FIN.23:4.4 - Follow ordinary cash and failure through the whole arrangement
When the decision depends on both entity and group consequences, connect the two views. For each affected entity, carry the cash, claims and contingent support that can affect its position at the required dates. A bound on cash available to the payer can settle a specific payment question before full reconciliation. In the group view, eliminate internal transfers once and retain external service, costs, taxes and economic consequences. The two views answer different questions and must reconcile. An internal debt eliminated in consolidation still has to be serviced or validly changed between the entities.
Test where a loss or delay stops and where it propagates. Follow restrictions on upstream cash, access to pledged assets, guarantees, cross-default or acceleration terms and loss of common bank capacity only as their actual agreements provide. A lender to the parent may depend on value reaching it after subsidiary creditors have been satisfied; direct lending or a guarantee can create a different claim. While rank or enforceability is unsettled, you can calculate recoveries under the competing assumptions. To rely on one as legally applicable, establish which claims and priorities are enforceable. The label “ring-fenced” is insufficient when another commitment reconnects the exposures.
Stress causes shared by several members as well as a local failure: the same customer, currency movement, collateral decline or bank withdrawal can damage more than one route. A backstop should be available in the state where it is needed. Do not both lend a subsidiary’s entire surplus and count that same money as available to meet its guarantee. Compare the group gain with effects on each materially affected participant. A design can lower group cost yet require changed terms or consent because it worsens one entity’s position.