C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
Type: Kind identity, subkind relation, and continuity pattern
Status: Stable
Normativity: Normative unless a section is explicitly informative…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1 counters hierarchy, sample-as-law, assertion-as-world, locality, and table-repair bias. A stronger-looking edge is not automatically an obtaining relation; a sample does not close an open domain; mutual classification does not identify two intensional…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:11 - Consequences
Benefits. Local typed compatibility remains small while its consequences for candidate judgments are testable.
Costs. A declaration change that matters to later classification needs an explicit edition and a separate continuity decision…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
For a subkind question restricted to a deliberately closed finite domain, account for every admissible case in which a narrower member could fall outside the broader kind. The exhaustive branch in C.3.1:4.1 can use established membership judgements or records…
In C.3 - Kinds, Intent and Extent, and Typed Reasoning
… effective reference scheme identifies another episteme under C.2.1. Judge its U.Signature membership under A.6.0 and its KindSignature qualification under C.3.2 separately; call it another edition only when the C.2.1 EpistemeEditionRelation obtains. C.3.1…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:2 - Problem
The sentence cooling pump is a pump is useful only when the membership conditions justify it. A current extension table can hide a bad proposal, and different intensional kinds can happen to classify the same candidates. Conversely, a unit…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:12 - Rationale
Kind identity, direct U.SubkindOf obtaining, assertion identity, declaration identity, candidate state, and current extension answer different questions and change under different conditions. Their separation lets a kind survive a…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:1 - Problem Frame
A practice/source boundary is provenance and a comparison cue. It affects the continuity decision only when comparison exposes a difference in the candidate domain or membership distinction.
U.SubkindOf is a same-individual dependent…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:3 - Forces
Force Tension Small typed reasoning vs ontology growth Projects need reusable kinds without a new public U.* name for each distinction.
Preorder vs kind identity Mutual subkind facts may hold for different intensional kinds; classification…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
… interpretation and assertion rather than occurrence identity.
Builds on: C.3, A.6.0 declaration identity, C.2.1 episteme and assertion identity, A.2.6/USM context-slice and scope discipline, F-G-R, and C.2.3 formality.
Coordinates with: C.3.2 judgments and…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:7 - Archetypal Grounding
Situation C.3.1 move Boundary CoolingPumpKind is below PumpKind. Use criterion entailment: the cooling-pump condition already requires the governed pump condition. State the readable relation and its applicability. Do not infer…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:5 - Solution
Recover each kind before comparing it. For each kind, state the candidate domain, membership condition, intended member/non-member contrast, and continuity rule. Use practice/source provenance to locate the declaration, not to decide…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
Compare the old and proposed declarations in this order: Preserving change. CoolingPumpSignature-3 replaces litres-per-second with an exactly aligned SI expression, preserves the pump candidate domain, cooling-performance discriminator, intended member and…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:9 - Conformance Checklist
Check Requirement CC-C31-1 Each U.Kind individual has a recoverable candidate domain, operative membership condition, intended member/non-member boundary, and continuity rule. Practice/source provenance is a comparison cue, not…
In C.3.1 - Kind Identity and Subkind Relations (U.Kind and U.SubkindOf)
C.3.1:4 - Core Objects
Object Meaning Boundary U.Kind The admitted meta-kind whose individuals are reusable intensional classification distinctions. One individual is recovered through its candidate domain, operative membership condition, intended…