ME.4:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source | Retained contribution | Use boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Daalhuizen and Cash, Method Content Theory | Goal, procedure, rationale, framing, and mindset as questions that prevent procedure-only recovery. | Static content variables and initial study population do not define FPF kinds, Method parts, or cross-domain effectiveness. |
| Gericke, Eckert, and Stacey, Elements of a design method | Core idea, representation, procedure, intended use, tool, ecosystem, and adaptation prompts. | Source elements remain questions and source claims, not a universal dossier ontology. |
| Stacey et al., Methods as a form of engineering knowledge | Current comparison of engineering-Method knowledge and the placement of representations, framing, and rationale. | Conceptual comparison supplies no project Method identity or package parthood. |
Current FPF A.3.1, A.3.2, B.1.5, and F.18 | Method identity, MethodDescription membership, composition law, and name recovery. | The DPF adds the decision-bounded dossier and dependency-slice Method. |
Reopen when a current source or package case exposes a decision-bearing contribution that cannot retain its kind, provenance, role, and relation in the open dossier; when a source profile hides material receiving conditions; or when the ordinary one-package result acquires burden that its use does not need.