Tag. Architectural pattern (foundational Standard; constrains G.1–G.5) Stage. Design time. Define the admissible comparisons and evidence minima that run-time checks will use. Primary output. CG‑Spec specifies which comparisons and aggregations a CG‑Frame…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:4.4 - Interfaces (normative)
Interface Consumes Produces / constrains G.0‑1 Charter CG‑Frame brief, USM scope signals CG‑Spec.Scope, entityOfConcern, ReferenceMap
G.0‑2 SCP CHR pack refs (G.3), legality proofs CG‑Spec.SCP + bindings to lawful…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:2 - Problem
Without a single, frame-level legality standard:
comparisons and aggregations drift into implicit assumptions (hidden scalarisation; silent totalisation of partial orders),
numeric gates run on “whatever is available” rather than declared…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:10 - Rationale
CG‑Spec centralises frame-level comparability constraints so that:
CHR authorship (G.3) remains about measurement meaning rather than implicit thresholds,
CAL (G.4) governs context-local acceptance/threshold policies and proof ledgers,…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:9 - Consequences
Lawful comparability. The frame enumerates the comparisons and aggregations it permits and the constraints on each.
Auditable selection. Downstream selectors can justify outcomes via pinned legality surfaces and explicit evidence minima.…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:3 - Forces
Pluralism vs. comparability. Multiple traditions must co-exist while allowing admissible comparison where justified.
Expressiveness vs. safety. Rich comparator sets and aggregators vs. measurement admissibility constraints.
Locality vs.…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
… generator guards), G.2 (harvesting constraints), G.3 (required CHR), G.4 (acceptance templates / proof hooks), and G.5 (eligibility gates); G.6 when the represented claim depends on CG-Spec, and parity/shipping/refresh where that specification is pinned.…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
… RSCRTriggerKindId.CrossingBundleEdit, RSCRTriggerKindId.FreshnessOrDecayEvent} Notes (wiring-only): Any SoTA palette/tradition semantics are governed by G.2. G.0 only requires that CG‑Spec entries cite the needed SoTA artefacts for auditability.…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:11 - SoTA‑Echoing
The pattern connects the following evaluation and governance practices:
treating abstention or deferral as an evaluation outcome, for example when the available evidence does not warrant the requested judgement (as in selective…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
Tell. Two labs compare energy efficiency results of a physical system where measurements use different rigs and units, and some evidence is missing. Show (failure without CG‑Spec). The team averages an ordinal safety rating, mixes units (“kWh” vs “MJ”), and silently treats…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
A team defines or evolves a CG‑Frame (e.g., a frame for creativity measurement, decision quality, architecture trade‑offs, or selected-set publication). Downstream comparison, aggregation, and publication of CHR‑typed observations (G.1–G.5 and beyond) must…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:6 - Bias-Annotation
CG‑Spec can encode (and therefore amplify) biases if authored carelessly:
Tradition favoritism. Comparator choices may privilege a tradition’s evidence style; mitigation: declare evidence minima and any justified crossing loss, and…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:7 - Conformance Checklist (normative)
ConformanceId Statement CC‑G0‑CoreRef G.0 is conformant only if the applicable core obligations listed in G.0:4.1 are satisfied (delegation to CC‑GCORE‑*; no shadow specs, no competing defaults, typed RSCR triggers,…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
G.0:4.5 - CG‑Spec authoring chassis (informative)
Begin with the receiving question and the available material: the task or decision request, descriptions of the subject and operating conditions, binding requirements, candidate methods, and existing…
In G.0 - Define Admissible Comparison and Aggregation for a Frame (CG-Spec)
Builds on: G.Core (Part-G core invariants; governing-pattern citation) GCoreLinkageManifest (normative). Effective obligations/pins/triggers are computed by union expansion of the referenced ids (per G.Core:4.2). Profiles/sets + explicit deltas; Nil‑elision…