E.17.0:6 - Consequences
| Gain | Cost or boundary |
|---|---|
| Directly authored and derived views share one stable membership rule. | A contested view claim requires inspection of one exact viewpoint edition and its fixed rules. |
| One episteme can serve several viewpoints without duplicated view individuals. | Current-use selection must be kept separate from conformance. |
| Viewpoint catalogues package references without redefining viewpoint identity. | A self-contained new P must state its complete fixed test; the C/Q/S branch is justified only when separately versioned convention organization changes a named reuse, comparison, or maintenance action. |
| Multi-view structures and correspondences become inspectable. | A package or graph cannot substitute for collection, structure, or direct-relation recovery. |
| Publication and rendering can evolve independently of view identity. | Publication users must name the exact occurrence, form, and carrier when those distinctions affect work. |
Reopen the pattern when either conformance participant kind changes, the fixed predicate changes, or a proposed condition makes occurrence identity depend on an object other than E and P. Reopen a particular use when the candidate episteme, viewpoint edition, selected describing use, direct correspondence, or publication occurrence changes.