fpf.tools
Library / First Principles Framework (FPF) - Core Conceptual Specification
Jump to passage
In this reading
Source · lines 59900–59919

Link to current text

Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-10-03 08:25:59 UTC · snapshot created 2026-10-03 08:26:43 UTC · last check 2026-10-03 08:30:15 UTC

C.22.2:3 - Problem-Kind Recovery

Problem remains an ordinary word when no FPF-governed claim is being made. Recover it only when wording changes a governed kind, relation, selector use, evidence claim, causal-use claim, assurance claim, decision, or use boundary.

FPF-governed useCurrent recoveryC.22.2 disposition
Symptom, anomaly, deviation, risk signal, or stakeholder signalProblem signal or exact signal referenceMay trigger a card but is not an actual Problem or complete problem-side claim by itself.
Problematic situationPlain cue for an exact condition, entity, Work, transformation, or relation under its direct patternThe phrase introduces no U.Situation; an actual Problem still requires one obtaining C.22.PFR relation.
Actual ProblemOne obtaining ProblematicForRelation with exact condition and applicability participantsC.22.PFR governs actuality and identity; the card can assert or designate it only after that settlement.
Forecast, scenario, counterfactual, or anticipated conditionExact non-actual claim with assumptions, horizon, and direct governorPreserve the claim family; do not turn affirmative wording into current PFR obtaining.
Method availability or solvabilityClaim over admitted methods, evidence, constraints, and one intended useSelecting a method revises this claim but does not end an actual PFR.
Framed problem-side representationClaimGraph about one joint EntityOfConcern under one effective ReferenceScheme and ClaimScopeCenter of ProblemCard; representation change uses its direct transition, retargeting, Bridge, or wording-use governor.
Candidate from archive or retained poolMember of an exact source set under a retention relationPreserve sourceSetRef, set kind, criterion, budget/window, and non-scalar next use; set semantics remain outside the card.
Selected problem from a set-return treatmentExact selected member under a direct selection relationThe card may carry the member, but selection, parity, archive, and set-return claims remain with G.5, C.18, C.19, G.9, G.11, A.6.P:7a, or C.16.Q as applicable.
Problem ready for selector-facing useCard sufficient to prepare or assign TaskSignatureC.22 constitutes and assigns TaskSignature; C.22.2 does not dump card content into it.
Downstream task, method, plan, or performed-Work cueExact value or relation under C.22, G.5, A.15, or another direct patternKeep only the problem-side cue and stop before claiming the downstream result.
E.8 or E.9 Problem frameAuthoring or decision-rationale sectionNot a ProblemCard and not an actual Problem by heading alone.

The card may reference candidate ProblemProfile, TaskSignature, source set, PFR, forecast, solvability claim, or first-principles cue only when that reference changes its use. No reference is promoted into a local kind or card constitution component.