NSTD.9:4.4 - Decide what to resolve and what to preserve
Select a single reading when its support is sufficient for the question. Retain several when the material supports each and their difference matters. Distinguish a missing fact, several supported readings and a set of proposals with too little evidence to use. The first may call for an observation, the second for a range of interpretations and the third for reporting a limit or reconsidering the proposals.
A literary passage may leave motive open while making the action clear. Identify the cues for any supported reading and the consequences of that reading. When composing an open scene, check that its intended alternatives are genuinely available. When interpreting someone else’s text, attribute that openness to authorial intention only when there is evidence for the attribution.
For a factual account, retain the uncertainty that matters to its use. New evidence can decide what happened while leaving differences in its significance intact. A participant’s account may already answer what they said about their experience or position. Use the relevant D.1–D.5 contribution when the task calls for a judgement of value, harm or consequences for an affected party that remains to be made.