is preserving an option rather than saving repeated effort, name the future change that would otherwise become impossible or costly, the mechanism keeping it available, its carrying burden, and the event that makes it worth exercising. A reversible first commitment can be preferable under uncertainty. An unused option is not a realized operating gain, and preserving every imaginable option is not free.
Select an additional observation only if its attainable result could change the choice, clarify the grounds for it or show the conditions under which it is justified, and its expected
benefit warrants the cost. A model can settle a known resource bound; it cannot establish the service team’s ability
to use a new commissioning procedure. A trial can reveal an integration difficulty; it need not justify a general causal claim.
Use SYSE.10 for what the result supports and C.11.DUA when further inquiry’s value is uncertain. A qualified decision
to retain the current arrangement is a substantive outcome.