A.14:6 - Choosing the right relation (decision table)
| You want to say… | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| “This is a piece of the same stuff or extent.” | PortionOf | One extensive measure and conservation rule govern the claim. |
| “This is a discrete structural part inside the whole.” | ComponentOf | The part is structurally integrated; amount and facet selection do not decide it. |
| “This is a logical or content part of a conceptual whole.” | ConstituentOf | The claim concerns conceptual or epistemic assembly. |
| “This dependent structural part is one aspect of this bearer under this facet rule.” | AspectOf | Name the aspect, bearer, facet rule, occurrence, and identity rule; a Characteristic, view, projection, partition, or time window is not enough. |
| “This is the same entity during a proper sub-interval.” | PhaseOf | The same carrier and its identity rule hold over a proper temporal restriction. |
| “This item belongs to that collection.” | The belongs-to rule defined for that collection | Name the entity and collection, state what makes belonging begin and end, and distinguish recurrence. Belonging establishes neither parthood nor its impossibility. |
| “This System is classified by a local work-facing kind, has an assignment to that kind, or participates in a direct relation.” | The corresponding local system-role-kind classification, U.SystemRoleAssignment, or direct relation participation; use A.6.5 when the relation needs reusable participant typing. | Kind classification, assignment occurrence, and relation participation are not parts. |
Firewall reminder. If the sentence is about system-role-kind classification or assignment, how action is done, or what happened when, use
A.2/A.2.1,A.3.1, orA.15.1as appropriate. For an episteme, use A.14 for content parthood or a proper interval of one unchanged C.2.1 identity; changed claims, EntityOfConcern, or effective reference scheme identify another episteme, and any historical continuation uses C.2.1EpistemeEditionRelationonly when its predicate obtains.