A.11:2.1 - Archetypal Grounding - Maintenance
| Candidate claim | Parsimony result | Why |
|---|---|---|
CoolingPump as a new root U-kind | First recover the project claim that distinguishes role classification, function, capability, component relation, or another governed expression. If that claim identifies an admitted U.System in an exact local cooling-circulator role, use the C.3 classification; otherwise return the missing discriminator. Add an assignment occurrence, capability, Method, or Work only when its own predicate is current. | The useful result follows the grounded project claim; the noun alone neither selects the role reading nor creates a universal kind. |
Actuator or another transformer-like noun | Recover the governed object and predicate needed by the candidate use; keep an ordinary functional or other subject claim with its direct rule. Use A.3 for a grounded acting-side claim and A.3.4 to identify any independently claimed actual change. An asserted Work needs the complete A.13 core and independent A.15.1 admission, with F.6 only for consumed precise attribution. If the facts do not select the predicate, return the missing discriminator. A new durable value still needs the parsimony finding and complete E.24.UK admission. | Neither the noun nor an identified change supplies an acting System, assignment, or Work. Those claims need their own facts. |
| Provenance-chain wording | Use A.10 for one source-to-use account and bounded reliance. Open G.6 when the use needs path identity, slicing, citation, or local refresh through already established objects and relations. Continue a new durable-value proposal only if the direct evidence or provenance patterns cannot express the needed claim without material loss; complete admission remains separately required. | Parsimony tries subject patterns before minting a kernel addition; a chain label does not itself require an addressable path. |
SmallPart or similar vague size class | Reject or keep local. | The boundary depends on private scale expectations unless a direct measurement or classification pattern supplies a crisp rule. |
A retained addition also needs a reopen condition. Reopen the parsimony finding and reconsider or lower admission under its governing rule when usage collapses, overlap with an existing value is discovered, an existing governed expression becomes adequate, the boundary becomes fuzzy, or the name starts hiding that expression. This is maintenance discipline, not a fixed calendar ritual.