Problem frame | Evaluated object kind, declared use, working reader, qualification window, first useful evaluation use, FPF-publication boundary, what goes wrong without this evaluation, and what practical move the evaluation enables. |
Problem | Failure modes that the evaluation prevents: wrong-kind scoring, hidden value drift, proxy value, one-score collapse, missingness confusion, or neighbour theft. |
Forces | Tensions among reuse, coordinate count, readability, measurement admissibility, trade-off protection, local stop, and open-ended improvement. |
Solution | Every required accepted-specification value and every triggered optional value: object and use, reader and qualification limits, cases and kind-fit, coordinate and scale bindings, value meanings and preferred movement, evidence and missingness, result form and calibration, coordinate-specific evidence, trade-offs and comparison, statuses, exits, and stop or reopen conditions. |
Archetypal Grounding | At least one passing evaluated object, one below-floor evaluated object, and one outside-declared-object-kind boundary case. |
Bias-Annotation | Known skew in source examples, reader family, domain tradition, measurement preference, benchmark preference, or FPF-internal reuse. |
Conformance Checklist | Checks that the specification is recoverable, not that a reviewer likes the evaluated object. |
Common Anti-Patterns | Score-sheet pattern, checklist-as-solution, table-first recognition failure, neighbour theft, one total score, hidden value drift. |
Consequences | What changes in practice after a conforming evaluation use, its scope, next action, stop or reopen, and the concrete contribution supplied by neighbouring content for any outside claim. Add a denied consequence only when a plausible intended reader has an independent reason to infer it. |
Rationale | Why this coordinate set and publication-form are selected, including relation to A.19.ECS and existing evaluations named by value. |
SoTA-Echoing | Current practice that changes evaluated-object selection, coordinate choice, value meaning, missingness, comparison, or stop discipline. |
Relations | A.19.ECS, E.8, E.21, E.22, E.23, and exact domain or neighbour patterns. |