E.9.DA:4.5 - Local result status and stop condition
The following are local conclusions for the exact checked DRR, required authoring use, effective floor, and qualification window. They may be stated in an ordinary bounded result; a C.2.1 aggregate result episteme is needed only when a named later reliance needs that exact reusable object. They are not review decisions, gates, permissions, assurance levels, or work states.
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
admissibleForDeclaredAuthoringUse | Every required coordinate meets its effective floor, no architecture or split blocker remains, and the result states the first drafting action, stop or return, and reopen condition. Any downstream acceptance or authorization uses its own receiving relation. |
newFrameRequired | The DRR appears useful only for a different decision, authoring use, selected-locus set, source-use claim, or qualification window than the required one. This is not an admissible result for the current request; open a new E.22 frame or repair the DRR. |
repairBeforeDrafting | One or more required coordinates fall below their effective floors for the required authoring use. |
splitDecisionRequired | Several coupled questions need separate decision records or explicit convergence before the current result can be admissible. |
holdForArchitectureDecision | Content object, branch, neighbour boundary, selected locus, structural-view relation, missing-structure return condition, source-use relation, or publication split must be decided before adequacy can close. |
The status rule is noncompensatory. A strong value on one coordinate cannot offset another required coordinate below its effective floor. An unresolved architecture blocker yields holdForArchitectureDecision regardless of the other values; a required split yields splitDecisionRequired; an easier or different use yields newFrameRequired. Otherwise any below-floor required coordinate yields repairBeforeDrafting. State the required-use source, effective floor, and floor source in either result form so another evaluator can reproduce the conclusion. A missing or unchecked basis does not establish a below-floor value. Complete the needed check before deriving a conclusion that depends on it; an unestablished required value cannot support admissibleForDeclaredAuthoringUse. Independently established architecture, split or below-floor findings remain usable.
A result carrying admissibleForDeclaredAuthoringUse states the first drafting action, stop or return, and reopen condition. A non-ready result states the first repair, split boundary, or architecture question. Add a non-admissible reading only when an independent local ground makes it plausible and action-changing; any later gate or authorization uses a separately defined receiving relation.