NSTD.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Schmid’s Narratology: An Introduction distinguishes happenings, story, narrative and presentation. Chihaia’s survey of narratology introductions shows differences of tradition and audience. These are historical conceptual anchors. Gatt and Krahmer’s NLG survey distinguishes content selection from text structuring and realization. Cardona Rivera, Jhala, Porteous and Young’s The Story So Far on Narrative Planning examines plan-based construction and communication of stories. This pattern synthesizes those distinctions into an ordering method; it does not require a formal plan for every account.
Operational payload:
- From Schmid, distinguish selection, composition and linearization. Well-chosen material may still be ordered badly, so compare
NSTD.2ordering separately fromNSTD.1selection. - From Chihaia, interpret terms such as plot, discourse or fabula within the tradition using them. Explain the ordering consequence when different traditions use a term differently.
- From NLG, distinguish what to say from how to order and express it. Inspect the needed content when fluent realization leaves the reader’s reconstruction incomplete.
- From narrative planning, distinguish the order of events from their presentation. Mark a divergence when it could mislead the reader about causality or dependency.
- For an architecture explanation, compare the account with the relevant structures and views. Use
C.30.ASV,C.33orC.34only for the architecture question each defines.
For a short explanation whose reader must distinguish event order from cause or prerequisite, the best-supported line here is to keep those relations available while choosing the presentation order. The serious default is to preserve source order and improve only the prose. Compare two equally short accounts of the incident in the Readme: both retain the logged times, but the relation-aware account leaves the causal investigation open. Source order alone cannot expose that difference; the added comparison is justified by the reader’s remedy decision, not by a preference for more elaborate planning.
Adapt the distinction between content, structure and realization from NLG, and between events and their communication from narrative planning, in :4’s short-sequence comparison. Reject a required formal plan for an ordinary account: its cost is unnecessary when a few relations can be compared directly. For suspense or aesthetic rhythm, accept a different order when its effect matters and the needed relation remains available. Reopen this choice if a changed reader task requires another relation, if a reader repeatedly reconstructs the wrong order, or if an equally economical alternative preserves those relations more clearly.