PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
Type: Method pattern body
Status: Stable
Primary working result: a multi-model decision account: the smallest useful set of situation and option models, the questions each answers, their…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
In this illustrative continuation of the flood-pump inquiry, the board needs a pre-season decision-support return about permanent pumps, mobile capacity, maintenance, staffing, and access. The current formulations distinguish capacity shortage, deployment reliability, unequal…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:10 - Rationale
Complementarity is a relation between useful contributions to a question, not a model count. Purpose-led selection and explicit loss preserve different interpretations while making technical claims inspectable. Separate assurance keeps a…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:4 - Solution
Build a question-led set of complementary models. For each, state its subject, intended use, assumptions, evidence, and what it omits. Compare only the overlapping claims whose meanings can be aligned, retain material differences, and…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:9 - Consequences
The recipient sees which model can answer which question and where the combined account stops. Contradictions can guide inquiry instead of being hidden by one score. The cost is explicit assumptions and correspondence work; limit that…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:3 - Forces
Force Tension Discrimination Each model should change a claim, alternative, or inquiry priority, while exploratory models may first reveal what question matters.
Plurality Material perspectives deserve distinct expression, while collecting…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:2 - Problem
A capacity calculation cannot show whose service standard should govern. A rich picture can reveal attributed concerns without estimating a failure probability. A scenario can expose a vulnerable condition without predicting how often it…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
… losses separately from confidence in the model or its producer. Technical sophistication, modeler reputation, or participant confidence is treated as sufficient credibility. Adapt: PSDA.3:4.3–4.6 and the flood-pump case retain applicability, evidence…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:5.3 - Cheap non-use
A technician needs one conversion under an already-qualified formula, with agreed units and no material uncertainty about applicability. Use that calculation directly. A rich picture, scenario set, and second model would add no…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:6 - Bias-Annotation
Scope: models supporting bounded problem-structuring and decision-support questions. Lenses: Onto/Epist separates subject, model, expression, and evidence; Prag selects useful discrimination; Arch exposes model connections; Gov…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:7 - Conformance Checklist
The account serves a named subject, question, receiving use, configuration, and horizon.
Needed formulation and scope inputs are current and compatible, or their exact gaps are returned.
Each model supplies a distinct useful…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:4.7 - What changes in practice
Instead of asking which model is “the right one”, the practitioner asks which claims need a model, what each selected model contributes, and which difference would change the next move. Models can remain usefully plural…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:12 - Relations
PSDA.1 supplies formulations only where their differences guide model discrimination. PSDA.2 supplies the scope and reopen basis for the same subject and decision. Missing needed values require qualified direct sources or an exact gap.…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:1 - Problem frame
Use this when one diagram, spreadsheet, simulation, or agreed story is being asked to explain a contested situation, represent everyone’s concerns, predict consequences, and identify the best intervention. Also use it when several…
In PSDA.3 - Construct Complementary Situation and Option Models
PSDA.3:5.2 - Development advice across two holders
An adviser compares a training direction for two service teams. A skills map suggests similar learning needs, but each team’s queue model uses its own demand and staffing evidence. The combined account keeps…