Library / First Principles Framework (FPF) - Core Conceptual Specification
Jump to passage
In this reading

Link to current text

Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-10-03 10:39:28 UTC · snapshot created 2026-10-03 10:40:04 UTC · last check 2026-10-03 11:40:09 UTC

E.4.PFR:6 - Conformance Checklist

CheckPassing condition
CC-PFR.1 Assertion firstEvery load-bearing claim has an exact subject, relation function, defining or constraining ClaimGraph, polarity, and current basis; a PFR row is optional.
CC-PFR.2 Named row receiverEvery row names a framework-maintenance, impact, comparison, repair, or refresh use that changes action; otherwise delete the row and retain the assertion.
CC-PFR.2a Smallest receiver formA cross-relation consumer uses the generic PFR row; a dependency-impact or refresh consumer uses the dependency-specific record. Both forms appear only when one named receiver needs both, cite the same subject assertion, link explicitly, derive overlapping values from that assertion, and share one refresh rule.
CC-PFR.3 No owner fieldNo generic subject-pattern relation, owner field, pattern agency, authority, receiver, or destination is asserted.
CC-PFR.4 Function before labelRelation function is selected by what the claim does, not by word similarity, adjacency, table position, or graph direction.
CC-PFR.5 Dependency separatedFramework-edition dependency remains separate from compatibility, specialization, publication, recommendation, preservation, derivation, and evaluation.
CC-PFR.5a One direct dependency per recordEach FrameworkEditionDependencyRecord names one dependent edition, one relied-on edition, and that dependency’s content refs, use, direction, reason, and refresh conditions together. Several dependencies use separate or keyed records; any aggregate is a derived projection, never parallel lists or a second maintained truth.
CC-PFR.5b Dependency predicate recoverableEach positive dependency assertion names the dependent edition, relied-on edition, exact relied-on content, named use, and the case fact that makes the content required: removing it or relevantly changing it invalidates the dependent content/result or reopens the use. The assertion and any record cite the E.4.PFR:3.4 predicate.
CC-PFR.6 Stable directionE.5.3 constrains allowed dependency direction and Core acyclicity only after dependency is identified; it cannot establish the relation. G.11 supplies currentness and refresh only.
CC-PFR.7 Compatibility independentA positive compatibility claim names the exact pair, overlapping use, difference or interface, impact, and reopen condition. Insufficient basis yields no positive compatibility claim.
CC-PFR.7a Optional link onlyA dependency record cites compatibilityClaimRefs only for a named maintenance consumer and only after the pairwise compatibility assertion exists independently; the ref creates neither claim.
CC-PFR.8 Carrier meanings preservedPublication, access, preservation, admission, source, Work/tool, evidence, assurance, and currentness claims keep their exact patterns and identities.
CC-PFR.9 Actual-use truthderivedUsingRuleContent or evaluatedAgainstRuleContent cites the exact actual-use claim and satisfies its strict truth condition.
CC-PFR.10 Analysis thresholdCandidate-family analysis exists only for a named comparison, replay, same-subject conflict, or reliance receiver and includes only candidates, axes, pairs, conflicts, and receiving-edition distinctions whose resolution can change the exact cell disposition or named receiver action.
CC-PFR.11 Analysis closureThe candidate universe, contract-required axes, candidate establishment results, required pairwise results, temporal cells and established family determine exactly one §3.6 disposition. Any false required axis defeats a candidate despite other unknowns; optional minimality remains separate. Recompute the affected results together when their cell disposition or named receiver action can change, using the exact RuleContentBasisFamilyAlgebra declaration edition.
CC-PFR.12 Non-permissive boundaryA basis answer supplies no authority, permission, gate passage, Work, actual use, evidence, assurance, or reliance by implication.