ME.12:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source | Adopted or adapted contribution | Boundary and practitioner implication |
|---|---|---|
| Ralyté, Koutsopoulos, and Stirna, verification, validation, and evaluation of modeling methods | Keep verification, validation, and evaluation questions separate and use evidence to locate the claim under check. | The source is modeling-Method focused and does not supply one universal FPF owner map or prove practical worth. |
| ISO/IEC/IEEE 24774:2021 | Use description elements, rules, views, and declared description-side conformance as selectable comparison bases. | The standard does not make description conformance a Method admission, fit, or performance result and is not imported as FPF ontology. |
| Cash, Daalhuizen, and Hekkert, method efficacy and effectiveness | Preserve the difference between internal or use-side adequacy questions and practical effect questions. | The contribution does not supply a universal coherence score or make one successful occurrence decisive. |
Current FPF A.3.1, A.10, C.2.1, E.17.0, A.22, and the direct governors cited by the maintained claim | Reuse Method admission, claim-bound evidence, episteme and edition identity, view conformance, structure selection, and direct predicate tests. | ME.12 contributes owner-specific comparison and correction routing; it does not redefine those identities or predicates. |
Reopen the pattern when practitioners cannot identify one maintained owner without changing the architecture, when repeated findings require a distinct independent coherence problem, when a source supplies a stronger owner-discrimination method, or when a governing FPF predicate changes the repair route.