Library.Reference:6.5.3.5 - Learning through work and changing collective activity
Learning approaches differ in what they develop and how that development reaches action. Begin with the contribution needed in subsequent work. A person may need a new distinction; practitioners may need an intelligible shared way; a group may need to investigate a problem it can act on; or the conditions of participation may prevent useful inquiry. Identify which agent can use the result of that development and what it enables the agent to do. One undertaking can require several of these contributions.
Develop a person’s use of experience. Kolb and Kolb’s 2018 clarification connects experience, reflection, conceptualization and experimentation while allowing different entry points and sequences. Facilitation, subject explanation, standards and coaching serve different learning needs. Select their contributions from the learner, subject and intended performance. A written plan for future experimentation can support reflection; its subsequent execution needs a later observation.
HCD.15:4.2.1 supplies a useful start from successful work: recover the action and help, compare the person’s explanation with a serious alternative, and retain a bounded lesson or select the next practice. HCD.9 connects feedback to another attempt; HCD.12 distinguishes use under a meaningful change from learning with a newly supplied source. Keep a sufficient explanation and action when no worthwhile learning question remains.
Develop a question participants can investigate together. Senge, Hamilton and Kania connect seeing wider relationships, examining assumptions through conversation and forming a shared direction. Their methodological account uses mapping, encounters with other practice settings and inquiry to develop these capacities. Select a tool for the relationship it helps participants examine and for the action that understanding can change.
CB.4 supplies preparation, access, facilitation and the return from a shared encounter. Where participants need to learn the reasoning, HCD.23 has them explain a consequential connection, compare its grounds and use it themselves. Where the result needed is a joint proposal, §6.5.3.8 returns its unresolved contributions and commitments to LDR and GOALS. An adequate existing answer can instead finish the inquiry.
Make practical knowledge usable beyond its first holder. The Nonaka–Toyama–Konno account of SECI and ba relates shared experience, articulation, combination of explicit accounts and learning through use. In ba, the shared context, participants interpret contributions and act together. Its individual, group and organizational scales describe expansion of knowledge creation. Control levels still require the relationships in §6.5.2. Nonaka and Takeuchi’s later treatment keeps knowledge creation connected to practical action.
Choose what is missing in the receiving practice. A demonstration can expose the practitioner’s choice. For joint work, identify the contributions and what makes them one result. That link can be another participant’s use of a finding or an agreed rule combining independent assessments. When the order is to develop the practice itself, establish who selected that connection and why it applies to the intended uses. An explanation can make it available to an absent practitioner; subsequent use can expose a missing condition or a defective way. CB.14 develops this connection from contrasting cases through a qualified method contribution, trial, receiving use and maintenance. A ready answer can finish one case. To settle a repertoire question, establish which intended uses can be served by the available answer and its conditions. An account’s availability and a person’s ability to use it require different observations. KCS in §6.5.3.7 develops the corresponding connections within service work.
Join inquiry to a real action and a learning return. WIAL’s action-learning account starts with a significant problem for which a group is responsible and able to act; a coach helps it learn through inquiry and action. The INTRAC set guide also supports successive individual cases: questions help the owner choose an action within their influence, and later meetings return what happened. Choose the variant from the problem owner and capacity to act.
Recover the problem with the people who have relevant experience and examine the assumptions that could change the choice. The responsible owner or group selects an action, obtains its necessary permission and means, and returns consequences to the unresolved question. CB.5 supplies a case owner’s reasoned continuation and the response to contributed help. A useful conversation can finish at a clarified question when action is not yet obtainable; its learning claim must retain that limit. Use the selected source protocol where its particular question, advice and participation rules matter.
The participants can also improve the encounter itself. Cauwelier’s 2023 WIAL guidance moves from repeated reminders about questioning to the group’s examination of why and how it communicates. This can change facilitation or a shared practice rule. The next encounter supplies an opportunity to observe that change. Reconsidering the premises that govern work is a further possible subject:
In Argyris’s Double Loop Learning in Organizations, participants can correct action while retaining its governing premises, or investigate premises that reproduce the problem. The latter move requires discovering norms actually used, making disputed assumptions testable in joint inquiry and changing subsequent action. A declared value can differ from the value governing decisions. Defensive interaction can prevent the inquiry from changing what happens. The result must return to the relationship between the situation and action. Single- and double-loop learning distinguish what is reconsidered and made effective; they do not establish two jobs.
In expansive learning, the object of collective activity and the way of working together can change. Participants encounter contradictions, examine the existing arrangement, model and test a new one, change practice and examine consequences. Tools, rules, division of labour and interaction with neighbouring activity can change together. The aim of the transformation can itself emerge in the work.
Engeström and Sannino, 2010, pages 6–8 identify the ideal cycle as a conceptual heuristic. It helps investigate formation of the object and transformation of practice. A claim about a particular controller still requires showing who selects and implements which changes in that realization. The source’s action/activity distinction supplies levels of analysis; it does not establish a universal seven-stage control prescription.
Let joint inquiry change the problem being investigated. In Restrepo and colleagues’ collaborative-learning account, the participants, their criteria and the working question develop together. The intended users’ different practices can expose a missing condition in the researcher’s initial problem. Dialogue informs discovery through observation, trials or scenarios; application then tests the proposed way in the participants’ circumstances and can reveal missing skills or poor fit. These relationships can recur as the collaboration develops.
CB.14:4.2 and :5.5 explain this contribution within joint practice development. The farming case changes a comparison of feeding practices after recovering differences in available labour and fodder. It follows that change through the professional study contribution, receiving guidance and a grant condition that can prevent the revised question from being pursued. CB.13 supplies the shared decision arrangement; OCE.14 supplies revision of an established organizational relation where that is the missing contribution.
The authors’ Kenyan dairy-project explanation, p.2, describes farmers with defined roles in decisions, comparison of how they regulate milk production and quality, video proposals for action funds, and peer exchange and experiments. That realization shows how a question participants can shape reaches a trial they can perform.
Romme and van Witteloostuijn’s Endenburg case describes policy decisions linked across circles by a leader and elected representative, with information access and ordinary execution retained. Selecting this arrangement elsewhere requires comparison with the actual decision work and participation conditions. Johannessen and colleagues’ urban-water cases connect learning with trusted exchange, capable intermediaries and institutional support, while reporting incomplete or temporary wider change. A local learning result therefore needs its own connection to any claimed continuing organizational result.
The term triple-loop learning requires a source-specific reading. Tosey, Visser and Saunders distinguish accounts concerned with higher governing purposes, reflection on how learning occurs, and Bateson’s more radical change of learning premises. These have different objects and proposed relations. Identify the proposed change and its means; the label supplies neither an implementation nor a universal third control level.
For example, two teams may already solve their respective cases but lack an account that lets a receiving team recognize a consequential difference. CB.14 can obtain that account and try its use. If a practitioner can recover the account but cannot yet apply the distinction, select supported practice. If the teams understand the distinction but lack permission to act, identify the authority the action requires. Seek a decision from its holder when the mandate is established. If the mandate is unclear or no one holds it, report that limit and keep the action conditional. The same eventual work result can depend on different repairs. An available explanation or direct authorized response may suffice; a recurring learning group is useful only when its continuing contribution warrants the work.