Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-22 12:18:55 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-22 12:19:56 UTC · last check 2026-11-22 12:45:10 UTC

C.39.QR:4.1.1 - Recover what “all” covers

Use this move when taking all, every, always, never or a similar expression literally would change a decision. Echo the word as a question to yourself: “Every single one?” Try one plausible exception. Who or what would count, under what conditions, and what is claimed, asked or required of each? A membership rule can identify the domain without a list of names. Establish separately the property or action claimed of its members.

Read the utterance in context. A literal “everyone” can cover exactly the people already identified in the conversation. An emphatic “everyone knows” can express impatience or a wish to move on. Preserve that purpose. To skip an explanation on the strength of an audience’s knowledge, establish what the people who need to act already know. An explicit requirement holds on its agreed terms, including who owes an individual or a joint result and which exceptions it permits. A possible exception tests the reading. An established exception within the stated domain refutes a universal factual claim. An actual breach leaves the obligation in force under the governing terms.

For “at all levels”, recover what orders the levels in this question. Within any relevant kind of holon, part–whole relations can give scales of composition. A System and a Method each have their own. Control layers can be ordered by how one sets goals or constraints for decisions in another. Model abstraction compares what models admit for the same inquiry. Recover the relation the speaker uses and the ranges included, even if the field orders its levels in another way. Checking every immediate part of a whole can stay at one composition scale. Examining work at each of several scales can leave some parts unexamined. Recover whether the question asks what holds at each member, what carries between them or what they achieve together. “Each can use a method” can allow a different method for each. Promising one method usable by all adds a shared choice. Here the domain identifies the members. The logical scope of a quantifier identifies the part of the proposition it governs, including any choice made within it. Include combinations of ranges when the question or the organization of the work requires them.

Use the reading supported by the words, the agreed work and the situation. When several readings remain, give the answer they share if it suffices. If they lead to different decisions, state the difference or ask the speaker about the boundary that decides it. For a factual claim about every member, give an argument that covers the domain or adequate evidence covering each member. To determine what was promised to all, the authorized agreement can suffice. To judge feasibility, examine the promised work and its shared conditions. To report fulfilment, establish the outcomes the agreement calls for. Rhetorical emphasis gives no estimate of the proportion. For membership of a context slice in an FPF applicability scope, use A.2.6. The people, parts or models quantified over can vary within a single such slice.