C.36:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source or source family | Adopted FPF move | Rejected overread | Field or boundary used |
|---|---|---|---|
Brinkmann et al., Machine Culture, arXiv:2311.11388; DOI 10.1038/s41562-023-01742-2. | Treat intelligent systems as possible mediators or generators of cultural variation, transmission, and selection. | AI agents, recommenders, platforms, or toolchains are only external aids. | MediationSystemOrArchitectureRefs, recognition and selection regimes, transmission, memory, and canon refs stay visible in CulturalEvolutionCaseCard@Context. |
Czaplicka, Baumann, and Rahwan, algorithmic mediation and cumulative culture, arXiv:2410.00780; DOI 10.1098/rsif.2024.0686. | Recover platform or algorithmic mediation by identifying the mediating System or architecture, any local system-role classification or direct participation relation, the recognition or selection relation, the measurement or visibility relation, and the actual scope or model-use boundary. | platform regime becomes a root ontology or a mere publication label. | MediationSystemOrArchitectureRefs, SelectionOrRecognitionRegimeRefs, and ApplicablePatternRefs identify the needed rule before platform wording is used. |
Yaman, Tian, and Lindstrom, semantic knowledge and cultural evolution, arXiv:2510.12837; DOI 10.1073/pnas.2530750123. | Keep method families, work families, characteristic spaces, canon or memory epistemes, and recognition regimes explicit. | Culture is shared vocabulary, random variation alone, or a genre tree. | MethodFamilyRefs, WorkFamilyRefs, CanonOrMemoryEpistemeRefs, and CharacteristicSpaceRefs are required when semantic knowledge is the live claim. |
| Tchernichovski et al., editing constraints in cultural evolution, arXiv:2502.16694. | Treat editing constraints as constraints on variant sets, characteristic spaces, and effect measurement. | Style engineering is unconstrained idea generation or one scalar taste score. | VariantSetRefs, CharacteristicSpaceRefs, and measurement or refresh exits must be named when a style intervention targets constraints; any claim that constraints actually changed still cites its exact A.3.4 and Work-to-change basis. |
| Marjieh et al., cultural-evolution mechanisms in experimental social networks, arXiv:2502.12847. | Keep topology, selection, reproduction, social-learning, and mediation relations recoverable. | Cultural evolution is one isolated innovation channel. | CollectiveHolonRefs, local-kind and separate classification refs, any assignment-species and assignment-occurrence refs, SelectionOrRecognitionRegimeRefs, and mediation refs are kept together in the case card. |
| Lee et al., melody and rhythm coevolution, arXiv:2605.05982. | Allow several feature-specific characteristic spaces inside one style or tradition case. | A style label proves one monolithic trajectory. | CharacteristicSpaceRefs may carry several feature spaces before selected-set or bridge claims rely on the label. |
| Gautheron et al., popularity feedback in cultural markets, arXiv:2602.09997. | Keep popularity feedback, visibility, recognition, selection, and measurement relations explicit. | Popularity or platform metrics are neutral evidence of value. | SelectionOrRecognitionRegimeRefs, measurement refs, and ApplicablePatternRefs identify whether to use C.36, C.18, G.5, G.11, or an evidence pattern. |
Current QD and open-ended-engineering rows, including the 2026 Quality-Diversity survey DOI 10.1016/j.swevo.2025.102240. | Keep archives, fronts, current pools, selected-set result declaration, evaluator relations, generalization pressure, and refresh distinct from the cultural-evolution case. When publication is current, also keep the source-backed face and source return distinct from the publication occurrence and audience availability. | C.36 absorbs archive, front, pool, selected-set, publication, or refresh semantics. | Use C.18 for archive and front relations, C.19 for current-pool treatment, G.5 for selected-set result declaration, G.11 for currentness and refresh, E.17 for a source-backed publication face and return to source, and E.24.PUB for the publication occurrence, form, carrier, audience, bounded use, and availability. Use C.36 only for the cultural-evolution case. |
Source-use currentness. One row’s adopted move, rejected overread, and named field or boundary form the smallest source-use decision and stay current only until its cited edition changes, a materially newer cultural-evolution or algorithmic-mediation result challenges that transfer, the current QD/OEE line changes its archive, front, pool, selection, or refresh account, or a directly consumed FPF interface changes. At that trigger, recheck only the affected row and exact field or boundary; revise or withdraw an unsupported transfer and leave unrelated rows current.