NSTD.9:4.3 - Compare interpretations at the consequential difference
Compare a plausible alternative when it changes the conclusion or its use. Another participant, a detail the preferred account cannot explain, a different possible cause or a different framing may supply it. Use an adequate reading directly when the alternatives add nothing material.
Read the same material under each account. Which details does it explain, what does it leave out and what assumptions does it need? Ask how the whole affects the reading of each part and whether independent details support the whole. If an account of betrayal supplies the intention behind a delayed reply, the delay cannot independently establish that intention.
For a factual disagreement, compare the claims with relevant observations or subject findings. Seek a missing observation when a stronger answer matters and it can distinguish the claims. For different meanings of a shared occurrence, explain the concerns and grounds of each participant. For a textual interpretation, examine the wording, narrative position, repetition, contrasts and what the account has made available to that point. If the claim concerns what a particular reader knew or understood, use evidence about that reading. Leave factual questions open where the evidence ends.