E.13:2 - Problem
Typical failures include:
- Measures replace objectives. Teams speak as if the score, metric, benchmark, assurance level, or all-
5posture is the value. - Evaluation loops become reward functions. A checking reader asks for improvement; the author adds fields, guards, source rows, proof sketches, and relation catalogues until the visible evaluation looks better.
- Unmeasured value is damaged. Usability, safety margin, maintainability, learning, domain fit, affordability, or operator action quality gets worse while the proxy improves.
- Proxy use is not typed. The same metric is treated as orientation cue, target, incentive, gate, and release proof without saying which use is live.
- No value slice exists. The text claims practical payoff, but no minimally viable slice shows the value being realized in a case.