FDM-E1 — A score is presented as a financial benefit
- Situation: A better score is reported as a benefit to a borrower, but the financial change is unclear.
- Question: What did the service change for this participant, and what remains unresolved?
- First useful result or blocker: A supported contribution to the participant’s result, an unchanged financial outcome, or a missing term or event.
- Start with: FDM.5 to examine how the service was used. Use a position or event method if the claimed change depends on a question still open.
- Stop or return: Report the established contribution and any material limit. Reconsider a term, occurrence or link to the participant’s outcome when the conclusion depends on it.
A scoring team improves the accuracy of its output and wants to explain the benefit to a borrower. Use FDM.5 to identify how the score affects the decision. If the applicable rule gives this borrower the same decision and terms at both scores, the gain in accuracy produces no difference through that route. That can answer the question. A claim that the borrower spent less time supplying information requires its own comparison.
Suppose an authorized decision maker uses the new score and changes a lending decision. Use FDM.1 to identify any rights and obligations created under the applicable terms. If the lender’s or borrower’s identity is disputed, use FDM.2 to resolve it. The agreement’s formation conditions determine which duties already exist before funding. To establish whether the funds are usable, follow the funding event.
In this example a valid agreement provides that successful funding of 100 creates a position with 105 due on day 30. Use FDM.3 to derive the contractual flows for each party and FDM.4 to determine what occurred and what it changed. Suppose 60 was paid and applied in full to the amount due, with no further interest or fees. The remaining obligation is 45. Reconcile a record showing 105 unpaid with that effect. The original contractual amount remains 105. If the evidence establishes only an instruction to pay 60, the payment and its effect remain open.
Use FDM.5 to explain what the financial service supplied. Funding may make the agreed proceeds usable even if the equipment bought with them never arrives. Report the funding and the failed delivery in their respective scopes. A later business benefit requires evidence that the financed work produced it.
For unclear terms, use FDM.1 or FDM.3. For a disputed occurrence, use FDM.4. For a gap between the service output and the participant’s result, use FDM.5. In each case, apply a sufficient existing result directly.