C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
Type: Architectural (A)
Status: Stable
Normativity: Normative unless marked informative
Plain-name. Sources and conditions of episteme use.
Use this pattern when. A claim or cue is being reused,…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:7 - Conformance Checklist
CC-C.2.6-1 Source, evidence or action relations SHALL NOT be inferred from publication phrasing alone when they matter for source use, reliance or Bridge interpretation.
CC-C.2.6-2 Embodiment-sensitive or operator-loop cases…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:9 - Consequences
The recipient can inspect the facts that make the proposed use possible and return to the particular missing basis. This requires enough source and interaction detail for that use. An account can cite existing adequate descriptions;…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:3 - Forces
Force Tension Embodiment vs abstraction Preserve bodily observations and operator participation while making their contribution explicit.
Compact description vs relevant detail Keep only the relations needed by the receiving use, with enough…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
If that change raises a semantic-correspondence question between local senses from different contexts, use F.9 to state and test the Bridge and its bounded-use claim, with the loss account; add an F.9.1 stance note only when it helps explain that claim. C.2.6…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
… account of those facts and conditions; C.2.1 governs the account and E.24.PUB governs its publication…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:2 - Problem
A common label can conceal the particular relation on which a use depends. Knowing that a reading was computed from a trace establishes its provenance; using that trace as evidence for a claim also requires the relevant observation and…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:1 - Problem frame
A U.Episteme may be produced from observations, refer to a model state, report another document’s assertions and participate in an operator’s decision. These facts answer different questions about the same episteme. Their importance…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:6 - Bias-Annotation
The questions favour explicit source and use claims when they affect a decision. Statements about bodily experience need an obtainable witness or other appropriate basis for the claim being made; describing that experience does not…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:15.3 - Boundary reminder
Source and use relations answer their stated questions. Representation, articulation, closure and trust retain their own definitions and tests…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
… objects through C.2.P and the relation through A.6.6 or A.6.P as applicable. If a changed source, access or interaction raises a semantic-correspondence question between local senses from different contexts, use F.9 for the Bridge, bounded-use claim and its…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
… use. For one unchanged relation, its adequate existing description can suffice. Distinguish the source episteme, any receiving episteme and their publication forms under C.2.P. State provenance, evidence and use claims about the participants. A prose form…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
For the stated use, check the original source and relevant transformations, what the recipient can recover or do now, and the grounds for the resulting claims. Include the separate F.9 question when a semantic correspondence is claimed. A joint-use account identifies each…
In C.2 - Epistemic holon composition (KD-CAL)
C.2:6 - Bias‑Annotation
Metric worship. Treating [F,G,R] as ends rather than means; mitigation: state the supporting grounds and limits for the claim and its use.
Category slip. Equating a notation, view, publication form, or carrier with claim content,…
In C.2.6 - Sources, Evidence and Conditions for Using an Episteme
C.2.6:10 - Rationale
A.16.0, A.16.1, B.4.1 and an applicable F.9 use need to preserve different facts when a cue is expressed or used elsewhere. An observation may remain the source after it is reported in text, while the recipient has access only to that…