Subject/action guidance reified or operationalized. Plain first-use guidance is turned into a SubjectActionSpine, structural field, method, CGUS, or performed work; or PrecisionRestorationProfile, process proof, or guard catalogues substitute for judgment of the pattern’s actual content. | Keep subject and action guidance Plain unless an exact admitted method or A.22.CGUS is genuinely current and cited by value; require dated U.Work independently when performance is claimed; judge the pattern’s own EntityOfConcern, first useful move, practitioner action, practical delta, and next useful action, adding a guard only when a plausible intended reader has an independently grounded reason for that reading. |
Score illusion. Pattern quality = 87 out of 100. | Use ordinal coordinate values; no arithmetic aggregation. |
| Two-column table. Coordinate-and-value table has no rationale. | Add ShortRationale for every coordinate. |
| Floor as omission. A floor evaluation omits maturity, SoTA, formal, corpus, or evolution coordinates. | Keep floor low if needed; evaluate all coordinates. |
Scope laundering. A landing-input, corpus-facing, Stable, release, or external-review request is reported under an easier use, local-only use, diagnostic pass, or evaluator-selected use. | Re-evaluate under the governing scope; if it fails, return repairBeforeUse, holdForArchitectureDecision, or refreshNeeded with the missed coordinates and repairs. |
| Administrative proxy. “4 because landed” or “3 because not externally reviewed”. | Evaluate pattern content. |
Currentness laundering. A registry entry, official publication date, maintained status, latest release, citation count, or fresh preprint is verified and then used to raise SoTABindingAndCurrentness. | Keep that evidence under traceability and the qualification window. Require one completed E.8:11 comparison and cap a currentness-only result below the ordinary floor. |
Comparator-free or locus-free maturity. MaturePatternParity... = 4 by impression, comparator IDs only, or category list such as “frame, first move, checklist, SoTA, relations”. | Name mature comparison patterns and use the maturity-discharge payload: comparator, selected ingredient, current locus, and missing or lowering item. Without that payload, cap at 3. |
| Omission account as maturity. A note explaining absence raises the value. | Add content to the body or neighboring pattern governing the claim, lower value, or mark the current request repairBeforeUse. |
| Semio-biased maturity. Non-semio pattern is judged by episteme or publication exemplars only. | Include non-epistemic mature comparators and score action on the primary EntityOfConcern. |
Quality-evidence leakage. Corpus projection, retrieval evidence, README, ToC, E.11 alignment, monolith parity, PatternQualityStatus, developer, reviewer, or executor correspondence, or other quality evidence is written anywhere in the pattern as method, problem, note, appendix, relation, rationale, or status content about the pattern. | Move the evidence to the E.21 result, E.19 run record, README, ToC, E.11, card, retrieval, projection, or release or landing evidence locus; keep only the user-facing action or boundary that the evidence justifies. |
Apparatus overwrap. A simple FPF claim is wrapped in extra role-word, publication-form, locus, flow, state, status, text-state, package, or process expressions, such as current pattern text, current object, active record, field used in the current pass, or route-like pattern talk where no real state or use relation is named, so the reader sees a bureaucratic apparatus instead of the object, relation, action, or boundary. | Apply F.19; record the scalar effect in PrecisionRestorationProfile, then lower the affected coordinates or name the completed repair. |
| Apparatus maximalism. Every pattern gets evidence cards, telemetry, archives, and companions. | Keep evidence compact unless it changes value, status, stop, or candidate comparison. |
| Quality veto theatre. “Not ready” has no E.21 coordinate named by value, evidence, status effect, and repair. | Rewrite as an E.21 finding or remove the veto. |