| Pillar essay. A review names Pillars without values or evidence. | Produce the complete E.2.DA result form. |
Local-quality averaging. Several E.21 values are averaged into FPF adequacy. | Re-evaluate Pillar effects over the FPF object. |
| Sterile or kind-changing precision cleanup. Language is admissible but no longer usable, or the trigger word is gone while the governed object kind, relation or claim kind, admissible use, or scope changed; this includes the current ontic slot, relation position, or use relation when part of the changed FPF-governed claim. | Lower P2, P6, and P7 and restore recognition reason, useful action, and pre-repair and post-repair kind evidence; if the current ontic slot, relation position, use relation, or claim kind changed without an accepted decision, treat the cleanup as a blocking semantic defect. |
| Ontic apparatus without FPF gain. A change adds ontic names, pattern-set maps, publication-boundary prose, or evaluation proof while duplicate ontology, entry confusion, or project-use difficulty remains. | Lower the affected Pillar coordinates; repair the governed object, slot-relation boundary, publication split, and user action, or decline the ontic candidate. |
| Projection authority. A ToC, packet, or companion independently defines or revises a durable pattern rule. | Place the authored definition, constraint, test, method instruction, or publication rule in its pattern body; preserve the source-linked public aid’s function under E.11. |
| Citation shelf. Source rows do not change FPF moves. | Lower P11 and state the missing source contribution. |
| Pillar table without evidence loci. Values are listed but not tied to corpus loci named by value. | Recover the needed evidence for Pillar coordinate | Value | ShortRationale | EvidenceLocus. Keep unsupported values as draft material until checked; lower a value only for a defect established under its coordinate meaning. |
| Goodharted Pillar adequacy. FPF-level values rise because more projection, source, review, or parity evidence was added, while entry recognition, layering, semantic authority, pragmatic utility, source use, or open-ended evolution becomes worse. | Reject apparatus-only improvement; apply E.13 when Pillar values become targets replacing Pillar realization; repair the FPF-level content effect, delete or relocate proof material, and record checked no-proposal only when no non-dominated Pillar-content improvement remains. |