FIN.23:5.1 - Change the location of a claim, not merely a reported ratio
In a separate simplified recovery case, parent P owns all of subsidiary S. S has assets realizing 80 and existing external claims of 60; P has no other asset and owes 30 externally. The stipulated ranking pays S’s creditors before distributing the residual to P, with no taxes or process costs. S’s creditors receive 60, P receives 20, and P’s creditor recovers only 20 of its 30. Group assets of 80 and debt of 90 do not tell that creditor’s answer.
For comparison, suppose the new 30 had instead been borrowed directly by S and ranked equally with the existing 60 against that same 80. The stipulated pro-rata recovery would be 30/90 × 80 = 26.67 for the new lender and 53.33 for the existing creditors. Location and rank have changed the distribution. The existing creditors’ worse recovery is a reason to inspect their restrictions and required consent, not an available free benefit to P. A guarantee or security package would require its own claim and recovery construction.