Library / First Principles Framework (FPF) - Core Conceptual Specification
Jump to passage
In this reading

Link to current text

Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-10-03 05:29:54 UTC · snapshot created 2026-10-03 05:30:57 UTC · last check 2026-10-03 07:05:20 UTC

C.3.2:8 - Subkind Comparison and Change

Whenever SubkindOfObtains(k1,k2) holds under C.3.1, its practical consequence is checked only where both candidate requests are admissible under the aligned declarations:

For the same candidate and slice, an admissible true judgment for k1 must not coexist with an admissible false judgment for k2 within the relation’s declared applicability.

C.3.1 decides whether exact criterion entailment or exhaustive evaluation over a deliberately closed finite domain makes the relation obtain. Non-exhaustive classifications support its assertion or expose a counterexample; they do not establish an open-domain relation. A not-applicable request is outside the comparison. Cross-local use first compares kind identities: reuse the same kind directly when its membership distinction continues; only distinct kinds with an obtaining correspondence use C.3.3. A bridge never transfers source classification truth.

Keep these changes distinct:

ChangeDirect consequenceWhat does not follow automatically
practice, source, team, or locality changescompare the exact kind definitions and declaration meaningsanother kind or KindBridge
two distinct kinds and a directional correspondence are currenttest C.3.3 obtaining and evaluate the receiving candidate afreshtransferred source truth
criterion, candidate domain, applicability, EntityOfConcern, or scheme changesanother declaration episteme; KindSignature qualification and any edition relation are checked separately as in section 5; C.3.1 decides kind continuityanother kind merely by edition
candidate fails ValueKind or slice applicabilitynot-applicable; no judgmentunknown or false
candidate state changesreevaluate in the relevant slice when admissiblea new signature or kind
support or dependency becomes unavailableunknown for an admissible requestnot-applicable or known false
publication form changesanother form or carrier may express the same epistemeanother signature, kind, or classification