E.14:7 - Bias-Annotation (what to watch for, and the counter-moves)
| Bias (name) | Symptom in drafts | Conceptual counter-move | Where to check this |
|---|---|---|---|
| Formalism capture | Treating a constructive narrative as “the real thing,” with ut:*Of reduced to a label. | Re‑assert Working‑Model primacy: publish in ut:*Of; attach assurance downwards only when needed. | E.8 template; Notational‑Independence guard‑rail. |
| Canonical inversion | Demanding constructive grounding for epistemic links by default. | Keep the progressive stance: prefer Logical/Mapping assurance for knowledge claims; raise to Constructive only when structure is at issue. | Authoring template; Working‑Model pattern family. |
| Layer leakage (order and time) | Encoding sequence or phase as part-whole to “strengthen” claims. | Keep order and time in their own relation families; do not smuggle them into structure. | Temporal and ordering patterns. |
| Collection and composition swap | Using a collection’s belongs-to claim as if it implied ComponentOf, or treating a set narrative as the source of belonging. | Keep collection identity and belonging separate from integrated assembly; a C.13 account reports those facts and creates none of them. | Working-Model mereology guidance in Parts B and C. |
| Notation lock‑in | Letting a diagram or syntax define meaning. | Apply Notational Independence: explain interpretation and any operative use; mark illustrative renderings informative, and retain reasoning or construction steps under E.5.2. | Notational‑Independence guard‑rail. |
| Backwards dependency | Letting an assurance publication or record redefine public terms. | Preserve unidirectional dependence: Working-Model terms do not derive their meaning from assurance publications or records. | Part E guard‑rails (dependency discipline). |
| Silent assurance posture | A claim covered by an elected assurance profile omits the posture required by that profile. | Keep the readable claim first, then declare only the posture and support required for the covered use. A direct claim outside a profile needs no E.14 mode. | Applicable assurance profile; B.3.5 for CT2R-LOG. |
Reading reminder. Bias checks are conceptual reading aids; they never introduce notational or tooling mandates.