PROBLEM-SHAPING — Stop at the earliest useful problem-side result
- Situation: Something matters, but the team may have only signals worth preserving, a direction for inquiry, a question about competing explanations, or enough clarity to accept a problem statement.
- Question: What can the available material support now: preserved signals, a routed direction for inquiry, an explicit question that contrasts possible explanations, or a problem statement ready for acceptance?
- First useful result or blocker: A preserved set of signals, a clear inquiry route, a question about plausible explanations, an accepted problem statement, or the missing anchor, route, subject, constraint, or acceptance basis.
- Mantra: Keep what was noticed before declaring a problem. Route the inquiry only when the signal has a stable anchor. Ask about explanations only when the open question and contrast are clear. Accept a problem statement only when the subject, constraints, unresolved relations, important distinctions, and basis can be stated. Stop at the earliest useful truth; return when its basis changes.
- Start with:
A.16.1for a cue pack,B.4.1for routed cues,B.5.2.0for an abductive prompt, andC.22.2for an acceptedProblemCard. - Stop or return: Do not force a cue into a problem. Open
C.22.PFRonly when whether the adverse relation obtains changes the next use.