Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-16 21:18:08 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-16 21:19:40 UTC · last check 2026-11-17 19:35:15 UTC

MDPE.30:5 - Archetypal Grounding

Toussaint supplies the rhythmic and action constructions. The receiving constraints, choices and rehearsal outcomes below are stipulated to show how a change of musical purpose affects the part.

MDPE.30:5.1 - Generate the small seed and choose its phase

An ensemble wants three audible attacks in a repeating eight-pulse span. Its pulse 0 is fixed by the accompaniment. Another instrument has a cue at pulse 6, where this new part should remain audibly silent. The percussionist has a low-sounding instrument for the right hand and a contrasting high-sounding instrument for the left. The first musical question is whether a two-cycle timbral exchange works with the accompaniment.

Use x for an audible onset and . for a silent pulse. For this specific seed, begin with three onset columns and five silent pulses. Give each onset one silent pulse, leaving two; append the remaining two to the first two columns. Read each column downwards and concatenate:

initial groups:       [x]   [x]   [x]     remaining: . . . . .
after first sharing:  [x .] [x .] [x .]   remaining: . .
after second sharing: [x . .] [x . .] [x .]
concatenated:         x . . x . . x .
positions:            0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

The onsets are 0, 3 and 6. Their cyclic gaps are 3, 3 and 2, including the return from 6 to the next cycle’s 0. The three gaps differ by at most one pulse. For other onset and pulse counts, use the repeated-distribution algorithm in chapter 21 or an already established seed. The two sharing steps here derive this particular pattern.

The seed strikes at 6, where the other instrument needs a clear cue. Advance every onset by two pulses modulo 8. Positions 0, 3 and 6 become 2, 5 and 0. In cycle order they are 0, 2 and 5, with gaps 2, 3 and 3. The attack count and cyclic spacing are preserved, while both placements have an attack at the fixed origin and only the shifted placement leaves pulse 6 silent. The unchanged accompaniment makes the two placements musically distinct.

MDPE.30:5.2 - Turn the onsets into actual hand and sound parts

First alternate hands on audible attacks only. Start with the right hand and continue across the cycle boundary. After three strokes the next cycle begins with the left hand.

Eight-pulse spanPulse 01234567
First cycleR.L..R..
Second cycleL.R..L..

R and L are audible strokes on different instruments in this example. The unlabelled onsets repeat after eight pulses. The hand and timbre assignments repeat after sixteen, with right-hand attacks at 0, 5 and 10 and left-hand attacks at 2, 8 and 13. If both hands produced indistinguishable sounds, the onsets could still repeat after eight while the hand assignments took sixteen.

The ensemble compares the alternating sounds with playing all three attacks on one sound. For these musicians that option requires less coordination and preserves onset timing, while the alternating sounds give an exchange across two cycles. In the stipulated rehearsal the percussionist plays the alternating-attack version at 72 pulses per minute with the audible reference, and the partner reports hearing the cue at 6 clearly. The ensemble selects it for the next rehearsal under those conditions.

MDPE.30:5.3 - Change the receiving condition without confusing the two action rules

The revised accompaniment now needs the low right-hand sound at pulse 0 of every eight-pulse cycle. Continuous alternation on three audible attacks gives the left hand that pulse on alternate cycles. To put the right hand on that entry every cycle, change the action rule or arrangement. If only the low sound matters, a different instrument assignment may suffice. Practising the same arrangement cannot change its predicted first hand.

Compare a second action rule from chapter 32. Alternate the hands on every pulse, including silent motions, and sound only positions 0, 2 and 5. Capitals below mean audible strokes; lowercase letters mean the indicated hand moves without an audible attack, stopping short or using an appropriately silent motion.

pulse:   0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
motion:  R l R l r L r l
sound:   x . x . . x . .

Eight pulse-wise motions return the hands to their original allocation. The first two audible attacks are right-hand strokes and the last is left-hand, the smooth-toggle seed of chapter 32. The onsets and silence at 6 remain. This version calls for eight alternating motions per cycle, three of them sounded. Silent positions still require their specified motions. Whether that organization helps a performer depends on their technique and the conditions.

In this constructed rehearsal the percussionist initially sounds an unintended stroke at 4. The ensemble slows the passage to separate audible from silent motions, then restores the original tempo and accompaniment. The performer now supplies the required sounds and entry. The ensemble chooses this version for that arrangement and retains the two-cycle version for its earlier use. If the needed silent motion remains out of reach in the preparation time, consider another playable allocation or a change in instrument, entry condition or rehearsal provision.

MDPE.30:5.4 - Extend the phrase while preserving a chosen action relation

Suppose a later arrangement requires twelve pulses, a right-hand block followed by a left-hand block, and three pulses at both block transitions. Stretching all old times by 1.5 would put the old onset at 5 on 7.5, between grid points. Appending four silent pulses would extend the cyclic gap from the last attack to the next first attack. Neither operation preserves the required relations.

Use chapter 32’s splice instead. Cut the eight-pulse motion after position 3. Copy its four-pulse transition segment at original positions 2–5, then insert that copy between the two halves:

first half       inserted transition    second half
R l R l          R l r L                r L r l

new positions:   0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
new motion:      R l R l R l r L r L r  l

The right-hand attacks are at 0, 2 and 4, the left-hand attacks at 7 and 9. Their cyclic gaps are 2, 2, 3, 2 and 3. The new span has five attacks in twelve pulses. The two hand blocks and their three-pulse transitions remain, and inserting four pulses preserves the alternation of the shifted motions. Other musical or perceived properties require their own comparison.

For the revised twelve-pulse accompaniment, compare the constructed part with its required landmarks. If that score is the commission, the entries, action allocation and transition gaps can settle it. If the accompaniment still demands the eight-pulse return, keep the suitable earlier part or reconsider the joint arrangement. For a question about the performed transition, effort or entry, use relevant performance evidence. If it is insufficient, a feasible trial may supply the needed observation; otherwise give the supported result and its limit.