SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
Type: Method pattern
Status: Stable
Normativity: Normative method guidance within SIE; examples are constructed and non-normative.
Primary working result: a QualifiedCorrespondenceSet@Use…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:10 - Rationale
A direct relation and permission to use that relation answer different questions. Keeping them separate allows a true relation to be rejected for a loss-sensitive use and a qualified narrow relation to support one operation without being…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:4 - Solution
Separate candidate discovery, direct relation judgment, and bounded-use qualification. For each row, identify exact source-local endpoints, state the relation or incompatibility and orientation, justify it with evidence and counterexamples,…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:9 - Consequences
The correspondence set gives mapping and interface work explicit semantic premises and preserves negative results. It makes version and loss dependencies visible and allows a narrow use to proceed while other rows remain unresolved.
The…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
… SIE.4 to construct a missing semantic model, decide cross-source identity, define transformation code, or choose the authoritative value. A local relation inside one governed source remains with its source owner unless the cross-source use makes it an…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:2 - Problem
Correspondence candidates are cheap. Labels can be normalized, lexical similarity scored, hierarchies compared, and model structures aligned. Yet “similar”, “related”, “narrower”, “same field name”, and “safe to substitute here” answer…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:12 - Relations
SIE.2 supplies exact endpoint senses, editions, profiles, authority limits, and model gaps.
SIE.3 is a conditional return when available models cannot express a required endpoint distinction.
SIE.5 consumes rows that expose a load-bearing…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
… counterexamples. SIE.4 adapts current mapping practice into a set that records negative dispositions and qualifies each relation for its receiving use. Reopen when an endpoint meaning or edition changes, a counterexample defeats the relation or use…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:3 - Forces
Force Tension Automation Matchers can surface many candidates, while their scores do not establish relation truth or permitted use.
Reuse A general crosswalk is attractive, while relation adequacy can change with receiver, grain, interval,…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:6 - Bias-Annotation
Lens Likely drift Repair Governance A matcher or integrator silently becomes the domain relation authority. Record the warrant, decision scope, and required domain authority for each accepted row.
Architecture Available mapping…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:7 - Conformance Checklist
Every row serves a named receiving use and consuming result.
Both endpoints reference exact source-local senses and applicable editions/profiles.
Candidate generation is distinguishable from relation judgment.
The direct…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:4.3 - What Changes in Practice
The team stops treating a mapping spreadsheet as a bag of equalities. A matcher result becomes a candidate; a domain judgment becomes a relation warrant; and a receiving-use decision states what the relation may safely…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:4.2 - Record the Result
Correspondence position Required content row identity and use stable row identifier, receiver/use, consuming result
source endpoint source, scheme/model, exact sense, edition/profile/effectivity, identifier
target endpoint…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
SIE.4:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
Anti-pattern Repair Same label, therefore same meaning Recover endpoint senses and test counterexamples.
Matcher score as truth Treat the score as candidate evidence; obtain a relation warrant and use…
In SIE.4 - Judge Cross-Source Correspondences and Their Permitted Uses
… a row disposition. Use accepted-for-use, accepted-with-loss, rejected, unresolved, or incompatible. A row can state a true broader/narrower relation yet be rejected for this use.
State dependencies and tests. Name whether SIE.5, SIE.6, or SIE.7 consumes the…