ME.15:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source | Adopted or adapted contribution | Boundary and practitioner implication |
|---|---|---|
| Schønheyder and Nordby, design-Method use and evolution in professional practice | Adopt cyclic evolution, project demands, practitioner skill sets, organization, and observed adaptation as inputs to variant and applicability maintenance. | One multidisciplinary design firm supplies neither a universal variant taxonomy nor independent admission or causal effect. |
| Faludi, Yiu, and Agogino, empirical tests of sustainable-design Methods | Adopt activity- and mindset-level observations across three Methods and industries as evidence that can motivate bounded branch or recombination questions. | Immediate self-report does not establish long-term results, hybrid-Method admission, or the worth of recombined variants. |
| Gericke et al., method ecosystems, and Stacey et al., Methods as engineering knowledge | Adopt maintained Method ecology, content, representation, use, and change questions for the repertoire account. | Position and knowledge contributions do not show that one repository, support stack, or variant organization works universally. |
| Gray, Chivukula, and Asad, Toward an Architectural Model of Design Methods | Adapt the question of which epistemic commitments a derived method preserves or loses into the concrete inclusion and decision-rule comparison in §5.2. | This initial architectural sketch motivates that comparison; it does not determine FPF Method identity or establish the candidate’s effectiveness. The example is a Method Engineering construction. |
Current FPF A.3.1, A.3.1.MR, C.2.1, A.10, G.5, G.11, and A.19 selected-set semantics | Reuse Method admission, candidate recovery, edition identity, evidence use, registered Method-family candidate sets, and non-forced selection. ME.15 itself records local source, evidence, situation, qualification-window, defeating-evidence, and retirement claims. Invoke G.11 only when the entry participates in a G.11-admitted shipped pack, evidence or selected set, archive or front, publication/currentness object, dependency on a reused A.6.RCD predicate definition or derived relation kind, or another condition named by G.11. | ME.15 contributes Method-variant semantic classification, derivation, applicability, and local maintenance. It neither redefines those governors nor turns every repertoire-entry currentness or retirement question into refresh orchestration. |
Reopen the pattern when practitioners cannot distinguish reusable semantic change from local Work or support change, when a mature source supplies a stronger variant identity and retirement method, when a new case demonstrates an independently useful lineage problem not covered here, or when current FPF Method and repertoire semantics change the result.