FIN.23:4.3 - Design the internal terms and the allocation of benefit and loss
Apply FIN.10 to the actual participants. For the internal lender, compare lending with retaining the cash or placing it externally on attainable terms. For the borrower, compare the internal loan with feasible external funding or a changed operating plan. Include required liquidity, expected loss and costs, not just interest. The internal price allocates benefit between members; an internal interest payment does not by itself increase the whole group’s external resources. Tax and other real effects can prevent cancellation and need their own supported treatment.
An internal loan needs a supportable amount, service dates, currency, rank, terms for early repayment or recall, and consequences if repayment fails. If the lender needs withdrawal on demand while the borrower can repay only after a long investment, identify the party and committed capacity carrying that mismatch. Compare a smaller loan, a longer commitment, external backup or equity participation. A transfer described as a loan but lacking a credible repayment route reopens the form and amount, as well as any required accounting or tax classification.
A guarantee needs a separate account of the guarantor. Calculate when it could have to pay while meeting its own obligations; follow any reimbursement claim and avoid counting its recovery twice. A guarantee payable after default may help the lender but fail to provide the borrower’s earlier payroll cash. Correlated deterioration can make both borrower and guarantor weak at the same time. An assessed fee or an owner instruction supplies no missing capacity. Compare a limited amount, different trigger, funded reserve or direct capital contribution when those alter the failing condition.
For cash pooling, distinguish a service that transfers balances and creates internal positions from a bank service that calculates interest across accounts without transferring their balances. Determine the draw, set-off, guarantee, membership and exit terms that apply. Derive the requests members may make alone and together, and identify who can direct the money and by when. To promise access, show how treasury can respond to each permitted demand with the information it will have before an irreversible allocation. A shared limit large enough for a single request can still fail if funds must be placed in a particular account before the requester is known. Provide a response to persistent balances and entry or exit of a member; a short-term liquidity service should not silently become uncommitted long-term funding. Keep the local forecasting and spending incentives in view through FIN.19 and FIN.20.
When related-party pricing or tax treatment matters, obtain the applicable treatment for the specified transactions and functions. A financially acceptable division of savings is not by itself an arm’s-length or tax conclusion. Equally, a tax-acceptable price does not establish service capacity or a worthwhile financial arrangement.